SOPA hearing yesterday: There are not enough /facepalms in the world

Recommended Videos
Nov 12, 2010
239
0
0
Otaku World Order said:
Ekit said:
But it's only being censored in America, right? So I have nohing to worry about?
Hey, I live in Canada, but I'm worried about it. Partly because I don't want our current government getting any ideas, but because I value everyone's freedom. People who don't understand the internet should not be making decisions about regulating it. Period.
That's the problem with politics: incompetent people making decisions that are absolute and the democracy part... is just for the show.
 

SenseOfTumour

New member
Jul 11, 2008
4,514
0
0
Monsterfurby said:
Ah, the unadulterated tenor of "they are old people".

Seriously folks - the problem with the American system is not the fact that "you have to be old to be a politician", it's that nobody goes into politics until they are 30+ and have already had a traditional career. This is not only to be blamed on the system - it is very much a result of the youth being raised to not give a crap.

Folks, I am 23 and European. I have held elected office on university level four times (twice as undergrad student rep, once as member of the student guild/parliament, once as postgrad student rep) in two different countries, on party level twice (regional representative) and on communal level once (local council). This is *not* because I am in any way rich (I am certainly not, and neither is my family) or want to make a living as a politician. It is just because I CARE about the decisions politicians make, and the only way for me to influence them is to play the same game.

In the US, people seem to be raised to stay away from politics. Where is the cure to the systemic illness going to come from if not from young people participating in an open and progressive political dialogue? It is not "us versus them" as much as "them, period." To change it, you must become "them."

tl/dr: if you want to CHANGE POLITICS - GO INTO POLITICS. It does not have to be a full-time job.
Could we just murder a bad one instead? Would be the same net effect, surely, minus one bad one against plus one good one?

Only downside is there's a hundred more goons ready to take the bad one's place. We sure as hell are NOT overstocked on good, thoughtful politicians.

In all seriousness, kudos to you sir, in an age when we can't get enough young people to even vote, it's great to know there's some trying to get genuinely involved.

Sure , younger politicians tend to get mocked, but then so do older ones.

At least you'll be capable of a sex scandal without pills :)
 

maxmanrules

New member
Mar 30, 2011
235
0
0
Qitz said:
Well according to the email I just got from Reddits petition, they cancelled their vote and disbanded for the year.

BREAKING NEWS: Because of immense public pressure, the House Judiciary Committee cancelled their vote on the bill that would kill Internet innovation and free speech -- and adjourned for the rest of the year!

Over the last 36 hours, over 97,000 people like you signed our joint petition with reddit against this bill, and thousands more called their representatives. The Internet fought back to protect the Internet -- and we won, for now.

We now need to assemble our Internet army for next year, when this bill will come up again. Can you help us reach 100,000 signers on the petition?

Click here to spread the VICTORY! news and share the grassroots petition on Facebook.

(Then, pass this email on to friends so they can sign the petition here.)

Our petition got a ton of attention in Washington, DC. Here's what some leading news outlets reported yesterday:

Washington Post: "The Progressive Change Campaign Committee and Reddit have been pushing a campaign arguing that SOPA, as written, would harm future innovation."

Roll Call: "A flurry of liberal and conservative groups issued last-minute pleas in the hours before the House Judiciary Committee prepared to vote on its latest version of a controversial intellectual property bill, known as the Stop Online Piracy Act.

'Join @reddit and PCCC (@BoldProgressive) in saving the Internet!' the Progressive Change Campaign Committee, a liberal advocacy group, tweeted urging followers to sign an online petition opposing the bill. The missive was paired with a letter signed by the founders of Twitter, YouTube and other tech giants."

But the fight is far from over -- big corporations are still pushing hard for this bill. We won the battle with today's delay, but we still have to win the war against Internet censorship.

Click here to spread today's VICTORY news and share the petition with your friends on Facebook.

(Then, pass this email on to friends so they can sign the petition here.)

Thanks for taking action. Our action together made a big difference!

-- Jason Rosenbaum, Progressive Change Campaign Committee (J-Ro on reddit) and Erik Martin, reddit General Manager
So the battle was won but the war may have to wage on.
Fuck yeah! Suck it congressmen and your stupid retardedness.
Now, onto protect IP!
 

Something Amyss

Aswyng and Amyss
Dec 3, 2008
24,759
0
0
McNinja said:
Do you know how much America hates people who know things?
Not America in general, just the government, mainly because the old dudes think no one else knows anything and that they are the best at deciding what is right for the people they represent.[/quote]

Actually, America in general REALLY hates smart people. This is how those old dudes got into power. This is also why McCain/Palin was considered a viable ticket, Why Bush got elected (Among other things, Gore was deemed too intellectual), why Bachmann was considered viable for even a milisecond, etc.

Intelligence is bad. We carry our high school mentality of "NEEEEEEEEEEEEERDS!" Into the voting booth and shit on people whose IQ is higher than their shoe size.

Even Kerry was "too intellectual," and he wasn't even particularly BRIGHT! Our criteria for "too smart" is "can find Canadia on the map. And misspells it as 'Canada.'"
 

UrieHusky

New member
Sep 16, 2011
260
0
0
I don't think it's funny at all to be honest.

If this bill and the protect IP bill doesn't pass and gets buried under mountains of public disapproval I'm going to laugh about this till the cows come home, but at this point it's still a major threat to our freedom on the internet.

The fact that material that has no copyrighted material can be taken down just because universal media doesn't want it there scares the living daylights out of me because this can easily extend to those making videos expressing their opinion, the simple act of expressing our selves over websites like youtube will be controlled.

So as stupid as these people are, it's not a laughing matter just yet, not till this is put behind us.

But that's my opinion you don't have to share it.
 

Firerush

New member
May 19, 2009
38
0
0
I've been thinking about this for a long time and honestly I think there's only one solution, there needs to be an armed uprising or revlution.

Yes it's extreme, yes it's over the top, and yes it will cause a huge series of problems, but you know what? If idiots in the US congress who know jack all about the internet and are jsut taking bribes to censor it by corporations who want to turn the country into an distopian police state oligarchy then it's time to stop messing aroung and get serious!

I can't do jack all because I'm in Canada and work part time and can barely afford my rent let alone a trip to the USA to organize and raise such an action so please everyone here, do this! This. Madness. Has. To. Stop!

I'm begging you, anyone with any amount of influence, get together and march tot he congress or anywhere, get peopel who keep saying "nothing passes in america, things will just keep delaying until it passes into obscurity" to open theri eyes and admit that they don't know everything about the government.

Please, I want to do something but I'm powerless here, I'm stuck in Canada, show those idiots that we can stop them, do whatever it takes! WHATEVER IT TAKES!
 

Something Amyss

Aswyng and Amyss
Dec 3, 2008
24,759
0
0
UrieHusky said:
If this bill and the protect IP bill doesn't pass and gets buried under mountains of public disapproval I'm going to laugh about this till the cows come home, but at this point it's still a major threat to our freedom on the internet.
If only such concern was actually leveled at concern for the provisions within the military commissions act which will violate both the sixth amendment and the posse comitatus act.

It's like if it doesn't threaten Youtube, nobody cares.
 

CrazyGirl17

I am a banana!
Sep 11, 2009
5,141
0
0
marioandsonic said:
If this bill passes, then I think Yahtzee said it best:

"THERE IS NO MIDDLE FINGER BIG ENOUGH!"
And if it does pass (God forbid), here's an appropriate paraphrasing: "Well done you miserable old FUCKS!"

Monsterfurby said:
While I'm normally not a big fan of politics (due to my policy of "don't trust anyone in a position of power")... if I have to vote to avoid these acts from coming to pass, then so be it. Besides, my folks keep telling me I should at least get more involved...

Firerush said:
Super Snip!
Personally, I'm all for this. Either that, or leaving the country. Yeah, it might be an overreaction, but hell if I care...
 
Apr 28, 2008
14,634
0
0
Sporky111 said:
I'm Canadian and I fucking hate SOPA. I can't do anything to fight it! I just have to sit up here and watch and hope that it goes alright, because America seems to be trying to turn itself into some dystopian horror.
leet_x1337 said:
Same here, except I'm Australian, so I have to sit down here and watch and hope.
AM I FUNNY YET
Well, there's this [http://americancensorship.org/modal/state-dept-petition/index.html]. Not sure how much it'll matter, but it's something.
 

UrieHusky

New member
Sep 16, 2011
260
0
0
Zachary Amaranth said:
If only such concern was actually leveled at concern for the provisions within the military commissions act which will violate both the sixth amendment and the posse comitatus act.

It's like if it doesn't threaten Youtube, nobody cares.
That concerns me far more, believe me.
But I'm not in america so there's nothing I can do about any of these things, still, I'm not sure why SOPA is getting so much more attention than a more physical limitation of freedom but hey, I gave up on trying to understand humanity long ago.
 

darksuccubus

New member
Jan 11, 2011
110
0
0
It does piss me off even though I', not from USA. Lots of awesome reviewers that live in America (TGWTG, Spoony, Angry Joe etc) will lose their jobs. And it's actually frightening to see how government can do this even though everyone opposes this bill. Kinda makes you think we're getting closer to the Big Brother regime.
 

Rikkano

New member
May 29, 2011
79
0
0
Ekit said:
But it's only being censored in America, right? So I have nohing to worry about?
I recall the bill allowing a certain company to shut down cites promoting, harbouring or, the worst, suspected of harbouring pirates. Which means this can still harm us non-americans.
 
Apr 28, 2008
14,634
0
0
Zachary Amaranth said:
UrieHusky said:
If this bill and the protect IP bill doesn't pass and gets buried under mountains of public disapproval I'm going to laugh about this till the cows come home, but at this point it's still a major threat to our freedom on the internet.
If only such concern was actually leveled at concern for the provisions within the military commissions act which will violate both the sixth amendment and the posse comitatus act.

It's like if it doesn't threaten Youtube, nobody cares.
Didn't Obama veto that? Or say he would? That's why I haven't been following it as muhc, I thought he had it covered.

Or did he change his stance on that?

Robert Ewing said:
didn't they postpone the bill because of a huge popular backlash?
They did, but then they quietly announced that the markup resumes one the 21st, when most will most likely be busy with family on the holidays.
 

Something Amyss

Aswyng and Amyss
Dec 3, 2008
24,759
0
0
UrieHusky said:
That concerns me far more, believe me.
But I'm not in america so there's nothing I can do about any of these things, still, I'm not sure why SOPA is getting so much more attention than a more physical limitation of freedom but hey, I gave up on trying to understand humanity long ago.
It's not so much whether it concerns you or whether you can do anything, it's the fact that this is getting buried under a major pile of unpopularity while the MCA 2012 is getting almost ignored.

I know why one is more popular. One deals with the internet, and the other deals with human rights. In that competition, internet wins.

Irridium said:
Didn't Obama veto that? Or say he would? That's why I haven't been following it as muhc, I thought he had it covered.

Or did he change his stance on that?
Not following it is kind of the problem in the first place. :p

You see, Obama vowed to veto it based on the fact that it stepped on the powers of the Executive branch, not because of the "detainment without trial" clause, nor the "this means Americans, too" clause.

So he didn't even really change his stance. He vowed to veto it, they changed the part he objected to, and now he's withdrawn his objections and the problems still remain.

He was outraged because it impacted him, not because human rights are at stake.
 
Apr 28, 2008
14,634
0
0
Zachary Amaranth said:
Not following it is kind of the problem in the first place. :p

You see, Obama vowed to veto it based on the fact that it stepped on the powers of the Executive branch, not because of the "detainment without trial" clause, nor the "this means Americans, too" clause.

So he didn't even really change his stance. He vowed to veto it, they changed the part he objected to, and now he's withdrawn his objections and the problems still remain.

He was outraged because it impacted him, not because human rights are at stake.


I don't know what's worse. The fact that this actually happened or the fact that I don't find it too surprising.
 
Dec 27, 2010
814
0
0
HerbertTheHamster said:
this is because America is a democracy you guys
Correction, it's a republic, which is both a curse and a blessing. If it were a democracy it would come to a referendum, like the Republic of Ireland (which is pretty counter-intuitive when you think about it).

OT: Unfortunately it seems like this will actually happen, one way of the other. If it fails, then then most of them will back Protect IP. If that fails then a barely amended version of this will come back. If that fails then a barely amended version of PIPA will come back, and so on and so on. Best hope, something else comes along the fascists will want to ruin.
 

Frostbite3789

New member
Jul 12, 2010
1,778
0
0
lunncal said:
Well, at first I was kind of terrified that this bill was actually even being considered.

Then I looked up the pro-SOPA ads I've heard people talking about, and now I just can't stop laughing. They're hilarious. Hilariously terrifying.
... Now I don't know what to feel.
Does one say, "SOPA: It'll clean the internet"? If not, what the hell? They're missing out an easy one.

This [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVVbVCAncLM] is what I imagine will happen if this passes. (From the beginning of the video, to about 20ish seconds.)
 

Something Amyss

Aswyng and Amyss
Dec 3, 2008
24,759
0
0
Irridium said:
I don't know what's worse. The fact that this actually happened or the fact that I don't find it too surprising.
I'd say the latter, but maybe that's just me. That this sort of thing has happened enough to make it commonplace is far more horrible to me.

A shame Obama isn't that hardcore lefty the Republicans were foaming at the mouth about. Instead, we get a guy continuing Bush-era policies of bailouts, socialism for the rich (and only the rich), erosion of freedoms (and the document the President is sword to protect specifically), etc. Hell, even his health care proposals were based on those of such liberal thinkers as Mitt Romney and Bob Dole.
 

Megumi0505

New member
Dec 7, 2011
41
0
0
NameIsRobertPaulson said:
Megumi0505 said:
Our government has fucked us and unless there's riots in the streets, I doubt anyone in congress is going to care. Since the media stations aren't covering this at all, there are too many people who simply don't know about it. I feel sorry for those poor ignorant folk for by the time they actually shut down social media, it will be too late to even find info about SOPA on the net because most of the sites discussing it have forums or blogs which will surely be shut down.
We tried that. They called it OWS and made it look like they were a bunch of free-loading hobos.

OT: SOPA will be very bad... if enforced. In most cases, it would cost more money to prosecute the YouTube user making CoD videos then would be retained by letting him go. It's all political gibberish to make it look like they're not wasting tax payer time and tax payer money in Congress.
Corporate run government is exactly what the Occupy movement was trying to fight peacefully. They went about it all wrong though, they didn't have a leader so there was no one to negotiate with on behalf of the group. They should have taken a hint from the Civil Rights movements and had someone like MLK to lead them. With no one to take the fall for them, police just started arresting protesters.

When I said riots, I didn't mean the Occupy movement I meant something like Vancouver where they turned over cars and set fire to them. If non-violence ain't working, there's always violence =P