Poorly Reviewed Games You Enjoyed

[Johanthemonster666]

Personally, of the more obscure titles many years ago I really loved the PS2 King Kong official game to the Peter Jackson film. Was it perfect? No, but it had that element of adventure which is lacking in 99% of today's dino-monster shooters.

Other titles that come to mind include -BioShock 2

-F.E.A.R 2-3- Both had creepy atmospheres and used jumps scares effectively with an intriguing plot continuation from the first.

- Alone in the Dark (2008)-Most of the hate from game reviewers was due to the glitches (which where later fixed) and the sometimes awkward dialogue and story elements...but the game was pretty much everything I look for in a survivor horror game.

-Dead Space 2- Absolutely loved the first installment and thoroughly enjoyed the second.

 

[AusGamer44]

Postal 2.It was blasted by critics and used by the anti-violent game lobby as its posterboy for its cause.It was even banned in Australia-where I may or may not live,hem hem.
And the funny thing is,I'm normally one of those people who usually dislikes most FPSes-especially the ultraviolent,barely-any-story ones.It's EXACTLY the kind of game politicans who crusade against violent video games despise-and I fucking enjoyed the crap out of it.
I think the thing with Postal 2,is that it's violence was SO OTT and corny you couldn't take it seriously.It's offensive in almost every way-racial,religious & sexuality stereotypes,animal cruelty and being murderous for fun.It reminds me a bit of South Park(without the cleverness).Being offensive towards EVERYBODY,it ends up with an odd kind of equal-equality mockery.
I think I enjoyed it because IRL I try hard to be a decent person.Courtesy,kindness and respect for others is impt to me,but I have suffered from self esteem issues and several times in my life have been walked over.Where else can I be a sociopath with no ill effects?You CAN complete the game without being violent,but the game loves to goad you into it.Long bank queue? Rude shop owner? Police brutality? Dude with an annoying walk? I COULD put up with it,or I could blast them all with a rocket launcher.Decisions,decisions.
Also,the cat gun is up there with the Portal APSD & the Gravity Gun for 'funnest shootey thing' ever.
A guilty pleasure.

Ignore the title,he's kidding.(Not everyone on the Steam forum got that.)NSFW,obviously.


Cat gun shown hereNSFW)

 

[CJ1145]

Ever hear of a game called Bladestorm? It's a Dynasty Warriors-esque game with some elements almost like a real-time Might and Magic thrown in about the Hundred Years War. I loved it, but it's pretty much unknown to the average bloke.

 

[The Wykydtron]

Well after playing Persona 4 to completion, I went and checked on a whim and appallingly, IGN gave it an 8/10 would you believe?

Anything less than an 11/10 is unacceptable. Hopefully people can move on from arbitrary numbered scores that don't really mean anything at some point though.

I think UMVC3 got some mixed reviews and I love that game,(not as much as I love BlazBlue but still.)

The absolute lack of any singleplayer content is admittedly a HUGE flaw. Capcom must have been counting on the online flourishing for the game's entire lifespan before release, something that actually happened thankfully. Even today over a year after its release it's still got a decent sized online community.

I still believe you can't truly *learn* a fighting game without going online. Sure you can get the combos down in training all day but good luck recognising how to get in to do them on an actual opponent. Having said that I wouldn't replace BB's awesome story modes for anything.

Jim Sterling would have a field day with you.

In a good way I hope? I was never one to keep up to date on his stuff because his loud voice and cheap suit irritates me. Quite sure he has some well founded points and knowledge on the industry but it's all in the presentation y'know?

I liked his Aliens: CM review though, I enjoy watching people rip the piss out of things XD

 

[Tomeran]

All games have been poorly reviewed and almost all games have gotten good reviews, so its difficult to reach some sort of philter there on what to pick out to qualify for this thread.

Guess I'll have to settle with "Games that were generally unfavored by a majority of game critics"....if I actually bought any such games. I dont, so I'll be forced to bring customer feedback into that fold, and that is unfortunetly about as reliable as building a bridge out of feathers.


- Dragon Age 2

Took a lot of flak for the way its story was told and the lack of bridging content between Dragon Age 1 and and nr.2.
Mostly took flak for its constant re-use of poor textures, buildings and caves. Not to mention the "when in doubt, throw in spiders or 9812 bandits".

Despite all that, I enjoyed the game immensely. Looking forward to the third title.


- Sim City (the new one)

This one's tricky, and a clear example of why its difficult to just choose a "poorly reviewed game". Because Simcity did not generally recieve poor reviews. In fact it was described as a pretty solid game. But the game(and EA) took MASSIVE flak from both customers and reviewers for the outrageously poor handling of the servers at the time it launched. It also took (mostly customer) criticism for breaking too far from previous simcity games and for making maps too small, as well as the DRM.

If one looks aside the server issues, I quite agree with most reviewers conclusion, Simcity is a pretty solid game and I enjoyed it(and I still enjoy it) a lot.



- Dead Space 3

Again an example where a game didnt really recieve that much negative attention from reviewers, but mostly from customers. Dead Space 3 took a lot of criticism for being too much of an action-shooter and taking too big steps from its predecessors. Less horror and more action.

I never played any of the previous dead space titles, and perhaps that's why I didnt really have a problem with the new title. I've definetly played better games then DeadSpace 3, but it didnt suck as much as many told me it did.

 

[Todstyak]

Halo 3: ODST.

Not only the best Halo game in my opinion. but one of my top eight games of all time. Brilliant music, a wonderful atmosphere, characters I cared about, a more refined version of the traditional Halo gameplay, and to all the math class dropouts who call it a "four-hour campaign", it's actually seven-eight hours long. Not exactly Skyrim, but still.

Thank you! ODST actually wasn't that bad and the enviornments were some of the best in any halo title. The campaign was like 10 hours for me but that is because i got stuck on Buck's first level, i mean FOUR hunters c'mon!

 

[Xarathox]

X2: Wolverine's Revenge. It was just... a comic book game. And a fun one at that.

Predator: Concrete Jungle. I've yet to play any other game that lets you just fucking pick someone up and rip their body in half, bare-handed. The stealth executions were just so goddamn fun.

I still to this day do not get why Concrete Jungle got slammed, its the best predator game out there. You sir earned your daily cookie for that.

To be fair, it was an ugly game for its time. Even for a PS2 or XBox game. I also think it might have been one of the first games to dip into the brown and gray color pool that all of this generation seems to love. Maybe everyone just wasn't ready for that yet.

 

[tgbennett30]

Multiple mentions for Dragon Age 2 and Alpha Protocol, and I agree.

Only one mention for Prince of Persia 2008. I am still awestruck at the art direction for this game. It is probably pretty non-PC to say you like a game for the visuals (pun intended), but I think far too often people equate graphics with simply having really high resolution models or something. There was just something fairy tale-ish about how this one looked, to the extent that I frequently just stopped free-running and simply looked all around myself in wonder, and more for this ONE game than all others I've played put together. Matter of fact, the last game where I simply stopped and looked around in awe was the very first Unreal game, back in the day.

And in fact, I think it was too radical of return, in a sense - Sands of Time was (and is) a true classic. The first sequel (Warrior Within) dumped much of the platforming and personality of SoT in favor of a brooding homicidal prince who fought everything that moved (with tons of electric guitar thrash in the background). Terrible idea. The next sequel (Two Thrones) minimized a fair amount of that, but still focused heavily on combat and less on puzzles.

The 2008 game, then, was actually closer to SoT in that it focused on the wall-running and the interaction b/t the Prince and the female lead, and much less on the combat. I think that might have been too much for folks to handle, given those changes along with the other major differences (no Dagger of Time hijinks and a new character and setting).

And to those reviewers who hated it because it was "too easy" because you can't die - I never understood that. So Elika saves you every time you "die" - to me, that meant she was essentially a quick-save / quick-load button with a personality ;-) I always thought that you can't die in ANY game that doesn't immolate the disc if you screw up (or else has a brutal hardcore mode like Diablo, etc. that erases your character).

 

[an874]

For me it would be Yoshi's Story on the N64, which I hear got poor reviews, but I loved as a kid. Also the first Star Wars: The Force Unleashed might count.

 

[Sensko]

All Samurai Warriors games: Mediocre gameplay, abysmal graphics but the writing, oh sweet Jesus the writing. It takes historical characters and hams them up to a point where it shoots beyond bad right into awesomeness.

 

[Ghostshark]

I really enjoyed Dragon Age 2 despite the redundant maps and combat system departure from the first Dragon Age. I really enjoyed the three different classes and all the character interactions for each of the members of your party. I wonder if it would have gotten better reviews if it had been it's own standalone game.

I also really liked the Dynasty Warriors games (except for maybe Empires) as they were fun, mindless and great to blow off steam with. I didn't expect the games to be much more than that, so I was happy.

 

[Jazoni89]

I agree with pretty much most of the games listed by people here.

Duke Nukem Forever, The new Splatterhouse, Bionic Commando, Alpha Protocol, Dynasty Warriors (any), Alone in the Dark Inferno, Alien Vs Predator, Star Ocean 4, Dead Island, Castlevania Lords of Shadow, Silent Hill Downpour, The Saboteur, The Last Remnant, and Metroid Other M.

So it's really nice to see i'm not the only one who liked these.

 

[DarkhoIlow]

Gothic franchise and Alpha Protocol come to mind of games that weren't so good reviewed.

There are a lot more games out there that I can't seem to recall now but I can say that I have "odd tastes". I usually don't look at reviewers and go with my gut most of the times.

 

[ninjaRiv]

The Hellboy game. I didn't even know it had bad review before I bought it, though. Also, Dragon Age 2

 

[rosque]

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: explorers of time

Reviewers didn't like it often for its repetitive gameplay. I fucking loved it for its characters and story

Absolutely agree. The writing for the prequel wasn't as good, and time had a little bit more dumbed down dialogue, but holy -hell- did it make me cry. As did the prequel which has a twist so dark it made me squeal with glee. As did the sequel which draws out the sadness over a ridiculously long time to just make it -worse-, and yet better.

 

[blaize2010]

Yeah, you know what, I'm gonna come out and say it.

Fable and Fable 2.

You heard me. Staples of my fucking childhood.

Fable 3 was crap though.

 

[Jazoni89]

Yeah, you know what, I'm gonna come out and say it.

Fable and Fable 2.

You heard me. Staples of my fucking childhood.

Fable 3 was crap though.

I didn't like Fable 2 all that much, but I agree with Fable 1, especially with Lost Chapters.

I firmly believe that Fable: The Lost Chapters is one of the best videogames ever made. It's just so goddamn polished, and the world is so realized, it just feels like a true epic adventure. Something even the Elder Scrolls fails to achieve at times.

 

[Virgilthepagan]

Well, if nothing else this makes me feel like I want to play Alpha Protocol...
As others mentioned Metro 2033 and the STALKER series are some of my favorites. I'd also throw in Mount and Blade Warband in here. It's addictive in a way that few games are. Add in the Game of Thrones mod and I sank over a hundred hours into the thing.

 

[bojackx]

Both the Pokemon Mystery Dungeon series and Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness. The former had a great story and addictive gameplay, and I thought XD was a great take on a slightly darker Pokemon world (admittedly it got low reviews mostly because it just copied most of the locations from its prequel).

And... Killing floor I guess? 72% isn't that bad, but I've played that shit for 133 hours now.