Poll: Smith or Tennant? (Or Eccleston)

[Jedamethis]

Awww, cute little kitty. *pets*

You mean Planet Catboy, or it's sister planet, Catgirl Lovers?

D: Noooooo!
*looks away for a second*
Awwww, what a cute kitty you are.

This is ... weird!
Cat-Dalek-Girls?!
Crazy Doctor Who fans! Crazy cat-people!

Yup. Us crazy people.

 

[Trull]

I read this on a different forum/tumblr maybe.

Tom Baker is the best doctor, David Tennant is my doctor, and Matt Smith is my favourite doctor

 

[imnot]

I like them all, but Matt wins just because of his fantastic dress scence.

 

[illas]

They got rid of Rose during Tennant, and introduced the Weeping Angels. On the other hand, they introduced Jesus Tinkerbell Doctor. During Smith, they brought the Weeping Angels back, just changing everything that made them any good in the first place, and then the universe exploded repeatedly and Rory's 2k years old and plastic except he's not and there was a grand conspiracy between everyone and everyone else to get rid of the Doctor but none of them thought of shooting him and...well, on the other hand, there was that Neil Gaiman story.


Hard to say, really, there's lots of fail to go round, and only the odd decent bit to make up for it.

Winner.

 

[Berithil]

David Tennant by far, though Matt smith is catching up in my book. Eccleston was good but it wasn't til the second season with David that I really started to get into the show. The tenth doctor was the epitome of awesome. Christopher kind of turned me off with the constant being rude thing (though I understand why). But none of them were "bad" in my book.

 

[Febel]

All of them are good from what I've seen but I prefer Eccleston. It's like that novelty Tshirt says: you never forget your first doctor."