Chapper said:
Highlander (The One) - Lost Horizon
Crazy vocals, not for beginners
Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bj5PWLXC7Qo
Part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUHnt9ubjwk&feature=related
... So, how would you actually turn that into a song you can
just sing?
Even if you cut out all the guitar solos, the singer's mostly singing around the guitar. His bit doesn't form enough of a coherent melody to stand on its own, just like, despite their important role in creating the feel of the whole piece, playing
just the drum part of most metal songs is going to give you incoherent trash. Now, with some other genres of music, the singer could cheat a bit by scat-singing some of the instrumental part, but you can't really scat-sing metal guitar.
Compare that to, say, Vienna Teng's "The Tower" (link to file, if anyone cares [http://viennateng.com/listen/]), which is representative of a very different genre, the modern "singer-songwriter" style piece. That's a song where the vocals are really the mainstay. Removing the instruments would definitely change the feel of the music, since they're used very carefully to accentuate and punctuate the lyrics, but it would still be a whole, coherent song.