Poll: Submit your Games for each category!

[Daedalus1942]

all and all id say nethack is best in every category, and it runs even on my linux server

As in .dotnethack? the RPG series?
The incredibly repetitive, trite generic role playing game that tries poorly to pass itself off as a sort of single player Massively Multiplayer online simulator rpg along with a poorly constructed, and a story that's almost just thrown together one night over a million tabs of acid?
Is that the same nethack we're talking about?

 

[happysock]

Best Graphicsirt 2

Best Bodiliy Destructability (GIBBING): Fallout 3 when the body explodes

Most Historically Accurate: Rome total war I guess with the skirmish missions

Best AI:COD WAW Zombie mode

Best Story:COD WAW Zombies again or Halo 3

Best Weaponry:Oblivion or dead rising

Most Replayable: Left 4 dead, COD Waw zombies, Dead Space

 

[Remleiz]

Best Graphics: Oblivion [just purely for when you first see the bright sky of the wilderness for the first time, it still makes me go 'wow']

Best Bodiliy Destructability (GIBBING): Fallout 3

Most Historically Accurate: Call of Juarez: Bound in blood [only game i have that could fit in this catagory ]

Best AI: Killzone 2

Best Story: Panzer Dragoon Saga [an oldie but a goodie]

Best Weaponry: Resistance 2

Most Replayable: Overlord 2 [yeah, so what ]

 

[JakCurse]

interesting comments. but i have NO IDEA how Halo has good AI. and i thank god that nobody said any of the CoD games. Run out/die/repeat.

 

[-Seraph-]

Best Graphics: Shadow of the Colossus. I'm going by general style and execution.

Best Bodily Destructibility (GIBBING): God of War

Most Historically Accurate: Brothers in Arms

Best AI: Crysis Warhead

Best Story: Final Fantasy 6

Best Weaponry: Unreal Tournament

Most Re-playable: Metroid 3

 

[LockHeart]

Best Graphics: Crysis

Best Bodiliy Destructability (GIBBING): Fallout 2 (I prefer this type so much more than 3)

Most Historically Accurate: Medieval Total War 2, or Empire.

Best AI: Any of the X-Com or Civ games on higher levels. You will regret picking it.

Best Story: Now this is a toughie, I love Mass Effect's space opera, and Half-Life's plot, and I do love the whole 'what if' story or World in Conflict...

Best Weaponry: The Unreal Tournament games have always had an awesome selection of murderising instruments...

Most Replayable: I'd probably have to say Diablo II (simply because of the randomising element), Rise of Nations always brings me back though, along with the Baldur's Gate series and the Total War games...

 

[Nouw]

Best weapons. Resistance sounded pretty good for that one. Well at least a PS3 fan-boy reviewer for a PS dedicated magazine said that

 

[MetallicaRulez0]

Best Graphics: Crysis

Best Bodily Destructibility (GIBBING): CoD: WaW

Most Historically Accurate: No idea.

Best AI: Marvel vs Capcom 2 remake (my GOD the Expert difficulty is hard)

Best Story: Mass Effect

Best Weaponry: Call of Duty 4

Most Replayable: Call of Duty 4

I find replayability is the most important aspect of games, I'm pretty much a multiplayer junkie.

 

[JakCurse]

surprised there's not more choices for AI, for me, that's what makes a game. I like to be fighting an intelligent enemy, but i don't always want to be playing multiplayer

 

[Lonely Swordsman]

Best graphics: Okami. Shows that you construct a beatiful immersive enviroment without many technological ressources, if you just put enough effort into style and detail.
Best characters: KOTOR 2. Every single one is truly unique.
Best storyline: Warcraft 3
Best in-game world: The Fallout series
Most eeplay value: Again, Warcraft 3. Custom edited maps and scenarios with endless possibilities.
Greatest Rage-outlet potential: Mad World. So many ways to slaughter people...
Biggest challenge: S.T.A.L.K.E.R.

 

[Ben7]

Best Graphics: World in Conflict/Crysis

Best Bodiliy Destructability: Fallout 3

Most Historically Accurate: COH

Best AI: Hl2? to be frank ive never experienced any shockingly smart AI, mostly play online anyway.

Best Story: Dead Rising

Best Weaponry: Fallout 3

Most Replayable: Any of the TW series

 

[Acidwell]

Story followed by good gameplay. If it has both of these i find replayablity follows

Best Graphics: Killzone(crysis)

Best Bodiliy Destructability: Good old soldiers of fortune series

Most Historically Accurate: Rome:Total War

Best AI: ?

Best Story: Deus Ex or Psyconauts

Best Weaponry: UT2004

Most Replayable: Neverwinter Nights

 

[JakCurse]

I tend to find that i can replay a game more if it has less linearity, or more flexibility. like, you're guided to the objective in CoD games, but there are sort of different ways you can accomplish it, if you can be bothered to take the blinkers off. On the other hand, something like oblivion, i feel is still linear in that the quests are always the same, and there's a set number.