Honest question because I'm not a metal fan and I don't really know, but do you (as a metal fan) feel that there is a need for that many different subgenre's in the overall metal genre? At some point isn't it sort of overkill? Or do you feel that each of those is legitaately different enough to stand in it's own separate sub-genre?SantoUno said:Thrash metal: Destruction - Bestial Invasion
Power metal: Stratovarius - Black Diamond
Melodic Death Metal: Arch Enemy - The Immortal
Death Metal: Hypocrisy - Penetralia
Doom Metal: October Tide - 12 Days Of Rain
Technical Death Metal: Atheist - ...And The Psychic Saw
Progressive Metal: Dream Theatre - Pull Me Under
Viking Metal - Equilibrium - Wingthor's Hammer
Folk Metal - Ensiferum - Lai Lai Hei
You REALLY want to avoid that attitude on here.Prtyclever1337 said:Eminem - Beautiful
That is, and will always be, what hip-hop should be. It's perfect. Gtfo if you don't think so.
It's overkill for a general conversation with non-metalheads. However, within the "metal community" people have very different tastes based on the specific subgenre. It helps when you want to recommend music to a fellow metalhead friend. If they like Metallica or Children of Bodom, you don't recommend them Slipknot or Korn. You recommend them Megadeth or In Flames.AgentNein said:Honest question because I'm not a metal fan and I don't really know, but do you (as a metal fan) feel that there is a need for that many different subgenre's in the overall metal genre? At some point isn't it sort of overkill? Or do you feel that each of those is legitaately different enough to stand in it's own separate sub-genre?SantoUno said:Thrash metal: Destruction - Bestial Invasion
Power metal: Stratovarius - Black Diamond
Melodic Death Metal: Arch Enemy - The Immortal
Death Metal: Hypocrisy - Penetralia
Doom Metal: October Tide - 12 Days Of Rain
Technical Death Metal: Atheist - ...And The Psychic Saw
Progressive Metal: Dream Theatre - Pull Me Under
Viking Metal - Equilibrium - Wingthor's Hammer
Folk Metal - Ensiferum - Lai Lai Hei
I ask because I love punk rock, and there are tons of sub genres in punk as well. You've got thrash punk, you've got street punk, oi, gutter punk, pop punk, commercial pop punk (two very different things), hardcore punk, cali surf punk, psychobilly (essentially rockabilly with Misfits sensibilities), Trash punk, irish pub punk (which is more often than not not really that irish so much as it's bands from boston that fancy themselves as irish), folk punk, cow punk, and I could honestly go on. These are all seen by some as legitimate, but I feel that most of them are completely useless distinctions.
By the way as I've said I don't dig much metal but That folk metal song is freaking awesome. Thanks for that.
To an extent. I feel it's just as often used for divisive purposes as well (at least is my experience).ReincarnatedFTP said:It's overkill for a general conversation with non-metalheads. However, within the "metal community" people have very different tastes based on the specific subgenre. It helps when you want to recommend music to a fellow metalhead friend. If they like Metallica or Children of Bodom, you don't recommend them Slipknot or Korn. You recommend them Megadeth or In Flames.AgentNein said:Honest question because I'm not a metal fan and I don't really know, but do you (as a metal fan) feel that there is a need for that many different subgenre's in the overall metal genre? At some point isn't it sort of overkill? Or do you feel that each of those is legitaately different enough to stand in it's own separate sub-genre?SantoUno said:Thrash metal: Destruction - Bestial Invasion
Power metal: Stratovarius - Black Diamond
Melodic Death Metal: Arch Enemy - The Immortal
Death Metal: Hypocrisy - Penetralia
Doom Metal: October Tide - 12 Days Of Rain
Technical Death Metal: Atheist - ...And The Psychic Saw
Progressive Metal: Dream Theatre - Pull Me Under
Viking Metal - Equilibrium - Wingthor's Hammer
Folk Metal - Ensiferum - Lai Lai Hei
I ask because I love punk rock, and there are tons of sub genres in punk as well. You've got thrash punk, you've got street punk, oi, gutter punk, pop punk, commercial pop punk (two very different things), hardcore punk, cali surf punk, psychobilly (essentially rockabilly with Misfits sensibilities), Trash punk, irish pub punk (which is more often than not not really that irish so much as it's bands from boston that fancy themselves as irish), folk punk, cow punk, and I could honestly go on. These are all seen by some as legitimate, but I feel that most of them are completely useless distinctions.
By the way as I've said I don't dig much metal but That folk metal song is freaking awesome. Thanks for that.
Someone who likes Dio is more likely to like power metal.
I imagine it's the same in the "punk community".
I understand what you mean, hardly a music thread can go by without someone going "nu-metal is for fourteen year old noobs" or "death metal sounds like shit why don't you listen to power metal with clean vocals lulzors".AgentNein said:To an extent. I feel it's just as often used for divisive purposes as well (at least is my experience).ReincarnatedFTP said:It's overkill for a general conversation with non-metalheads. However, within the "metal community" people have very different tastes based on the specific subgenre. It helps when you want to recommend music to a fellow metalhead friend. If they like Metallica or Children of Bodom, you don't recommend them Slipknot or Korn. You recommend them Megadeth or In Flames.AgentNein said:Honest question because I'm not a metal fan and I don't really know, but do you (as a metal fan) feel that there is a need for that many different subgenre's in the overall metal genre? At some point isn't it sort of overkill? Or do you feel that each of those is legitaately different enough to stand in it's own separate sub-genre?SantoUno said:Thrash metal: Destruction - Bestial Invasion
Power metal: Stratovarius - Black Diamond
Melodic Death Metal: Arch Enemy - The Immortal
Death Metal: Hypocrisy - Penetralia
Doom Metal: October Tide - 12 Days Of Rain
Technical Death Metal: Atheist - ...And The Psychic Saw
Progressive Metal: Dream Theatre - Pull Me Under
Viking Metal - Equilibrium - Wingthor's Hammer
Folk Metal - Ensiferum - Lai Lai Hei
I ask because I love punk rock, and there are tons of sub genres in punk as well. You've got thrash punk, you've got street punk, oi, gutter punk, pop punk, commercial pop punk (two very different things), hardcore punk, cali surf punk, psychobilly (essentially rockabilly with Misfits sensibilities), Trash punk, irish pub punk (which is more often than not not really that irish so much as it's bands from boston that fancy themselves as irish), folk punk, cow punk, and I could honestly go on. These are all seen by some as legitimate, but I feel that most of them are completely useless distinctions.
By the way as I've said I don't dig much metal but That folk metal song is freaking awesome. Thanks for that.
Someone who likes Dio is more likely to like power metal.
I imagine it's the same in the "punk community".
This. Or maybe Sell Out. Or possibly The Impression That I Get by The Mighty Mighty Bosstones. Third Wave Ska is just awesome.Vanguard_Ex said:Everything Sucks, by Reel Big Fish
You are so wrong it's not funny, Ghost of Perdition defines Prog Metal, saying Pull Me Under is like searching Progressive Metal on google and using the very first one that comes up, there is no way that is the defining song.SantoUno said:Progressive Metal: Dream Theatre - Pull Me Under
Oh mai gosh I'm that wrong?? /sarcasmShredHead said:You are so wrong it's not funny, Ghost of Perdition defines Prog Metal, saying Pull Me Under is like searching Progressive Metal on google and using the very first one that comes up, there is no way that is the defining song.SantoUno said:Progressive Metal: Dream Theatre - Pull Me Under
dude, it's either reign in blood, or raining blood, you don't get to throw them into one word.awes0mepenguin said:Reigning Blood sums up thrash metal pretty well IMO