Too much love for Batman!
I'm not very fond of him. Probably the lack of super powers. (I know for a lot of people that this is why he is 'teh awesums' but for me he's just a guy who knows kung fu, big deal.)
I went with Spiderman. I grew up with his cartoons, I love his powers, I love his villains. I know he can be an over emotional *****, but then he starts shooting webs and swinging around again and all is well.