Poll: Telepaths are Rapists

Recommended Videos

LittleAmii

New member
Mar 10, 2010
33
0
0
In my younger years, I honestly believed in mind reading. I'm still a little tentative of highly perceptive people.

And, yes, I regarded it as a very obscene act. But then, I can be a very paranoid person.
 

YawehG

New member
Feb 14, 2010
59
0
0
Daveman said:
it's not happening, so who cares?
Well, the events in video games aren't real either, but here we have an entire website devoted to them.
 

PrimoThePro

New member
Jun 23, 2009
1,458
0
0
Well first of all, there are two kinds of telepathy, where there is command-their-mind-no-holding-back telepathy, and you-see-what-they-let-you. I wish I had the latter. That would be epic.
Second, It's only evil if you make it so. If you have category A telepathy, then you can control it so that you don't have to read what's not allowed.
 

PrimoThePro

New member
Jun 23, 2009
1,458
0
0
I just read through some of these comments, and jeez, some of you guys need to lighten up. :p
Anyways, THIRD. What is your definition of telepathy anyway?
 

Summerstorm

Elite Member
Sep 19, 2008
1,480
125
68
Nah, just reading the minds is more disgusting voyeurism. IMPLANTING memories, taking them away or taking control of your actions... that is mind-raping.

Just watching is not good but not HORRIBLE either. (What you DO with that information can be very evil though)
 

Internet Kraken

Animalia Mollusca Cephalopada
Mar 18, 2009
6,915
0
0
Yes, I agree. Somebody's mind is truly their own world. You can think of whatever you want. You can imagine anything you like. Your thoughts are your own, and you only share them with people if you choose to do so. The moment people begin prying into someone else's mind is the moment that nowhere is truly safe. No thought could go unnoticed. Everything you think of, every memory you have, every fact about your life could be lifted from your mind. If a man can not keep his own thoughts safe, then how safe can he really be?

Also, I can't believe people are really responding with "it's not real so it's not evil". I thought it was pretty obvious that this was a hypothetical question, meant to contemplate the ethics of mind reading as it is something that often comes up in fiction. I mean, we're on a gaming website. Many of the things we talk about are not real, so what kind of response is that?
 

JRCB

New member
Jan 11, 2009
4,387
0
0
I think that it can be evil, depending on what you use it for. For personal gain, yes. For helping others, like trying to find out here a person his holding another person hostage? Not so much.

It's a thin line.
 

Angry Caterpillar

New member
Feb 26, 2010
698
0
0
YawehG said:
Magic Hobo said:
No. Because mind reading isn't real.
Okay, yeah, obviously, but I mean as a concept.
As a concept then....still no. Maybe for others it would be, but if they peeked into my mind they would see things that cannot but unseen.

If, however, they could operate it both ways and put things into your mind, then that's definitely mind rape.
 

quiet_samurai

New member
Apr 24, 2009
3,897
0
0
Daveman said:
Magic Hobo said:
No. Because mind reading isn't real.
Duh, obvious really.

Seriously, I can't even begin to get mad about that.

It's like, "You know what's really wrong, murdering aliens..." but... it's not happening, so who cares?
What about stealing from leprechauns??

OT: Um, no. As long as you didn't do it to gain deep personal knowledge from that person.
 

Daveman

has tits and is on fire
Jan 8, 2009
4,202
0
0
YawehG said:
Daveman said:
it's not happening, so who cares?
Well, the events in video games aren't real either, but here we have an entire website devoted to them.
Yes but it's pointless getting into a MORAL debate over something that doesn't happen. I guess what I'm saying is it's pretty hard for people to feel strongly either way. It is like arguing over the Covenants rights to religious freedom... which has yet to happen I believe. This is why FOX throws hissy fits about gunning down civilians when we just don't care.

What I guess I'm saying is it's hard for anybody to feel strongly either way.
 

YawehG

New member
Feb 14, 2010
59
0
0
Daveman said:
What I guess I'm saying is it's hard for anybody to feel strongly either way.
Well not me.
I guess I just see it a figurative extreme in a discussion of the natural right to privacy.
 

Shoggoth2588

New member
Aug 31, 2009
10,250
0
0
Mind reading isn't real however, in most media in which mind reading is possible, it is mentioned how reading one's thoughts without consent is considered very rude. I liked the explanation given in Harry Potter though; that the mind is not as a book to be open and perused as one pleases but rather, a complex system of information which even the user isn't completely aware of. In a way, the mind can be seen as the ultimate place one can attempt to peer into however, that's all you would be doing. You would be looking at the memories and thoughts of someone and unable to say, make them see as you do, make them forget something or, make them suddenly forget how to make their heart beat. Physical rape causes physical damage and is an actual crime which can be committed in any universe by any person. Most of the time, when one is able to 'read a mind' there is almost always another person with whom the first can 'meld' with. The Mind Meld is described as being the most intense form of joining two people can engage in. I dunno, I guess it depends on which universes rules you go by. Martian Manhunter could hear your thoughts but, Voldemort can make you forget how to breath.
 

userwhoquitthesite

New member
Jul 23, 2009
2,177
0
0
YawehG said:
Let me clarify that. Mind reading is a gross, depraved practice, regardless of the circumstances behind its use. It's my believe that a person's thoughts are their inner-most sanctum, the most private place anyone has, and a breaching that boundary is a violation of mind in the same way rape is a violation of body. I've heard quite a lot of opinions on this before, both with me and against. So does this make sense to you, or am I crazy?

EDIT: I mean, obviously, as a hypothetical concept. I don't think mind-reading is real
only if your mind is on fire

cuz that's a flaming WONDER telepath
 

Gilhelmi

The One Who Protects
Oct 22, 2009
1,480
0
0
YawehG said:
Let me clarify that. Mind reading is a gross, depraved practice, regardless of the circumstances behind its use. It's my believe that a person's thoughts are their inner-most sanctum, the most private place anyone has, and a breaching that boundary is a violation of mind in the same way rape is a violation of body. I've heard quite a lot of opinions on this before, both with me and against. So does this make sense to you, or am I crazy?

EDIT: I mean, obviously, as a hypothetical concept. I don't think mind-reading is real
No, but because if you give me permission to read your mind, then it is consensual. Or if it existed where everyone can read everyones mind(like the Betezoids on star trek), then it would be second nature and no-one would give a second thought about people reading your mind.
 

YawehG

New member
Feb 14, 2010
59
0
0
Eukaryote said:
Nothing can be inherently evil, because "evil" is an artificial construct of the human mind.
That's true, which is the point of asking for an opinion. You have to judge things against your personal definition of "evil."


Gilhelmi said:
No, but because if you give me permission to read your mind, then it is consensual. Or if it existed where everyone can read everyones mind(like the Betezoids on star trek), then it would be second nature and no-one would give a second thought about people reading your mind.
That's a good point, the Betezoids thing I mean. I'm talking about mind-reading without someone's knowledge or consent. In our extended mind-rape metaphor consensual mind-reading would just be sex I guess.
 

CuddlyCombine

New member
Sep 12, 2007
1,142
0
0
The lizard people who control the governments want us to believe that it isn't real. But I know that it is.