They're also completely free to voice their criticism in this thread.Loonyyy said:Sure.Hagi said:That's kinda what happens when you make a silly request like that...Loonyyy said:Good work guys. You've managed to turn a request to avoid the moaning and flaming into your motivation to moan and flame.
I disagree. I think it is entirely on those making the complaints. And no, I don't think they'd be replaced by other complaints, since, as is obvious, they're already slipping in.This isn't on the people complaining about that, this is on the OP. If he hadn't made this request half the complaints in this thread wouldn't exist (and no, they wouldn't be replaced by other complaints. Do you honestly believe anyone with something to say is going to refrain because of some silly extra note in the OP?)
And the CoC is simply inviting me to call other users trolls, to disrepect people, to be a jerk, etc. My comparison's grossly exaggerated, but I think you get the point. Asking people to keep it polite and on topic shouldn't be a problem, and that they were asking for it because people can't keep it civil is just absurd. And the comparison to other sentiments should be obvious. However, I won't derail further by going into that(Especially since that's a gender war all of it's own). If those people make the complaints, it's on them. The OP has washed their hands of it.A request like that is simply inviting complaints.
Of course. I don't think that should stop someone from hoping people are willing to be reasonable though.If people want to complain they will complain, regardless of whether you like it or not.
Sure. But at least you've good grounds to complain when people have no interest in discussing the topic than bringing their tired gender-wars into your thread.Adding in a request explicitly asking dissenting opinions to not be voiced means you not only get those dissenting opinions but you also get a ton of people arguing against you for free and open discussion.
And anyone who makes the criticism about free and open discussion is being foolish. As pointed out in the OP: They're entirely welcome to make their own thread, or even make their own thread that's about the gender war they want to start. Which might save this one an early grave from the lock of doom.
Because... you know... there's a pretty clear and obvious difference between the CoC and a silly request from another user.
See the CoC is by the people who actually own these forums and all the threads in it. This is their place. So it's their rules.
The OP does not own this thread. That's the entire purpose of a forum, a place where anyone can voice and share their opinion and thoughts on any topic. You can start a discussion on any topic but you don't control that discussion, as soon as the topic starts it's out of your hands.
The OP's request goes against the entire point and spirit of a forum. Therefore I can see it as nothing other than a silly request of which the sole purpose, probably unintentional, is to serve as flame-bait.
And he's not asking people to stay polite, that'd be fine. He's explicitly asking people not to voice opinions contrary to his own, that's just stupid and asking for all the complaints he's getting.