I had originally pre-ordered a copy of the Balls of Steel edition. Luckily I cancelled it and instead reserved a Day 1 rental copy.
MY GOD. This game is just balls.
Like the OP I went in with no expectations for the graphics, I wasn't even sold on the sense of humour but I wanted to give DNF the benefit of the doubt. I haven't been a Duke Nukem fan, mainly out of not playing the games rather than out and out hatred. So I thought I'd represent the new generation of gamers who didn't rely on nostaliga.
I don't think even the darkest shade of rose tinted glasses can cover this game up. Graphics are AWFUL. Don't need to harp on about that but they look a lot like Doom 3's idea of "Make everything glossy and that will make the graphics look good". Actually Doom 3 looks better. MOVING ON.
The sense of humour is just plain bad. Imagine any comedy where the jokes fall flat, not just some of them, ALL of them. This is the Epic movie of games. That's how bad the jokes are. Duke sounds dated and bored. As a character he just is not interesting. Every single line of dialogue that comes out of his stupid mouth sounds EXACTLY THE SAME. He is even less than 1 dimensional. The game touts that ladies want to be with him and guys want to be with him, but even the worst NPCs (and they are awful) have more character than Duke. I'd rather watch the characters in Oblivion talk about Mudcrabs for 10 hours straight than listen to this shit.
Music = generic
Level design = Un-navigable and bland
Weapons = Boring
Enemies = lame and stupid
Ladies and Gentleman, we have a contender for the year's worst game.