Poll: Which would you buy of the three?

[King of the Sandbox]

San Andreas just has a LOT more replayability and lasting appeal.

This, basically.

 

[RDL_Razor]

GTA:SA has multiplayer and so it is a no-brainer.

It does?!

Well, it does have MP on PC, why shouldn't it on Xbox?

 

[AgDr_ODST]

This poll having the Zero added to Perfect Dark seems to have created a lot of confusion. Zero is a terrible game, I love Rare, but it is the truth as far as I am concerned.

I actually love both those games but Perfect Dark is \my favourite shooter of all time [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.181494-Perfect-Dark-it-is-out-An-XBLA-must-have#5361647]. So I am biased. I think it is the best for multiplayer and it has achievements, which matters to some.

I think GTA is a great open-world single player game, but to me PD is the best "package".

Fix your poll. Says Perfect Dark Zero, I'm sure you meant Perfect Dark.

my bad I fixed it and threw in an edit to my OP

 

[StBishop]

I think you should just buy a light saber for your avatar.

 

[BolognaBaloney]

San Andreas! So much replay value, I'd side with it.

 

[Flight]

I honestly didn't like the Max Payne series at all, and I didn't enjoy Perfect Dark (although I did like it on the N64, the 360 version left a lot to be desired), so I'm going to have to go with GTA: San Andreas.

 

[MR T3D]

GTA:SA has multiplayer and so it is a no-brainer.

except that MP support is going to be gone soon.
get perfect dark

 

[Garfunkel00]

I honestly didn't like the Max Payne series at all, and I didn't enjoy Alone in the Dark (even though it had its good moments), so I'm going to have to go with GTA: San Andreas.

It's PERFECT DARK not Alone in the Dark. Do try to understand the question before answering, helps a lot.

San Andreas! So much replay value, I'd side with it.

Bollocks. There is no replay value in a completely linear game. Don't mix "replayability" with "much optional content".

None of those games is any good after a single play-through. Max Payne 2 is a good OTS-shooter with very rare film noir plot and pretty good levels. Perfect Dark is a good shooter. San Andreas is probably the best 3D GTA. Since you play on XBox you can't run any mods either, so it comes down to the fact that SA is the longest game to finish. I'd still recommend Max Payne 2, since it's atmosphere is very good.

 

[Flight]

I honestly didn't like the Max Payne series at all, and I didn't enjoy Alone in the Dark (even though it had its good moments), so I'm going to have to go with GTA: San Andreas.

It's PERFECT DARK not Alone in the Dark. [/quote

I did understand the question, but my brain went poof for a minute there. Happens to the best of us, but thanks for pointing out my error so I could fix it.

 

[Tasachan]

GTA hands down.


Though I thought you meant the 360 Perfect Dark... Hmn. Now its a tough call. Perfect Dark was awesome multiplayer, GTA hours of entertainment for singleplayer.

 

[Shepard's Shadow]

Perfect Dark, without a second of hesitation. Why? Its the best of the three.

 

[Commander Jack Rankin]

GTA: SA without question.

 

[asdasdasdasda]

GTA:SA, neither of those come close. It's by far the best game of it's kind (Saint's Row 2 comes close, though)

 

[tikian12]

That GTA has to be one of my favorites, though I only played the AO PC version...

 

[Good morning blues]

I'm trying really hard to recommend one of GTA or Max Payne 2. They're both fantastic.

I dunno. I had more fun with MP2, but GTA is the best of that series in my opinion and it will last you a lot longer.

 

[TelHybrid]

GTA:SA has multiplayer and so it is a no-brainer.

It does?!

Well, it does have MP on PC, why shouldn't it on Xbox?

The PC's multiplayer mode is a fan made mod. That's why. =/

 

[RDL_Razor]

GTA:SA has multiplayer and so it is a no-brainer.

It does?!

Well, it does have MP on PC, why shouldn't it on Xbox?

The PC's multiplayer mode is a fan made mod. That's why. =/

Oh well, it's still both the longest and the most replayable game of all three.

 

[ethaninja]

San Andreas was crap. Buggy as hell. I would go with Max Payne 2. Nothing better then diving out of corners in slow motion and putting a round in between the eyes of some douche.