I really don't consider myself an "expert" in anything, but I have always been a weapons and warfare kind of guy. Not the Cod kind of weapons guy, the kind that prefers to sit in his room reading about the history of weapons all day. My friends know about my somewhat obsession, so they always bug me with stupid ass questions. The "what-if's" are the worst.
"What if a knight charged a a dude with a crossbow and he shot him"
"Well, he would probably die"
"But what about his armor?"
"What kind of armor?"
"Oh, any kind"
That went on for at least 10 minutes. First of all, who is the knight? What weapon does he have? How thick is his armor and what type is it? What kind of crossbow is it and who is shooting it? What kind of bolt is it?
They think I can just wizard up a scenario out of undetailed babble. This one will haunt me to the day I die.
"Ok, what if a green beret was sent in to recover a nuke and he was crawling through the vents. He used a little rope thing and came above two guards guarding the door and hit their heads together. While he is hacking the door, two guards come up behind him, one holds his arms above his head and the other wails on him. If he managed to pull out his silenced pistol and shoot them, would other people hear it and raise the alarm?"
That, made me cringe. First of all, how would he zoom down from the vents? I cannot imagine that vents were made to hold so much weight, but thats just speculation. Also, if these guys are guarding a "nuke" then they would not be little dopy 20 year olds staring at the wall and not moving like they are guarding Buckingham palace. Im no doctor, but hitting these guys heads together would only knock them out for 10-15 minutes at most ( even if they did get knocked out ) if this "solo" green beret ( Cant think of a single time when a green beret would be sent on a highly dangerous mission alone ) didn't carry a heavy ass warhead out of the compound that he aperantly snuck into by then, the alarm would be raised. Also, the two guards that caught him "hacking" the door would just shoot him. No questions asked. They wouldn't go all "schoolyard beatdown" on him. The question itself is fine, and I said probably not, considering the amount of backround noise that would come from an underground facility, but the scenario is damn stupid.