I just want to say that I never expected this thread to go this far. It single-handedly got me the Excellent Topic and Hot Topic badges (50 replies and 1000 views respectively). Thanks guys.
Fumbles said:
On topic- The Divine Comedy----Oh wait...
But, maybe this time they could make it good?
Actually, that raises another point. I read Beowulf a while ago and it seems like it would be a decent game (based on the poem, not the movie). It would need to be expanded, of course, but it already has antagonists and bosses (Grendel, his mother, the dragon at the end).
If expanding Beowulf would be too difficult, would The Odyssey of Homer make a good game adaptation? I haven't read it, so I might just be being silly for suggesting it.