RWBY review: It's Brawl in the Family

Recommended Videos

Izanagi009_v1legacy

Anime Nerds Unite
Apr 25, 2013
1,460
0
0
Hello and welcome to RWBY where we get our first look at Qrow and Winter

On the animation front, it has degenerated even more. There is now a large amount of shaky cam and still frames to compensate for the fact that the animation has become less fluid and more stop and go; the shaky cam itself reaches the point of nausea inducing as it wildly shifts from one end of the fight to the other with no ability for the eye to keep up. Fight movements have the character poses jump from position to position instead of flowing into each other and movement is wrong with a lot of characters stopping and then moving back. The weapons transformations also aren't integrated into any motion and instead being framed in still shots. There is even one scene where the slash pattern that Qrow does is repeated. All and all, the only parts of the animation that catch your eye are the faults and not the actual animations; the only way the bad animation can be justified is as if the bad fighting is to depict Qrow's cocky nature

Speaking of Qrow, Qrow himself is not a bad character in terms of personality on a conceptual level; he's a cocky drunkard who loves to toy with people during fights but does seem fairly capable. Winter's personality is one that drives me up a wall but I feel it's intentional. She is a high ranking official in Atlas and it shows; her personality is cold and strict even towards her own sister who she expects better from. She does have an impulsive side when Qrow incites her. The two are also voiced fairly well with personality actually being carried through though that comment can actually extend to the rest of the cast now as it seems they have settled into their role.

plotwise, the first half has noting really to discuss. Winter just shows up, some comedy between Winter, Weiss and Ruby occurs revolving around Ruby's out of place nature compared to the formality of Winter and Weiss and then the fight between Qrow and Winter. The second half has more details. Qrow states that he, Ozpin, Glenda, Ironwood and the head of the other academies are part of an unnamed organization that defend the people from Grimm. Qrow also states that the infiltrators that are in the school are "fear itself" and will bring Grimm; Ozpin makes it a point that Ironwood's fleet has made people concerned about what might happen. We then get a small shot of the chess piece symbol that showed when Cinder hacked the communication tower appearing on Ironwood's PDA. It is then shown that that symbol represents a virus that allows Cinder an access point and uses it to set her team up against team CVFY's representatives as the episode ends.

In conclusion, the show's fight animation has gotten worse in Monty's absence but the story is starting to progress faster and may be reaching some point.

Edit: just realized something, Winter uses glyphs just like how Weiss uses it. That makes no scenes because Weiss's glyphs are a semblance and each semblance is supposed to be unique. So if Winter and Weiss both uses glyphs, either the glyphs are not a semblance or semblanaces are not unique.
 

Scarim Coral

Jumped the ship
Legacy
Oct 29, 2010
18,157
2
3
Country
UK
Ok I admit the fight scene were bad in this one as I too notice the slash pattern animation like some cliche anime fight and it did look stiff in that part when Qrow tap on Winter weapon. Also I thought Qrow weapon was suppose to be a scythe but I'm guessing that its hidden form that he was going to unleash before he did the "come at me bro" gesture.

Character wise, yeah I liked Qrow as he's the type who can act big and CAN get away with it! Winter on the other hand reminded me alot of Kuvira from Legend of Korra except she is somewhat inconsistant. Ok so she kinda acted strict toward her sister (which I'm not complaining on given that I'm assuming how unfamily Weiss family are) to the point of critizing her "win" but she strike her when Weiss was given a report than an saying how she's doing health wise??? Also for someone so formal, she did got carry away during the fight like running up that wall!

Also I'm looking forward to next week episode just to see CVFY getting their arse kicked but it's a shame the rabbit girl wasn't chosen in the two tag fight so we can see her actual weapon.

Lastly, I digged the ending tune (I like trance at times) which is alot better than the openning.
 

DirectorK

New member
Aug 22, 2014
86
0
0
Scarim Coral said:
Also I'm looking forward to next week episode just to see CVFY getting their arse kicked but it's a shame the rabbit girl wasn't chosen in the two tag fight so we can see her actual weapon.
........................

(Slowly and painfully face palms myself)

ARE YOU. FUCKING!!! KIDDING ME!!!

First Velvet gets pushed aside at the end of Volume Two and now they're pushing aside again?! Jesus, they might as well say that she doesn't exist at this point.

Anyway, yeah the story does seem to be picking up(finally). Let's hope it actually goes somewhere this time. On a side note, I'm happy to see that Qrow didn't turn into another Spirit Albarn as I dreaded earlier. However, there's always the possibility that that could change in the next few episodes.
 

StormShaun

The Basement has been unleashed!
Feb 1, 2009
6,948
0
0
Well, at least my feeling was right, and that I now believe that the outer combat animation is better. (Minus that Winter slap part)
Then the combat destroyed that feeling... yay~ Also, for some damn reason, when Winter stabbed the building (and the lagged behind part where Qrow stabbed the ground to slow down), it made a "blade impaling flesh" sound, weird.

Character wise.
Ruby seemed more stiff when meeting Winter. Sure, of course that is a good reaction, but I thought Ruby would be more of the quiet kind rather than looking like a doofus. She always seemed to be that kind of character... so ever since her first appearance, it has been a surprise. The good or bad kind, I have no idea.

Weiss was very... excited by her sister, and I have no idea why. We'll probably find out soon.

Winter, I hope will be more than just your average ice queen/corporate high rank, but thanks to Qrow, I believe that she will be more than that. Speaking of the Devil...

Qrow, now this is a character that immediatly gained my interest this episode. In fact, he's entertained me with a couple of lines, and has a damn good reason for doing what he's doing... minus the drinking of course (actually, he might have a reason for that). With both him and Winter, is it very nice to see some professionals in action, even if the animation is still a little inexperienced. For a little nitpicking, they said he was a scythe user, and of course this is explained because Ruby was taught by him and such, but what he used... that was a sword, I'm sure. Unless that last point of the fight was his transformation sequence or something.

Apart from that, as we know, the story is finally picking up. Not bad for the third episode, I only hope that it evolves to something good, along with the characters.

Boy, studying Creative Writing really makes me want to aid some productions.