It's just too clusterfucked, subject Lost. When an RP racks up 7 pages in 8 hours, it just boggles the mind and everyone is tripping over themselves. To me, it seems with that RP there's a story post, then just random chatter til Elricik advances the story himself. There is no drive to a story. A good RP should advance the story without someone telling you to do stuff.
Subject Smag, thanks but no thanks. XD I would do it but seeing as I've only been in 4 RPs and I've only finished one of those (One got God-Modded into hell, one died, the other one I couldn't work with), I'm not the best choice.