Lil devils x said:
This is a hard path to walk, but not just because of the ethical questions (like people sneaking it into each other's food or something). It's also because it will reveal a lot of twisted logic.
On one hand, people as a whole
really, really enjoy being told that things are "genetic" or "caused by a chemical imbalance." It alleviates any sense of responsibility (note well that I did not say "fault"). This is why, nine times in ten, someone won't just say, "I'm sad." They'll say, "I'm clinically depressed," even with no credible diagnosis. Adding that qualifier to the beginning is a way of letting you know that you can't argue with them, and that they are automatically worse off than you, with your "normal" depression.
At the same time, if we keep insisting that everything is genetic or a result of a chemical imbalance,
people are going to find ways to manipulate it. Furthermore, we will remove all sense of responsibility. Oh, you raped someone? Chemical imbalance. Can't show up to work on time? It's genetic. You're just a plain old jerk to everyone you meet? Not your fault--you were born that way!
There are two sides to everything--the biological, and the psychological. When we
only focus on one (whichever it is), we handicap ourselves in ways we can't begin to imagine.
If everything is biological, then there's absolutely nothing wrong with forcing a change in someone's biology, right? After all, they'll
believe that it's what they really want, because biologically that's what their body will tell them. No harm, no foul.
If everything is psychological, then there's no reason to medicate people with severe problems. They're obviously just not trying hard enough, right?
In both camps, you've got people trying to "figure out" people. The inevitable result, once either side feels they've got us all mapped, is that people will be treated as something
less. This pill could represent one extreme, but overreacting to it just represents the other. And that's the thing about balance beams--you're hurt exactly the same if fall off
either side.