Poll: Will IE9 beat FireFox and Chrome?

Recommended Videos

JoJo

and the Amazing Technicolour Dream Goat 🐐
Moderator
Legacy
Mar 31, 2010
7,170
143
68
Country
šŸ‡¬šŸ‡§
Gender
♂
Probably will beat them overall, although this forum seems to be filled up-to-the-brim with anti-IE fanboys so it'll lose on this thread. I personally find it convinient and perfectly fine to use.
 

Hosker

New member
Aug 13, 2010
1,177
0
0
I might give it a try if it develops a good reputation. Otherwise I see no reason to.
 

Thaliur

New member
Jan 3, 2008
617
0
0
FlashHero said:
But what are your opinions? Will you switch if everything is true?
I won't switch, because I've been using the beta since it was published anyway.
First I was just curious, and I slowly got more and more attached to it. Here are just some of the reasons:

Security:
IE uses a Windows function (which is - by the way - available for all software) that puts the associated processes on even lower permissions than the current user.

Privacy mode:
Since in IE every tab is one process, I can switch to privacy mode without closing any of the existing ones, and just close the privacy window when I don't need it anymore.

Jump List integration:
I actually don't know if other browsers finally make proper use of the jumplist by now, but IE does it, and does it well, so it's an advantage to me.

Tab management:
Every IE9 tab is shown in the taskbar as if it were a window (since the windows get grouped by program, it doesn't clutter the taskbar), making switching between them easy, even if there are a lot of them. If I don't have too many tabs open, I can see a current preview of each. Granted, videos don't play when minimised, but at least I see the state of the page at the moment I opened the list. I can simply close any tab by middle-clicking on it in taskbar view (or the browser for that matter). I can move tabs around freely. Tabs that are opened in the same "tree" (originating from the same page or successive pages) get colour-coded and can be closed as a group (single tabs can also be un-grouped). Dragging a tab detaches it from the window, releasing it in "free air" creates a new window, moving it to screen edges performs appropriate snap actions.

Bookmarks/Favourites:
The IE Favourites are neatly integrated into the Windows interface, and even get synchronised between my desktop PC and my netbook, automatically and silently (as long as Live Mesh is running).

Page Apps:
I had no idea how else to call this function. A web page in IE9 can be attached to the taskbar like a program. Once attached, it will be displayed with the asssociated icon (the e logo in escapist's case) and when the page gets opened that way, the browser controls get a matching colour scheme. Web pages attached this way can be handled like normal attached programs.

Resource management:
If I close an IE9 tab, it's gone. It can be restored If I want to (via the "new tab" page), but as far as the system is concerned, the process is gone from memory and CPU.
After a while, my Firefox process usually needs about 800M RAM + about 200M for "plugincontainer" and pretty much all of my CPU, either for itself, or because the system is swapping like mad.

Message handling:
IE9 messages, including downloads, are displayed in a non-intrusive, yet easily visible way by showing a yellow bar at the bottom of the screen.

Progress display:
IE9 download progress is displayed on the program icon in the taskbar. Firefox downloads aren't, unless you're using a download manager plugin which does that.

Web Slices:
As far as I know, no other browser does that: Some sites offer a "web slice" which is basically a small page which gets saved as a bookmark, and when you click on it, it doesn't go to the linked page, but instead opens the page in a small dropdown window. Really useful to quickly check the weather forecast (Bing search results including "weather" and a location name automatically generate these slices), see your social networking news or whatever other sites offer for it.

There are a few disadvantages though: Since every tab is its own process, sometimes it can take a second to open a new one, and there is no significant amount of plugins available.
 

Hamster at Dawn

It's Hazard Time!
Mar 19, 2008
1,650
0
0
Hey would anyone mind telling me what's so bad about IE? I mean, I personally use Firefox since I tried it a few years ago and it had all these crazy features I had never dreamed of but now it seems like IE has more or less caught up. I don't really know because I don't use IE anymore so I'd like to hear it from someone who more or less knows their shit when it comes to internet browsers. In particular, I have a friend who is always asking me why I use Firefox over IE and I don't really have any good reasons why, particularly as I don't know IE well enough.
 

jpoon

New member
Mar 26, 2009
1,995
0
0
Nope, I won't be touching that shit with a telephone poll. Now if I could only strip IE8 out of Win 7. I'll stick with a trustworthy browser...Chrome, or Firefox.
 

Golden Hawk

New member
Jan 30, 2011
65
0
0
I've gone through the cycles of disillusionment with IE, then tried using Safari, Firefox, Chrome etc. Then went back to using IE9 (the beta anyway). Maybe it's familiarity or something, or using Microsoft software since I was born, but in IE9 everything is just where it should be and works how you'd expect it to. (One odd thing about IE9 beta is that when you're in a search tab in Google and you highlight your search terms and swipe too far to the left, it sends you back to your homepage)

And if anyone says using IE is to do with Microsoft dominancy, what the hell do you think Google wants to do, now introducing browsers and phones and OS's?
 

wizard_joe88

New member
Nov 12, 2010
347
0
0
Well, good luck microsoft, but aren't you supposed to take baby steps first? And by baby steps, I mean making an internet browser that is actually useable!
 

Conza

New member
Nov 7, 2010
951
0
0
When I downloaded IE9, I decided to try the other browsers, as I'm a long standing IE fan, but I like to keep my mind open. I was almost a Chrome fan, and Firefox wasn't bad either this time, and I normally hate Firefox.

All the browsers have become kinda samey, but let me tell you why I'm back with IE. Chrome was slow, it almost behaved like it was lagging when playing Facebook Tetris for example, and a few other times it began to memory leaked. Which is the shame as I think its the best looking browser.

Firefox was arguing with Gmail, which I just couldn't tolerate/nor bother to fully investigate.

I must admit, that in terms of screen realestate (efficiency of layout, occupying the least amount of pixels to give maximum page size), for the first time ever, IE is LAST followed by, virtually equal FIRST for Chrome and Firefox (whem maximized, exlcuding full screen mode), I'm extremely impressed by the work Firefox have down to fix that - albeit it, just copy Chrome, but that was the biggest issue I had with it for some time.

So... yes, for me atleast, IE does beat the others, it's a closer competition though!

Also, Thaliur makes some excellent points.
 

Thaliur

New member
Jan 3, 2008
617
0
0
Golden Hawk said:
(One odd thing about IE9 beta is that when you're in a search tab in Google and you highlight your search terms and swipe too far to the left, it sends you back to your homepage)
This happens to me frequently. I almost assumed that something might be wrong with my mouse, that it mabe relased the button for a split second and then clicked on the search engine logo when I released it myself (I actually had a similar error with my mouse one. When I opened it I found a bunch of cat hair in the button area and after cleaning it was OK again).
Kind of comforting to know it might not be caused by my computer, but still weird.

Thanks Conor :)