Super Mario Odyssey and The Fake Review

Recommended Videos

CritialGaming

New member
Mar 25, 2015
2,170
0
0
I saw this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I5EzAh7ZkZI this morning and I thought it was pretty fucking funny.

If you guys followed any new on Zelda Breath of the Wild you would probably have seen that Jim Sterling gave the game a 7/10 and people lost their fucking minds. To the point where they DDOSed his site for days about it. I think the outright nonsensical outrage about that review was part of the reason that Sterling decided to completely bail outright on traditional reviewing.

So to keep things interesting, the internet made a fake review on Super Mario Odyssey and have been sharing the screen shot of the 7/10 review on metacritic online to trigger people for the Lol's.

Personally, this is another example of the unnatural attachment people have to games and reviews. This desperate need to insist that other people rated a thing they like as highly as they would rate the thing they like is fucking stupid, and signals a depressing level of infantile mentality amoungst the gaming community.

I have a theory that these reactions stem from people who were so bullied in school that they became almost complete shut-ins. Locking their free hours away in their room to play games or whatever other non-social solo activity for the majority of their childhood that as grown ups, they don't know how to properly interact or react to people. They have a hard time building personal relationships, nor can they reasonably process negative things they don't agree with like game reviews or No Man's Sky.

I get it, I can understand how and why people react this way. I just wish there was a way to fix it. Like a Chris Hanson show "To Catch a NeckBeard."

Chris would show up to an online troll's house and sit them down.

"Excuse me sit down right here. Just...Just sit right there." He would say. "Now explain to me....why are you obsessed with My Little Pony. You're 37 year old, what is this about?"

It would be amazing.
 

happyninja42

Elite Member
Legacy
May 13, 2010
8,577
2,990
118
CritialGaming said:
Personally, this is another example of the unnatural attachment people have to games and reviews. This desperate need to insist that other people rated a thing they like as highly as they would rate the thing they like is fucking stupid, and signals a depressing level of infantile mentality amoungst the gaming community.
This isn't exclusive to the gaming community. Humans in general develop obsessive levels of fixation on things they enjoy. Just look at physical sports fans, and you will see what I'm talking about. DDOSing might seem bad (and it is), but at least they haven't set cities on fire in protest/revelry of their team winning/losing some sports match. While it's not 100% confirmed, many people believe that the word itself is a shortening of fanatic. Which again, easily exemplifies the behavior, and has done so for centuries.

People devote a large amount of personal worth and validation into the things they feel are important and enjoyable. Criticizing those things can then be considered to be a criticism of them as well, thus they feel threatened and react negatively. This is nothing new, it's just online now is all.
 

Silentpony_v1legacy

Alleged Feather-Rustler
Jun 5, 2013
6,760
0
0
CritialGaming said:
"Excuse me sit down right here. Just...Just sit right there." He would say. "Now explain to me....why are you obsessed with My Little Pony. You're 37 year old, what is this about?"
What's the age limit on MLP then? 'cause I'd remind you all the writers, actors, directors, producers, animators, all of the staff are adults. Who are so obsessed with MLP the freaking make it!


Edit: Also in response to a fake Jim score
 

CritialGaming

New member
Mar 25, 2015
2,170
0
0
Silentpony said:
What's the age limit on MLP then? 'cause I'd remind you all the writers, actors, directors, producers, animators, all of the staff are adults. Who are so obsessed with MLP the freaking make it!
Adults making entertainment for kids, is different than adults obsessing over kids entertainment. I'm not talking about watching a show and liking a show meant for a younger audience, that's whatever.

I'm talking about this nonsense https://imgur.com/7NYNIcp

There is such a thing as "too much". That's not even half as bad as I've seen people get. Fanaticism is bad regardless of the subject as pointed out by @happyninja42
 

Leap That Wall

New member
Oct 27, 2017
6
0
0
Yeah, this is sad. If people need a metric system, I like how Eurogamer does it. It's either recommended, essential or something you should avoid. If it doesn't have a tag it's probably good if you're down for that kind of stuff. The 0-10 scale doesn't help anyone.

To be completely fair, Jim's review of BOTW sucked balls and not because of the score, but because he literally mentioned the scores the games was getting as something that was on his mind as he was reviewing it. You review the work, you don't review the reception it's getting.
 

sanquin

New member
Jun 8, 2011
1,837
0
0
Leap That Wall said:
To be completely fair, Jim's review of BOTW sucked balls and not because of the score, but because he literally mentioned the scores the games was getting as something that was on his mind as he was reviewing it. You review the work, you don't review the reception it's getting.
Now that I have BotW I can say that I don't agree with the 7/10 score. It's at least an 8/10, if not a 9/10 for me. But that's all I do. I say "I don't agree" and I move on.

I used to be fine with calling myself a fan of something. But these days I'm really hesitant, considering how extreme a lot of 'fans' seem to get. Instead I just go with "I really like" or "I love" X. Because I want to stay away from fandoms as much as possible.
 

Leap That Wall

New member
Oct 27, 2017
6
0
0
sanquin said:
Now that I have BotW I can say that I don't agree with the 7/10 score. It's at least an 8/10, if not a 9/10 for me. But that's all I do. I say "I don't agree" and I move on.

I used to be fine with calling myself a fan of something. But these days I'm really hesitant, considering how extreme a lot of 'fans' seem to get. Instead I just go with "I really like" or "I love" X. Because I want to stay away from fandoms as much as possible.
Absolutely, I don't agree with the score as well but I really disagree with the review itself. That doesn't mean I'll go nuts over it and anyone who throws a tantrum because someone somewhere disagrees with his opinion should take a step back and maybe get out of the internet for a bit.
 

CaitSeith

Formely Gone Gonzo
Legacy
Jun 30, 2014
5,374
381
88
At least people seem to have relaized it was a fake screenshot before making a DDoS on his website (again). That would had sucked!
 
Jan 27, 2011
3,740
0
0
The fact people ragged on Jim for a fake review he didn't make, for a game he hasn't played yet, when he already made a big deal about no longer doing official reviews and people still made a fuss about all this is just further proof we all live in a parody. XD
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
13,054
6,748
118
Country
United Kingdom
Leap That Wall said:
To be completely fair, Jim's review of BOTW sucked balls and not because of the score, but because he literally mentioned the scores the games was getting as something that was on his mind as he was reviewing it. You review the work, you don't review the reception it's getting.
He didn't "review the reception". He mentioned other scores, briefly, at the very end of the review-- there's no indication it affected his own score, and that seems a bizarre assumption to make.
 

Leap That Wall

New member
Oct 27, 2017
6
0
0
Silvanus said:
He didn't "review the reception". He mentioned other scores, briefly, at the very end of the review-- there's no indication it affected his own score, and that seems a bizarre assumption to make.
I wasn't talking about his score, I have no issues with his score. And while he didn't center the review around the reception, it was featured in the text and even if it was briefly that still bothers me.
 

gigastar

Insert one-liner here.
Sep 13, 2010
4,419
0
0
A predictable reaction from a particularly neurotic fanbase.

Join us again next year when this all happens again.
 

InsanityRequiem

New member
Nov 9, 2009
700
0
0
Hater creates a fake review to disparage Jim Sterling (who stated a couple months ago he?s stopping reviews), more haters and trolls boost the fake review, pushing it in Nintendo circles, idiots in Nintendo circles believe it?s real because they?re idiots and respond as idiots would.

Yet across most of the internet, only Nintendo fans are attacked and disparaged for this, not the haters and trolls who perpetrated this shitstorm. Keep it classy internet.

Note for those who think I?m ?enabling? the grotesque reaction of a minority of Nintendo fans. Well, for one, I recognize them as what they are, a minority of shit stain idiots who are easily duped by haters and trolls. But that?s par for the course of every group of people.
 

kilenem

New member
Jul 21, 2013
903
0
0
DDOSing someone kind of closes the door for an actual debate on a review which is sometimes needed. I remember when Mod Nation Racers was dinged by gametrailers because the story was pretty Bland but the majority of Kart Racers don't have story modes.
 

Drathnoxis

I love the smell of card games in the morning
Legacy
Sep 23, 2010
6,023
2,235
118
Just off-screen
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
Sure is an easy life to be a troll on the internet. Nobody ever fact checks before posting their opinions.
 

Specter Von Baren

Annoying Green Gadfly
Legacy
Aug 25, 2013
5,637
2,859
118
I don't know, send help!
Country
USA
Gender
Cuttlefish
This isn't anything new. Movie's have had this kind of thing happening to their reviews and reviewers long before video games and the only reason you don't hear about it as much from books is because there's so many books.