Poll: Sonic in 3D, What would you do to make it work?

Recommended Videos

sonicspin

New member
Nov 13, 2008
573
0
0
BIGpanda said:
sell sonic to Dimps studios. they successfully recreated the sonic class twice one what was believed to have been an inferior console port. twice.
Dimps is remaking sonic3 and knuckles for ds and psp I read, so at least a rehash of what people want the most is coming out...again...how many times have I bought those games now?
I just hope they'll keep the Michael Jackson music that was in sonic 3...Hey! Maybe that's why Sonic went downhill! LET'S GET MICHAEL JACKSON TO MAKE ALL THE MUSIC FOR THE NEXT SONIC GAME!
 

BIGpanda

New member
Jan 13, 2009
179
0
0
sonicspin said:
BIGpanda said:
sell sonic to Dimps studios. they successfully recreated the sonic class twice one what was believed to have been an inferior console port. twice.
Dimps is remaking sonic3 and knuckles for ds and psp I read, so at least a rehash of what people want the most is coming out...again...how many times have I bought those games now?
I just hope they'll keep the Michael Jackson music that was in sonic 3...Hey! Maybe that's why Sonic went downhill! LET'S GET MICHAEL JACKSON TO MAKE ALL THE MUSIC FOR THE NEXT SONIC GAME!
...........sexually active pop stars aside I really liked Dimps. they gave sonic the same old 2D feel yet the fun fast-paced mini games needed a 3D view. the music is also a positive note but then again these half the staff from this company made a major musical effort of street fighter four and king of fighters. I believe Dimps can jump start sonic back into it's prime time. then again I've grown over my childhood memories and I've moved on to knifes and tits.
 

cartooner2008

New member
Dec 18, 2008
229
0
0
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
Speaking of dieing, when will this thread die?
Not too soon, lets hope it stays here forever! ^_^ Here, let me help you out d-y-i-n-g, dying. Don't be a fool, stay in school!
The reason why I'm saying this is because I think that this thread has been going on for too long (not to mention that voice acting doesn't matter for a Sonic game), and I would like to see it end.
 

mike1921

New member
Oct 17, 2008
1,292
0
0
sonicspin said:
gibboss28 said:
replacing the 3 with a 2. that'll probably do it.
Use your imaginations people. I know it's hard, but think of playing a 3D sonic game that wouldn't suck ass. What would be different?
It'd be called sonic adventure2.
 

sonicspin

New member
Nov 13, 2008
573
0
0
cartooner2008 said:
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
Speaking of dieing, when will this thread die?
Not too soon, lets hope it stays here forever! ^_^ Here, let me help you out d-y-i-n-g, dying. Don't be a fool, stay in school!
The reason why I'm saying this is because I think that this thread has been going on for too long (not to mention that voice acting doesn't matter for a Sonic game), and I would like to see it end.
There's the old pepper! Giving me some serious feedback! And roll with me here buddy, as long as people have got ideas this thread is still fresh. You can never have too-much feedback...unless it's from a very loud speaker...then your head might explode!
 

sonicspin

New member
Nov 13, 2008
573
0
0
BIGpanda said:
sonicspin said:
BIGpanda said:
sell sonic to Dimps studios. they successfully recreated the sonic class twice one what was believed to have been an inferior console port. twice.
Dimps is remaking sonic3 and knuckles for ds and psp I read, so at least a rehash of what people want the most is coming out...again...how many times have I bought those games now?
I just hope they'll keep the Michael Jackson music that was in sonic 3...Hey! Maybe that's why Sonic went downhill! LET'S GET MICHAEL JACKSON TO MAKE ALL THE MUSIC FOR THE NEXT SONIC GAME!
That is true, I did like the Sonic Rush games, but the level design left a little something to be desired. The 3D special stages were also fun! But the whole thing is that they do good 2D handhelds, but can they do a 3D console game? And lastly...say what you will about Michael Jackson, but that man's music is timeless! Ice Cap Zone in Sonic 3? Good Beats! Not to mention his actual music. He will always be the king of pop! Seriously go watch his music videos right now...Cool, huh?

...........sexually active pop stars aside I really liked Dimps. they gave sonic the same old 2D feel yet the fun fast-paced mini games needed a 3D view. the music is also a positive note but then again these half the staff from this company made a major musical effort of street fighter four and king of fighters. I believe Dimps can jump start sonic back into it's prime time. then again I've grown over my childhood memories and I've moved on to knifes and tits.
 

mike1921

New member
Oct 17, 2008
1,292
0
0
sonicspin said:
mike1921 said:
sonicspin said:
gibboss28 said:
replacing the 3 with a 2. that'll probably do it.
Use your imaginations people. I know it's hard, but think of playing a 3D sonic game that wouldn't suck ass. What would be different?
It'd be called sonic adventure2.
I don't get the puchline...What?
Sonic adventure one and two were good 3d sonic games.
 

cartooner2008

New member
Dec 18, 2008
229
0
0
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
Speaking of dieing, when will this thread die?
Not too soon, lets hope it stays here forever! ^_^ Here, let me help you out d-y-i-n-g, dying. Don't be a fool, stay in school!
The reason why I'm saying this is because I think that this thread has been going on for too long (not to mention that voice acting doesn't matter for a Sonic game), and I would like to see it end.
There's the old pepper! Giving me some serious feedback! And roll with me here buddy, as long as people have got ideas this thread is still fresh. You can never have too-much feedback...unless it's from a very loud speaker...then your head might explode!
It's good that your getting a lot of feedback. I'm just getting a bit annoyed that most of it is either saying "All of the Above" or "Just kill Sonic". I'll agree that the new Sonic games aren't as good as the old ones, but some people go way too far. For example, one guy sent me a PM calling me a retard for liking some 3D Sonic games.
 

Piotr621

New member
Jan 6, 2009
385
0
0
The main reason, I believe, that Sonic has screwed up in 3D is because of the speed. On a 2D plane, it is very easy to go as fast as you want and still easily collect rings and take out enemies. However, add a third dimension, and all of a sudden it gets a hell of a lot harder, forcing you to stop to collect items, thus breaking up the flow of the game, (that and the controls feel like Sonic has put ice on his shoes). What I would do in a 3D Sonic game is perhaps put in a "lane" system, where in any level, there are invisible lanes that you could move Sonic to, and all collectibles are oriented along those lanes. Also, unlike other parts like this in Sonic games, you can still go back and control your speed. I would also have lanes that lead to other places, and it would be like a normal 3D adventure game, but with SPEED.
 

Piotr621

New member
Jan 6, 2009
385
0
0
Also, I dont about you guys, but I have a copy of Sonic R on PC and I actually like it. The controls arent bad, you just got to adapt to them. Though, I do admit, the soundtrack sucked.
 

sonicspin

New member
Nov 13, 2008
573
0
0
mike1921 said:
sonicspin said:
mike1921 said:
sonicspin said:
gibboss28 said:
replacing the 3 with a 2. that'll probably do it.
Use your imaginations people. I know it's hard, but think of playing a 3D sonic game that wouldn't suck ass. What would be different?
It'd be called sonic adventure2.
I don't get the puchline...What?
Sonic adventure one and two were good 3d sonic games.
Oic...Yes...Yes they were, but they need improvement by today's standards.
 

sonicspin

New member
Nov 13, 2008
573
0
0
cartooner2008 said:
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
Speaking of dieing, when will this thread die?
Not too soon, lets hope it stays here forever! ^_^ Here, let me help you out d-y-i-n-g, dying. Don't be a fool, stay in school!
The reason why I'm saying this is because I think that this thread has been going on for too long (not to mention that voice acting doesn't matter for a Sonic game), and I would like to see it end.
There's the old pepper! Giving me some serious feedback! And roll with me here buddy, as long as people have got ideas this thread is still fresh. You can never have too-much feedback...unless it's from a very loud speaker...then your head might explode!
It's good that your getting a lot of feedback. I'm just getting a bit annoyed that most of it is either saying "All of the Above" or "Just kill Sonic". I'll agree that the new Sonic games aren't as good as the old ones, but some people go way too far. For example, one guy sent me a PM calling me a retard for liking some 3D Sonic games.
Be the bigger man and walk away, he's just some random guy on the internet, bored. Why do you take offense to that anyways? Are you ashamed of the fact you like 3D sonic games? Don't answer that! It's a rhetorical question. Bottom line...screw em'!
 

sonicspin

New member
Nov 13, 2008
573
0
0
Interesting concept! It might work, but getting rid of a level of freedom? It's too hard to decide right now, I need to marinate on this one! Congrats! You're the first parson to make me stew about something!
 

cartooner2008

New member
Dec 18, 2008
229
0
0
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
sonicspin said:
cartooner2008 said:
Speaking of dieing, when will this thread die?
Not too soon, lets hope it stays here forever! ^_^ Here, let me help you out d-y-i-n-g, dying. Don't be a fool, stay in school!
The reason why I'm saying this is because I think that this thread has been going on for too long (not to mention that voice acting doesn't matter for a Sonic game), and I would like to see it end.
There's the old pepper! Giving me some serious feedback! And roll with me here buddy, as long as people have got ideas this thread is still fresh. You can never have too-much feedback...unless it's from a very loud speaker...then your head might explode!
It's good that your getting a lot of feedback. I'm just getting a bit annoyed that most of it is either saying "All of the Above" or "Just kill Sonic". I'll agree that the new Sonic games aren't as good as the old ones, but some people go way too far. For example, one guy sent me a PM calling me a retard for liking some 3D Sonic games.
Be the bigger man and walk away, he's just some random guy on the internet, bored. Why do you take offense to that anyways? Are you ashamed of the fact you like 3D sonic games? Don't answer that! It's a rhetorical question. Bottom line...screw em'!
I did move on from that PM. Once I got it, I just deleted it and moved on.
 

quack35

New member
Sep 1, 2008
2,197
0
0
Paint "101" on Sonic's back and have him walk slowly around a wasteland with a rifle strapped to his back and old fashioned music playing?
 

Not Good

New member
Sep 17, 2008
934
0
0
I for one vote franchise death so that Sonic Team can be disbanded and our attention focused toward games without sequels.

But if I had to keep the franchise alive. I'd just make a bunch of levels together, staple one right next to the other (By that I mean no filler) and throw in some secret levels and hypersonic and We're good. Sonic originally was a pretty basic concept: platforming + speed = fun. And this worked. Sure we had tails to fucking deal with but at least the concept wasn't lost. Right around sonic adventure 2 3rd-person cameras started being a problem and from then on the games were unplayable because they didn't fix that.
 

mike1921

New member
Oct 17, 2008
1,292
0
0
sonicspin said:
mike1921 said:
sonicspin said:
mike1921 said:
sonicspin said:
gibboss28 said:
replacing the 3 with a 2. that'll probably do it.
Use your imaginations people. I know it's hard, but think of playing a 3D sonic game that wouldn't suck ass. What would be different?
It'd be called sonic adventure2.
I don't get the puchline...What?
Sonic adventure one and two were good 3d sonic games.
Oic...Yes...Yes they were, but they need improvement by today's standards.
Ofcourse, it's a relatively old game. You were asking for a 3d sonic game that doesn't suck ass as if it were theoretical instead of something that already existed and just needs to be brought back.

A good 3d sonic game already existed. A gone one for this gen would basically be Sonic adventure, with all non-sonic type levels being optional, more levels, graphics and models from sonic unleashed(only thing they got right), and sonic being slightly faster.