hURR dURR dERP said:
I very much consider myself part of the 'new wave' here on the Escapist, having arrived here for no other reason than a link to a Zero Punctuation video (posted on 4chan's /v/, to add imaginary insult to perceived injury), but I am very much aware of the process you describe, and have experienced its effects first-hand on several different forums.
The most annoying part to me, while realizing that I am just as much to blame for this as anyone else, is the way people respond to threads. As I mentioned in another thread, I made a thread about something game-related that I felt strongly about in an attempt to start a meaningful discussion on the subject, but most of what I ende up doing was repeating myself over and over for four pages because everyone felt entitled to share their opinion without even trying to keep any real discussion going apart from the occasionally quoted post. Some time after that I made another thread containing something that required a minimal amount of reading or writing and didn't contain anything worth thinking about for more than three seconds, and it immediately reached more than 10 pages.
Needless to say this annoyed me, but I guess it's only logical. The only alternative is to change forums whenever the current one gets too populous, but I feel I've done my share of forumhopping, and it's time to stick around a bit.
For now.
I've been bothered by this too; I've resolved to make a movement towards boycotting low-content threads. I hope others will do the same. I mean, isn't that what the forum games are for?
I worry that people obsess about their post count a bit, and will opt to post where they can, rather than use their discretion.
Azure-Supernova said:
I am more and more intrigued about the Old Escapist I keep hearing about. Because it sounds like a good place. The sole reason I joined this place is because it had a more personal feel to it, though coming from the cold steel prison that is GameSpot, it was a big leap.
I do fear that perhaps some of the older member idolize this Golden Age. Though reading some of the threads around, I'm partially to blame perhaps. Though that isn't to say I haven't made an effort to get to know people better, more specifically the people that have added me as a friend or whom I have added myself.
I'm definitely part of the most recent wave of members, having only joined in late 09. And I'm not a particularly known user either. There seems to be a big thing about people being judged by their post count, which is a bit on the silly side. I just post when I've got something I wanna say, though I'm guilty myself in making one or two half assed threads.
Sometimes intelligent conversation seems to be sacrificed for the sake of humour, something I've noticed in a great deal of threads and something I'm guilty of myself. Every now and then there will be a good topic, but we're all so busy trying to scream our own opinions at the top of our lungs, there's never any room for actual discussion. It just ends up with a series of posts of "I think that..." and "In my opinion..." or "Fuck you, I don't think that..."
Ah, the golden age. It was real. Not necessarily guilded, but... Well...
xmetatr0nx said:
NewClassic said:
While i cant speak for everyone...
In my eyes, it doesnt really matter, its not as if this place will fall apart. Its a business and it shall continue until it is no longer economicly viable.
Yes i understand you have your intimate group of people you skype with or whatever. It seems to me that you, and others, are trying too hard to turn this place into some sort of hug time-friends hour where we discuss machiavellian concepts and the meaning of love...give me a break. Everyone comes here for their own reasons, sure the quantity of people who come here shape its values etc etc. Some choose to take it personally and attempt change in some way or another, yet others show up and have their fun and are happy with that. I come back to my business aspect, the more hits and people this place draws the better it is for the entire site as a whole. Would you rather have this place turn into warcry? If i remember correctly everyone there started on this complaining path about the "past" and eventually threw a giant hissy fit...now its a wasteland. Im ranting a bit, regardless. Its just as easy to ignore these things, make a group, or just simply head elsewhere. We all cant live up to peoples expectations of intelligence...and if im honest those standards border on ridiculous. Ive said it so many times before, this place is a video game website, their draws are bad flash animation and an english man reviewing video games with cursing. Maybe im not seeing this utopia people keep painting, there hasnt been much change in my eyes, it all comes and goes. Complaining certainly doesnt change things, neither do these threads that everyone forgets about or ignores. Just accept that the little niche website you joined so very long ago is now a big boy and can take care of its own issues.
I gotta address both of you with this:
The "golden age" that is so often referred to was just a matter of unspoken social rules. Its the little things that make a cordial demeanor, like offering to let someone else go before you through a door, or to speak flatteringly towards your fellow interlocutor.
If those around you reciprecate your politeness, then everyone's all happy and merry. If you're in a group, and everyone notices that one person is taking advantage of this, they may be somehow dealt with.
This is the model of the early Escapist. No one wanted to be the one jerk, and if someone was considered as such, the mods were not in the least bit afraid to take action.
If we return to the hypothetical situation, lets add a significant number of people who are not afraid to accept whatever is offered to them by the politeness of others and run with it. They aren't
technically doing anything wrong- just always taking people up on offers of sharing or assistance, without ever giving the same to others, 'n such.
With so many people not technically doing anything wrong, the group authority can't rightly say that unspecific behavior of half the population is disruptive, and is unable to step in if they follow universal ideals.
The cordial people are left with two choices- either continue to do the nice thing and become the doormat to others, or to go with the flow and snap up any opportunities available.
"This is a gaming site" is true, and probably isn't going to change any time soon. Subtle, unwritten social practices are not etched out, and are by no means easy to moderate. Even things like "post quality" are impossible to truly define. And you're right, xmegatr0nx, this is a part of a business, and yes, by its nature, this forum and its users are transient. Some want to make the IRC/skorgy group out as
the Escapist community, and its not. Between usergroups and a plethora of boards, addressing the "escapist community" is like trying to address the "christian community" or the "british community."
But all I really expect from the Escapist users is that in any social sub-circle, the priority is on promoting a good discussion, or just a good time for everyone involved.