That depends on the kind of person you are.
If you love ballsy fun, great action, and unprecedented creativity, go with Saints Row 3.
If you just want to shoot things in the face, go with Saints Row 3.
If you want to be a complete dick to everything you find, go with Saints Row 3.
If you're just a boring fucking sheep who buys whatever's the hottest series filled with brown and gray to trash talk other douchebags through mikes and teabag people's corpses, get an actually fun game like Saints Row 3.
Hrm, I guess it doesn't really depend on the kind of person you are. Either you'll love it from the get go or you need it to stop being a dick. In any event Saints Row 3.