Madame_le_Flour said:
Dirty Hipsters said:
Perhaps that would be true for later parts of the game, but when someone is having difficulty just finding the first door, they might need a little visual direction to get them off the ground (hell, until I finally caved and looked up a guide I was trying to go through the Catacombs first and didn't even see the path up to the Undead Burgh, without watching a guide and having visual reference for where the fuck I needed to go). Also, ENB's walkthrough (especially the first episode) is custom tailored to explaining how the mechanics work to new players, and how to get the most out of them; things that, lets be honest, are explained fairly poorly in the game itself (it took me until playthough 2.5 before I figured out how weapon scaling worked).
There's absolutely nothing stopping a new player who doesn't want to spoil themselves from just watching the part of the video they need and then shutting it off and going blind from there.
Dark Souls is one of my favorite games and I wouldn't want to ruin it for anyone, but sometimes you just need proper visual feedback, even if it's just to find a door behind some pots.
Oh yeah, you should definitely look up guides on the game mechanics, since those are explained incredibly poorly (took me forever to figure out how weapon upgrading worked in this game, and I actually got some help on this very forum), but there are guides on youtube that explain those mechanics better than ENB does, and which aren't walkthroughs.
Speaking of which, I highly recommend vageta311's parry guide:
Also, I wish you hadn't told him about the boulder trap. You're supposed to get hit by that, every player gets hit by that their first time, it's part of the experience and helps teach you that stairs aren't your friend. I tried to be kind of vague in my explanation, basically just telling him where the door was in the boss room, and emphasizing that you need estus flasks so that he would keep exploring until he found them, you told him everything to expect in the first area.
Granted, there are certain things that do totally need to be explained to people in detail, like how to get back to the undead asylum from firelink (I refuse to believe ANYONE figured that out legitimately), but the tutorial area is not one of those things.