Spike VGA's Are Absolutely Irrelevant

Recommended Videos

mar4511

New member
Oct 17, 2011
24
0
0
Wait, you are glad that people who know nothing about games are voting which games are the best? Who the hell are you? Bobby Kotick? No one in their right mind would take the VGA's seriously, and especially nobody in the industry would take it seriously. They are trash.
 

Scizophrenic Llama

Is in space!
Dec 5, 2007
1,147
0
0
NuclearShadow said:
Also The Witcher 2 was on both PC and Xbox 360, how does it make sense to complain that game didn't get a nomination and then turn around and claim cross platform games should not be nominated?
The Witcher 2 hasn't been released on the 360 yet, there was no real date set for it's release and now it's stuck in legal limbo thanks to Namco-Bandai. So it can't be counted towards the 360.
 

RatRace123

Elite Member
Dec 1, 2009
6,651
0
41
Not completely true, the VGAs also air debut trailers for upcoming, or even previously unknown games.

That's the only reason I care about them at all. Beyond that though, yeah. Spike has as many credentials for judging videogames as MTV does for judging movies.
 

Jennacide

New member
Dec 6, 2007
1,019
0
0
NuclearShadow said:
mar4511 said:
there is a lot of rage regarding the inclusion of cross platform games on the award list, such as Portal 2, being nominated for 360 GOTY, when Valve has always been PC based since its inception.
I am not sure why a cross platforming game should be unable to win awards. Also The Witcher 2 was on both PC and Xbox 360, how does it make sense to complain that game didn't get a nomination and then turn around and claim cross platform games should not be nominated?
Reading comprehension, DO YOU KNOW IT?

He asked why Witcher 2 isn't up for RPG OF THE YEAR, not 360 exclusive. And the Portal 2 as best 360 game is highly suspect, since even Valve admits it's the weakest version, since it uses the Portal 1 engine. This is because MS wouldn't allow Steam structure, which Portal 2 relies on, so they ported the 2 assets into the engine for 1 and implemented the new stuff like gels. (It's why stuff like portal dancing still works in 360 but nowhere else)

A better example of the irrelevance of the VGAs is that Minecraft is up AGAIN for best Indie game, when it was up last year. They let a fucking beta version go up for an award. (Which the game claims to be gold, but is still a fucking alpha)
 

Scrustle

New member
Apr 30, 2011
2,031
0
0
True. I voted on them myself, and the categories I missed were often ones which included Skyward Sword. I'd love to give the game my vote, but so far I've only played 2 hours of it so far. I can't vote it with so little experience with the game. Although I think it's pretty safe to still vote it as best Wii game. That's obvious.
 

AnarchistAbe

The Original RageQuit Rebel
Sep 10, 2009
389
0
0
NuclearShadow said:
if by any chance a cross platform game was so epic that it won the hearts of all and was paraded as one of the greatest games of all time, what harm would it do to have it win the awards?
I will answer this simply: Because it would be boring! The show is supposed to entertain us. I've seen games clean house, and it's not entertaining to watch (in my opinion). It's just like "Oh, great! They're going to win...again..."

NuclearShadow said:
The game is indeed on the platform and therefor being capable of being the best game that platform has to offer.
That is probably the best argument that I hear for justification!
 

Erttheking

Member
Legacy
Oct 5, 2011
10,845
1
3
Country
United States
PEOPLE HAVE DIFFERENT OPINIONS FROM YOU? Oh dear lord, CALL THE POLICE! A MAN IS UPSET THAT PEOPLE LIKE DRAGON AGE 2! THIS IS A CRIME THAT MUST BE PUNISHED!
 

DustyDrB

Made of ticky tacky
Jan 19, 2010
8,365
3
43
That's actually a better argument for the irrelevancy of the awards show than the "I don't like frat boys and popular people, so there for this show sucks" argument. I mean...not all frats are the same. There are nerd fraternities. I know...I was roommates with three members of one. They were all bona-fide nerd stereotypes. And the other kind of frat boys can be decent people.

But your argument? Makes sense. They really should host this in January or February. That way, the year is actually over and all the games for it have been released (I know there weren't many December releases, but there was the one big one: The Old Republic). And this way does make sure that the people voting have actually had time to play the games.

erttheking said:
PEOPLE HAVE DIFFERENT OPINIONS FROM YOU? Oh dear lord, CALL THE POLICE! A MAN IS UPSET THAT PEOPLE LIKE DRAGON AGE 2! THIS IS A CRIME THAT MUST BE PUNISHED!
That's not really his issue here...
He mentions it, but that's not what his case is built off of. I'm a DA2 fan as well, by the way.
 

Lunar Templar

New member
Sep 20, 2009
8,225
0
0
i was kinda under the impression they never mattered to begin with.
like ...
the Golden Globes
or
Oscars
or
the Grammys

or any other lame awards show that eats up to much time on TV. the fact the VGAs are also an embarrassment to the medium, doesn't really take away from the pointlessness of the whole thing
 

Korten12

Now I want ma...!
Aug 26, 2009
10,766
0
0
Vault boy Eddie said:
VGAs. Oh, you mean the Modern Warfare 3 awards? I'll pass. If they can count the multiplayer leveling system as RPG they'll screw Skyrim right in the poopers.
Yes because MW3 won... soo many awards during it...

Oh wait... They only won one.
 

Soviet Heavy

New member
Jan 22, 2010
12,218
0
0
erttheking said:
PEOPLE HAVE DIFFERENT OPINIONS FROM YOU? Oh dear lord, CALL THE POLICE! A MAN IS UPSET THAT PEOPLE LIKE DRAGON AGE 2! THIS IS A CRIME THAT MUST BE PUNISHED!
Dude, has your account been hacked or something? You've been necro-ing threads a lot today.
 

Erttheking

Member
Legacy
Oct 5, 2011
10,845
1
3
Country
United States
Soviet Heavy said:
erttheking said:
PEOPLE HAVE DIFFERENT OPINIONS FROM YOU? Oh dear lord, CALL THE POLICE! A MAN IS UPSET THAT PEOPLE LIKE DRAGON AGE 2! THIS IS A CRIME THAT MUST BE PUNISHED!
Dude, has your account been hacked or something? You've been necro-ing threads a lot today.
I swear to god, I'm not checking the dates on these things, I'm just looking around for discussion with the search bar and previous posts made by other people...I should probably stop.