For the love of God, please leave Tails out of the main characters. Maybe an Assist Trophy who would keep you from falling for a certain amount of time, but nothing else.
In a close second would be Stan, the guy who sprayed pesticides at Donkey Kong (He's a trophy in Melee), as some retro replacement for Game and Watch. Please no.
However, I'd sort of like to see Blob from a Boy and his Blob as an item. Throw a Jellybean at him to change him into other items, possibly even more powerful than the original items or never run out of energy. That would be awesome.
In a close second would be Stan, the guy who sprayed pesticides at Donkey Kong (He's a trophy in Melee), as some retro replacement for Game and Watch. Please no.
However, I'd sort of like to see Blob from a Boy and his Blob as an item. Throw a Jellybean at him to change him into other items, possibly even more powerful than the original items or never run out of energy. That would be awesome.