You know, I'm gonna be honest (I don't care if I get a quote barrage), but I liked this movie. I walked in not being excited (my nephew wanted to see it.) because it was so soon after the former Spidey movies and because Spiderman isn't on the top of my super heroes list.
I enjoyed Garfield as Spidey, I especially enjoyed Emma Stone. I think Garfield was scores better than Toby. The fact that he was more of a science geek than a 'nerd' was great, while showing inklings of a personality type that would become a crime-fighter given the circumstances. I enjoyed his personality and just how he brought Parker to life.
It's not the best movie ever made, but I'll probably buy it on DVD to watch with some mates. And it's definitely no Green Lantern, which was horrid.