The Big Picture: You Are Wrong About Sucker Punch, Part Two

Recommended Videos

daibakuha

New member
Aug 27, 2012
272
0
0
DVS BSTrD said:
No I wasn't Bob: I thought none of what happend actually mattered in the end and it turns out I was right.
It's a good thing you aren't a film critic, because you suck at film analysis.
 

PsychedelicDiamond

Wild at Heart and weird on top
Legacy
Jan 30, 2011
2,197
1,102
118
I think it's unfortunate that you didn't comment on the character of the "High Roller", the other sympathetically portrayed male character and the one you'd least expect to be shown that way. It's shame that his only scene was in the directors cut.

The other thing is: While i see where your interpretation of the movie as a commentary on the progress of feminism comes from i interprete it a bit differently. To me it's mostly a coming of age story. Babydoll, representing childhood, obviously has to sacrifice herself for Sweetpea, the adult, to survive. This happens, in the burlesque world, with the loss of her virginity to the High Roller and in the asylum world with her lobotomy. While the symbolism of sex as a rite of passage is fairly obvious the lobotomy part is far more interesting. She accepts the loss of her free will to let the other part, the adult, take control. That seems pretty brutal but it's not that bad of a representation of the transition into adulthood.
 

castlewise

Lord Fancypants
Jul 18, 2010
620
0
0
If I'm in a certain mood I really did this kind of deep analysis of movies. Hunting for metaphors and hidden meanings can be fun. Its hard to know where to stop though. For example its probably safe to assume the curtain call thing at the beginning was put there for a reason. On the other hand, last week MovieBob included the advertising for the film as part of the film's message, and I'm not sure that moviemakers always artistic direction over their posters and trailers.
 

elitestranger1

New member
Nov 20, 2009
46
0
0
can we have more heavy deconstructions in future please?
its nice to learn something new about films ive seen which isnt common for me because ive usually analyzed it myself
thx bob, your the best critic on the web i know of :)
 

varmintx

New member
Oct 6, 2011
149
0
0
daibakuha said:
DVS BSTrD said:
No I wasn't Bob: I thought none of what happend actually mattered in the end and it turns out I was right.
It's a good thing you aren't a film critic, because you suck at film analysis.
Give 'em a break, most people suck at analysis of every kind...especially introspection.
 

rekabdarb

New member
Jun 25, 2008
1,464
0
0
Abbie Cornish is 6 foot 8?

Holy shit! She's taller than me. by 6 inches... Me thinks bob meant 5'8

But while I would agree with some of the things he said, we might be delving a tad bit deep into the rabbit hole.
 

King of Asgaard

Vae Victis, Woe to the Conquered
Oct 31, 2011
1,926
0
0
EDIT: Removed, because I wrote it when I was tired and having a bad day.
Plus I don't want to get any more flak for it.
 

Azuaron

New member
Mar 17, 2010
621
0
0
shogunblade said:
As far as your interpretation goes...

I'd be more than willing to watch it a second time. I've said all I wanted to say last week [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/6.387238-The-Big-Picture-You-Are-Wrong-About-Sucker-Punch-Part-One?page=4#15462682] on the subject.

That being said...etc. etc. etc. tl;dr;
*snicker*
 

Kargathia

New member
Jul 16, 2009
1,657
0
0
RTR said:
I'll take a movie that tries hard but stumbles along the way than a movie that doesn't try at all.
Oh certainly, but the minor thing of there being actually -good- movies does still relegate this to the bad movies department - especially as this didn't so much as "miss the landing", but faceplanted into the concrete at 300 miles an hour.
 

Hitchmeister

New member
Nov 24, 2009
453
0
0
This is odd. I so often disagree with MovieBob, that I feel weird about totally getting what he's said in these two episodes, because they mirror so closely what I took away from Sucker Punch. Although I'm 99 44/100% sure that he's wrong about Abbie Cornish being 6' 8". ;-)

Captcha: fishy smell (ain't that the truth)
 

tehweave

Gaming Wildlife
Apr 5, 2009
1,942
0
0
Alright, I was really impressed with this. I agreed with the first episode (I actually sort of liked Sucker Punch) but didn't see the full analysis until this one. I like your interpretation. It's pretty damn cool.

Nice video.
 

bz316

New member
Feb 10, 2010
400
0
0
I'm not sure what's worst: having a movie pretty much call me an asshole, or (assuming Bob is correct in his assessment of the film's intentions) the fact that I totally deserved it...
 

Callate

New member
Dec 5, 2008
5,118
0
0
It's an interesting interpretation. I'm not sure it's in any way invalid, but I do have some problems with it.

Well, any story in which characters are in some sense entirely not characters performing actions but symbolic representations of philosophies or... I dunno, Jungian archetypes?... whose activities serve only to reflect upon those philosophies/archetypes and their successes/failings is going to have a hard row to hoe. Not least because those "characters'" successes or failures is going to starkly be due to the whim of the storyteller. If the failure of Babydoll's plan is the failure of third-wave sexualized feminism, if I disagree with the notion that third-wave sexualized feminism has failed in the way portrayed, the whole thing kind of unravels, even having come so far as to recognize all the symbolism the director intended.

When I saw "Sucker Punch", I was most irritated by the notion that Sweet Pea was the "actual hero", and I guess I still feel that way. I felt that the earlier story of Sweet Pea coming to the asylum to protect her sister Rocket might be a story in which she was a hero, but the one we were seeing was one where Babydoll was the instigator of all the action; that being the case, saying that Sweet Pea was the hero was simply not a choice the movie had the right to make for its audience.

Yes, in many ways Baby Doll's plan was a failure. But it wasn't a failure because of Baby Doll, aside perhaps from her excessive willingness to put the others at risk, a risk each girl agreed to take on; it was a failure because of bad luck, and one girl's reaction to setback being an unfortunate decision to confess the plan. And while Sweet Pea's desire to keep Rocket safe might be admirable, what does she offer in opposition to Babydoll's plan, other than a continuation of the status quo (which appears to consist of the girls continuing to suffer routine sexually abuse until their captors tire of them and decide to get rid of them?) What's "heroic" about that in this story?

In the final hour, it's still Babydoll who has to rescue Sweet Pea and choose to sacrifice herself.

Sucker Punch was certainly an interesting film, and not one I'm sorry I saw, but however one chooses to interpret it (and even to the extent that many interpretations run into their own road blocks), I think my ultimate description would probably have to be something like "ambitious failure".
 

Drew Dubois

New member
Apr 12, 2012
2
0
0
Why do I feel like it's totally illegal for anyone to like this movie? This was one of my favorite movies from last year, but every time I bring it up people call me an idiot, misogynist, etc. Even when I try to explain things like Bob did, they just tell me I'm an idiot.

Sucker Punch wasn't perfect, but at least *attempted* to do more with its narrative. Whether it succeeded or not is up for you to decide, but I'm glad it took a risk.
 

daibakuha

New member
Aug 27, 2012
272
0
0
varmintx said:
daibakuha said:
DVS BSTrD said:
No I wasn't Bob: I thought none of what happend actually mattered in the end and it turns out I was right.
It's a good thing you aren't a film critic, because you suck at film analysis.
Give 'em a break, most people suck at analysis of every kind...especially introspection.
The only reason I didn't was because even after both of these videos he still refuses to acknowledge any other opinion than his own.
 

Smeagol150

Emperor of the Moon
Oct 20, 2008
64
0
0
I'm still not sure how any of this "makes me wrong about Sucker Punch." Because the movie is more thought out then what most people gives it credit for makes it a good movie? It's like saying, "You're wrong about Call of Duty." Because they put a lot of work into making the game and have refined multiplayer to a level that can be carried over so many people. It's still a crap game, you haven't changed that. And you haven't made me wrong about it or this movie.
 

Callate

New member
Dec 5, 2008
5,118
0
0
Sorry for the sudden second posting, but the first line of Yahtzee's "Extra Punctuation" article this week coincidentally seemed apropos:

Motivation is an important part of characterization. There's nothing duller than an entirely reactionary character who never acts out of their own decisions, only blind loyalty or automatic response to a perceived slight.