Just commented on the Escapist Reveal and I'll say the same thing here.
No one has any idea what this game is going to be like. The gameplay I can estimate will be a lot like the gameplay of previous Halo games, so if you liked them it'll most likely be the same.
But other than that? They've said nothing about the story, nothing about the characters, and nothing about this installment's place in the canon. How can you possibly know it is going to suck? Do the developer's have along history of making awful games? Nope, because they haven't made any yet, and that's how every developer, good or bad, started once. So do the developer's have a history ofmaking bad stories? Nope. They presided over or directly contributed to Halo: Legends, which is awesome, Halo: Evolutions, which I think is awesome, Halo: Fall of Reach comics, which are pretty good, Halo: Helljumper, which I think is awesome.
So they have yet to prove themselves as game designers and have shown they are cpaable of putting out great stories with an in-depth understanding of the Halo universe. And their game will probably be based on the previous Halo games.
Yet somehow people seem to know that the gameplay will suck and the story will be rubbish. How exactly? When and where did you get clairvoyance because I want to know.