So i started writing...

Recommended Videos

Oliver Pink

New member
Apr 3, 2010
455
0
0
Jewrean said:
Zeeky_Santos said:
Isn't there like some sort of rule against posting your works of writing for speculation? I swear this came up a while back. oh well, never mind.
I just got put on probation for posting my own music and asking for advice on it. Oh well... I guess its a forum rule to not be allowed to better ourselves here. Let's just continue with the only thing we can do instead!

'HURP DE DURP Justin Bieber HURP Banana why all the hate on HURP DE DIDDLY DUMB'
There we go, accurate simulation of the usual un-moderated drivel seen on this pitiful forum. If people can't submit something they have created for advice then what is the fucking point of the forum in the fucking first place?

BTW not angry at you.
Hmm, I sincerely hope that isn't the case. I was given fairly explicit instructions about where to post my writing, so if it lands me in any trouble I shall be quite miffed to say the least.
 

Phoenix09215

New member
Dec 24, 2008
714
0
0
Hmmm The Great One sounds a little cheesy... But besides that its was pritty good. If this is the first time you have tried to seriously write something then its not bad at all :) But you can only get better with practice so keep it up!
 

Slash Dementia

New member
Apr 6, 2009
2,692
0
0
The tone that is given off at the start is good, but there's a lot of repetition throughout the story. Vary your words (something that's hard for me), like when you use "making it seem" twice; try to use that only once, and merge the two together.
Try to leave some space between events--you don't want to rush things, because that's when your ideas might run out, and you find out that parts of your story are too short when they can be expanded on.

I liked the_root_of_all_evil's advice and his criticism, too.

There's not much else I can say, but the writing is good, and so is the style. Just keep writing and editing. Show some friends, show us, ask for advice from a lit. teacher. All criticism is good and can only help you improve (unless of course it's some to discourage you or pointlessly rip on your writing).
 

Oliver Pink

New member
Apr 3, 2010
455
0
0
RAKtheUndead said:
Oliver Pink said:
Jewrean said:
Zeeky_Santos said:
Isn't there like some sort of rule against posting your works of writing for speculation? I swear this came up a while back. oh well, never mind.
I just got put on probation for posting my own music and asking for advice on it. Oh well... I guess its a forum rule to not be allowed to better ourselves here. Let's just continue with the only thing we can do instead!

'HURP DE DURP Justin Bieber HURP Banana why all the hate on HURP DE DIDDLY DUMB'
There we go, accurate simulation of the usual un-moderated drivel seen on this pitiful forum. If people can't submit something they have created for advice then what is the fucking point of the forum in the fucking first place?

BTW not angry at you.
Hmm, I sincerely hope that isn't the case. I was given fairly explicit instructions about where to post my writing, so if it lands me in any trouble I shall be quite miffed to say the least.
As I've mentioned, I've made a few story-based threads before [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/18.105011-Of-Questionable-Contact-A-Hard-SF-Story], as well as commented on more than a few by other people, and people don't tend to get punished for them.

By the way, use that link as an example of what not to do when you're writing a story.
I'll freely admit I'm quite new to the Escapist as far as actual participation goes, so I appreciate all the advice I can get. So thanks very much!

Having said that, we should probably get back on topic.
 

Mr Pantomime

New member
Jul 10, 2010
1,650
0
0
Prologue's a bit short, but i'm loving the detail you put in there. Really lets me imagine the scene you're portraying.

In a dark cathedral, high upon a hilltop, a woman's cries were lost in the torrent of rain and thunder. I like this line, but Cathedral is a little odd. Small Church maybe?
The midwives and the doctors did all they could to help, but the woman knew her time was coming. With a final push she delivered the child into the world, and with her dying breath whispered Expand on this, describe the inside of the Cathedral, the woman giving birth, the doctors and midwives, the lighting in the room even. Paint me a word picture
"Go forth, my son, Gariah..." This line is lame, its not something id expect a mother to say either.
And with a final flash of lightning, the woman was no more. I like this line, but you should describe her final breaths in more detail.

Still, I really want to read more
Sorry if i come across as a prick.
 

Oh That Dude

New member
Nov 22, 2009
461
0
0
It's nice, also I have a question to writers of thEscapist, is there a poetry themed user group to be found?
 

TheDrunkNinja

New member
Jun 12, 2009
1,875
0
0
It's fairly good. Well written, if that's what you're asking for. However, I can't even comment on the concept or whatever idea you're trying to write considering how vague the opening is. Apparently, one of those destiny-babies was born today. That's all I got really. You can't even truly figure that the baby being born will be our main character. You see how little you gave us to work with?

It's important to work out the plot before putting anything finite down. People in the education system would tell you that you should get your ideas out and just start writing. Well, a creative writing story is different than an essay. What you need to do is to start writing, but whatever you're writing will not be your story. Write you're entire concept of the story you want to convey out in the plainest terms. When you're finished, write it again adding specified details. Plan out plot points and do entire character studies for your characters. It all can't just be from your head.

From what I can tell, you plan to get this all out in one go. Write out one page or one chapter at a time and build on that. I figure that simply because I used to do the same thing when I was a freshman in high school. Well, that's really what you can't do. You can't just start writing your story and try to sound as fancy and well-written as possible. That comes after you get your story out on paper. Seriously, multiple rewrites are your friend, and I don't mean making small changes. I mean, blank paper in front of you and completely rewrite your story. I know it doesn't sound fun, but that's the way you need to do it in creative writing. And, this subject is a creative writing matter, not composition. Those are two different classes. Perhaps if you tell us the actual story you wish to write, I could help you better than with just this vague opening.
 

The_Blue_Rider

New member
Sep 4, 2009
2,190
0
0
Fire Daemon said:
Keep in mind I'm not an author. If you want advice on writing you might want to hear what some other authors have said. Anyway...

If you want to turn this into a novel than you need to really, really want it to be a novel. A novel isn't like a flower because it doesn't grow itself, it's probably closer to a wrestling match because you constantly need to be on top of it, trying to get it pinned down. If you give up you've lost and the book isn't written, so you really have to want it.

As for what you've given, it's alright but it has to be longer, I think. The first paragraph in a book is important because it's here that people decide whether they want to put in the time to read it, but I've seen so many people write very, very short chapters that would never actually be published by themselves and it pisses me off. The first page of my copy of the prologue of The Lord of The Rings has about 400 or so words and I'm not saying to go and write LoTR, but you have to put in more stuff to a chapter.

If you have trouble with length aim for a short story or maybe draw a brief story arc and then seperate that into chapters and then set out to write each chapter. Try to find your own way of writing if your current way is too difficult.

For the story, doesn't seem that interesting to me, sorry. I don't really know much about the world you've set up and you haven't really given me any reason to care. I feel that I've heard this before and I don't really want to hear it again. I think starting with a babies brith and making a deal about that is somewhat cliche, it would be better if a prologue would describe the world and then link into the childs birth somewhat. Also, if you want to make a messiah story read good examples of those stories done right. Dune, is a good one and so is the Bible I suppose.
Cool, this is a very rough draft so the end product will look quite different, i think i need to have a look at where the story actually leads before i write anymore