Scars Unseen said:
Pseudonym said:
If nobody has a better idea I'm still continuing on my quest to kill Armadox. I will repeat myself, his post is the only reason why I ever heard that Revenant might have been the priest.
I have to say that your insistence on continuing to bring that up even after SR himself admitted that he was the one who slipped up and outed himself as the priest is in and of itself suspicious. That Armadox is the person
you saw it posted from first is irrelevant if he isn't the original source.
What does it matter who is the original source of the information? It was spread further by Armadox. Not only that, but it was spread allong with saying he suspected SR of being the lawyer. Something that would be flat out suicidal for the lawyer. Assuming that SR was the priest, a safe bet at that point, doing that puts the priest, hence the spy, hence all of us in great danger.
Tell me this. How would I have known about SR being the priest if not for the posts of people who weren't SR accusing him of being a bad guy when he had just claimed a goodguy role? Because wherever SR slipped up, I didn't see that and thus you could have prevented me from knowing that. If we assume the bad guys might be in the same position I am this means you might have been able to prevent the bad guys from knowing that. If he was a bad guy we could have waited a round and have killed him after that if he hadn't safed the spy by then. Because I looked at the thread prior to armadox' post and I looked at the posts in the serial killer user group. I don't see where SR told anyone he is the priest. If he did so in PM's that's a mistake but those PM's should have remained PM's with the stress on that 'P' until after the priest sacrificed themselves. Or are there other venues of communication where he leaked that info?
All that needed to happen was that the priest would survive for another round or so. It should have been kept as quiet as possible. If you are one of the two bad guys up against 18 good guys, claiming a role you are not is suicidal. I'll link a post by Gritch where he explains this and I'm honestly not sure why anyone wouldn't at least wait until the priest could have revived anyone before they put somebody who was likely the priest in such danger.
http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/362.877540-Serial-Killer-Round-68-Cylon-Invasion-Cycle-3-VOTE-VOTE-VOTE-AVENGE-THE-MEDIC?page=7#22102699
Maybe Armadox judged the situation differently then I would have but I have seen countless people in similar games claim roles and none of them ever lied about it. This game has very few bad guys and a lot of good guys. The idea that SR should be accused of anything at that point assumes that he is an epicly incompetent lawyer or killer and goes against my prior experience with games like these. Maybe you guys' experiences are different and you've been in plenty of games with people falsely claiming roles but for me that is a very rare occurence. Which is why I find accusations in his direction at that point sketchy. It isn't just that I disagree with them, it's that I have a hard time believing somebody who has played at least four more of these games (Armadox has played serial killer since at least round 64 if I have dug correctly) would do that. They might, maybe Armadox just judged the situation differently than I would have but I'm not sure I believe that.
Armadox said:
You've been gunning for me since the beginning, and I think even if I had said nothing it'd have been the same.
I want to draw attention to the fact that either Armadox doesn't factcheck himself or this is a flat-out lie. I looked through my posts and I defy you to find any suspicion or even mention of Armadox until page 9. You posted your suspicions of SR on page 7. I see one other possible explanation for this mistake but I'll wait for Armadox to bring that up if he can think of it.
At this point I give Armadox at least a 50/50 shot of being a bad guy. There is nobody else whom I mistrust to that level so I think I'm going to keep voting for him until he is dead or a better suspect shows himself.