MizPiz said:
AgentBJ09 said:
Blaming that Chun-Li thing for sucking because it doesn't follow the original canon is like blaming Sonic 2006 for sucking because it's not like the first Sonic. I know it's an odd choice, but its actually true. When a way the story is being told changes, the story itself must be changed in a way that would be appropriate to the means. Lets face it, Mortal Kombat's origin story is extremely shallow and only really there to give a reason to have two colorful (read: cheesy and over the top) characters to fight to the death. It would be impossible to make it into a movie for the sole reason that movies rely way heavier on story than video games do, and they both rely on way different techniques to tell the story that would be impossible to translate between the medias.
Also, to say that the director "has no idea what he's doing" just shows how ignorant you are about filmmaking and should be a little more open to different interpretations of a story. I actually like the concept of the tournament being a death match between serial killers/assassins set up by the leader of a highly powerful crime syndicate. It's a (somewhat) fresh and original take on something that, until recently, I had no idea had a true story behind it. I'm not saying that you need to like it, but at least give it a chance. If after this, you still think the movie's story should follow the original's because you've followed it from the start, then you need to get your head out your ass and realize that your opinion is about as valid as a bum ranting about the end days.
Also, if MovieBob actually thinks that MK:R is a Saw knockoff, he's probably not a reliable source for movie information.
You do know that Capcom co-wrote that script for Chun-Li, right? They invented Street Fighter, and they screw up their own canon? Why? How hard is it to make Chun-Li an Interpol agent, like the game, and bring in plot elements from the film to tell a story?
Now, I have stated in my first post that this is what Tancharoen wants to do. Because of this, what goes into the story is thanks to him and his writer.
So, what is the plot, from what the teaser said: "Enter Shang Tsung's underground tournament, take down the killers within, and potentially kill Tsung."
What was the plot of the first game: "Enter the Mortal Kombat tournament, defeat any in your way, and stop Shang Tsung and Outworld from taking over Earthrealm."
And the first film: "An FBI agent, an actor, and a White Lotus outcast enter the Mortal Kombat tournament, tasked to stop Shang Tsung and his fighters from winning the tournament."
If after this, you still think the movie's story should follow the original's because you've followed it from the start...
I didn't ask him to copy the plot from the first game, and the first movie, then set the story somewhere else. He did that. So, by your logic, you should be looking at Tancharoen and his writer for not innovating on the plot. Sure, copying is the foundation of the entertainment industry, but if he's copying the original film, which I already enjoy, and turning the film into a slasher film, none of which I enjoy watching, why should I give this a chance? I don't have to have movie taste to see that this idea is not worth making.
Valdric_gundam said:
You know AgentBJ09... you kinda sound like a fan boy of MovieBob... any way, I wouldn't mind seeing this movie... it looks like one hell of a good time... and aside from that, takeing away the magic of it, at least to me, makes it that much more interesting, and makes room for more epic one on one fights. And aside from that, why can't the new Mortal Kombat film be more realistic? Why can't it have more blood and gore? And hell how can it be worse than the other Mortal Kombat films that have been made?
By quoting MovieBob once on a point that I agree with, I'm a fanboy? What kind of sense does that make? So, if I think Final Fantasy VIII was terrible and say so, if someone agrees with me and quotes me as saying such, does that make them a fanboy?
As I said, I would like to see blood and gore in an MK film, but that's only a third of the reasons why I like MK. The other two are the characters and the settings, neither of which are, in my opinion, well represented in this teaser. This is why I liked the original MK film so much: It may have left the blood out, but it got the characters right and the settings were recognizable.