I like it.
It's not all that good of a game engine, but I love the world and the quests.
I want someone to make a single-player RuneScape in the style of The Elder Scrolls. It'll never happen, of course, but it'd be pretty cool.
Why do I hate it, though?
I keep quitting and my cousin keeps dragging me back to it trying to get me to PK with him, especially since they brought the Wildy back. I hate PKing.
I hate the players. I hate Dungeoneering. I hate Firemaking. I hate the stupidly steep EXP curve for skills. I hate how I can't open my bank and put new stuff in because I'm not a member anymore.
I hate a lot of things in it, but I still like it overall.
It was my first MMO, and I think it'll end up being one of the ones I keep playing. I'm Devius on there. I have decent stats. Woo.