The Game with the Greatest Atmosphere
- Thread starter agerdemon
- Start date
Recommended Videos
Another one for Vampires - Bloodlines. Bloody immersive, and I'll never forget how creepy the haunted mansion was, or the "eye harvest"
Jesus, there are too many to count! I might as well tell you my favorite, Shadow of the Colossus...don't get me wrong, I love the atmosphere of most of the games mentioned thus far, but for me, nothing beats watching a boss taller than a skyscraper in the distance with a couple of my arrows sticking out of it!
Call of Cthulhu is pretty good at creating an atmosphere; it's pretty creepy playing it alone, even before you realise the extent of the horror that is Innsmouth.
I would say Bioshock as well, and Beyond Good and Evil struck a nice balance between drama and humour. Oh, and Portal. I had no idea what to expect when I picked it up. The progressively more sinister insinuations of GLaDOS sent shivers through you; there was a kind of grim anticipation of what was to come.
Morrowind and Gothic most of all. I really felt that I'd been cast into an (undoubtedly hostile) backwater swampland. Oblivion lacked this; it forced heroism upon you, whereas Morrowind hated you. It tried to kill you. Cliffracers have scarred me for a lifetime.
Gothic shared this brutality. The magical prison seemed real at times.
I would say Bioshock as well, and Beyond Good and Evil struck a nice balance between drama and humour. Oh, and Portal. I had no idea what to expect when I picked it up. The progressively more sinister insinuations of GLaDOS sent shivers through you; there was a kind of grim anticipation of what was to come.
Morrowind and Gothic most of all. I really felt that I'd been cast into an (undoubtedly hostile) backwater swampland. Oblivion lacked this; it forced heroism upon you, whereas Morrowind hated you. It tried to kill you. Cliffracers have scarred me for a lifetime.
Gothic shared this brutality. The magical prison seemed real at times.
Like most horror games. They are the best for atmosphere.
Can't stand horror films though. All they seem to be these days is large amount of blood and gore. Would rather films be more psychological than blood and guts. At least then, it's more intelligent.
Can't stand horror films though. All they seem to be these days is large amount of blood and gore. Would rather films be more psychological than blood and guts. At least then, it's more intelligent.
Max Payne 1&2, I could actually sympathize with Max and understand his desire for revenge. Also, when he gets drugged and you go to those really f***ed up levels, that is f*** awesome. And the storyline sucked me in like a black hole, and thats saying alot because those are the ONLY games that actually did that.
Definitly Half Life two Raven Holm when i played it on hard was absolutly nightmarish i played it with the lights off and when someone came in the room i jumped out of my skin, I lived in fear of the fast head crab zombies and most of all the poison ones they could take a grenadfe and not die! Also later in the game when city 17 rebels you got this feeling of liberation very good atmosphere though water hazard felt more like a cruise than a death dash
No there isnt anything "rong" with me. Learn to type complete words.JD4566 said:
Why not?JD4566 said:
You know that game existed pre-xbox, right? Wrong is spelled with a 'W', you actually DID spell "squirrels" correctly, but spelled multiplayer, that (twice!), with, sorry, and wrong incorrectly. And you replaced "too" with a number.JD4566 said:
It wasnt innovative in the slightest, it was childish humor. Unless you consider childish humor to be "innovative."JD4566 said:
Also, Conker is hardly an "immersive" game, maybe look up what that word means, and you might have a better ability to respond.
Ahh, System Shock 2 is probably my most memorable terrifying atmosphere... the first time I played it I got as far as the crew quarters, had virtually no health, one healing hypo, a bag of crisps, and a broken pistol.
I was so frightened that my character hid behind the counter in a canteen for ten minutes before I could muster the courage to come out. The whole experience was made far worse by the hybrids setting off the automatic doors as they wandered about in the corridor, muttering crazy-talk and death threats. I knew that any second one would wander in and murder me. It honestly felt like it was MY life, and not that of my character that was at risk.
I like Bioshock a lot as a game, but after I had become used to being regenerated without fail I got that Boris from Goldeneye "I am Invinssseeable!" mentality, which stopped me feeling scared, so the creepy factor was spoiled quite a lot. Still think it's a beautiful interesting world, just not frightening.
I was so frightened that my character hid behind the counter in a canteen for ten minutes before I could muster the courage to come out. The whole experience was made far worse by the hybrids setting off the automatic doors as they wandered about in the corridor, muttering crazy-talk and death threats. I knew that any second one would wander in and murder me. It honestly felt like it was MY life, and not that of my character that was at risk.
I like Bioshock a lot as a game, but after I had become used to being regenerated without fail I got that Boris from Goldeneye "I am Invinssseeable!" mentality, which stopped me feeling scared, so the creepy factor was spoiled quite a lot. Still think it's a beautiful interesting world, just not frightening.
I can't say WoW, or any other MMO for that matter, because half of every MMO base are retarded d-bags, who want nothing more to frag you. I'm gonna go with GTA4 and my top pick, Assasin's Creed coming in a close second. Anyone whose played GTA4 and just sat on top of a building and watched the civilians just act can tell you that the developers did a wonderful job of creating the game, despite it erring on the real side a bit too far. Assasin's Creed is huge, with maybe not the level of interactivity one would desire, but the game just has a 'feel,' knowmsaying?
I think that for things like atmosphere especcially, the graphics can make a HUGE difference. You had a nice experience playing system shock. But for somebody who has played bioshock first, I can imagine something looking less good will also be less atmospheric... like putting one finger in 0 degree water and another in 40 degree water and then put them both in 20 degree water...
BioShock overall. I have played many games with great and even better stories, such as FFX, but the overall feel of the environment and tone greatly made up for the story, which was still great but only had one major twist. I just wish the difficulty was harder. Even the Brass Balls achivement was pretty easy if you conserve your ammo.
And I, despite absolutely hating Bioshock, think it's ridiculous to claim everyone is inexperienced (as if 5-6 years is inexperienced) just because their opinion differs from yours.StatikShock said:
Half-Life 2 sucked me in, but it was really the two episodes (especially ep. 1) that pulled me in the most. And, although the game was incomplete, KOTOR II really had a great atmosphere, a much darker one than the original.
EDIT: Apologies to whoever I quoted. I had pulled up this post when there was still only one page, and didn't get around to replying until now. So, I hadn't realized your post had already been addressed.
I'm going to say Morrowind. Just stopping and observing the Ascadian Isles... breathtaking.
Apart from that, I'm going to say World of Warcraft, the starting areas in particular, and Ace Combat 5 & 6.
Apart from that, I'm going to say World of Warcraft, the starting areas in particular, and Ace Combat 5 & 6.
The first Manhunt. It doesn't get any better than fighting for your life to film some sick fuck's snuff film. Especially when the sick fuck is Brian Cox. AWESOME.
Well hell, i'm bored and meant to be studying for exams, so it wouldn't be right if i didn't procrastinate and add in my two cents on the old/new thing here.
I have to say i had the same reaction as StatikShock to everyone posting bioshock. Or at the very least "Bioshock, hands down". It's not that it didn't have great atmosphere, it's damned good! Really damned good! But it's certainly got a lot of competitors. And if you've played the earlier games in the series, you've *seen it before*
I do think games have more atmosphere these days. Not as a general rule, most games coming out are still rubbish. But there's certainly a growing recognition of the potential of games to tell wonderful stories, and I think more developers are interested in taking advantage of that. This is, of course, on the back of a lot of old games that really did set the world on fire - fallout, starcraft, system shock. Some would seem a little dated now (because they've inspired so many titles after them that have the advantage of graphics). Some were so well made and original that they're as good as anything today. *Everyone* who games should eventually give fallout and starcraft a go, for example.
So it's not all blind nostalgia. And I think older gamers will be less excited about new stuff that is the same as old stuff but with a facelinf. But there's no denying that there's some amazing games coming out - GTAIV for example. And there's no denying that , even if I've seen it before, people who play bioshock or halo are definately feeling 'immersion' - possibly more than i did back when i played system shock because of advances in the industry. Just harder to get exited about stuff that seems less original to me than to people with a shorter history.
PS, i'm not *that* old, i've been gaming just less than 2 decades. Any really old farts like to comment?
I have to say i had the same reaction as StatikShock to everyone posting bioshock. Or at the very least "Bioshock, hands down". It's not that it didn't have great atmosphere, it's damned good! Really damned good! But it's certainly got a lot of competitors. And if you've played the earlier games in the series, you've *seen it before*
I do think games have more atmosphere these days. Not as a general rule, most games coming out are still rubbish. But there's certainly a growing recognition of the potential of games to tell wonderful stories, and I think more developers are interested in taking advantage of that. This is, of course, on the back of a lot of old games that really did set the world on fire - fallout, starcraft, system shock. Some would seem a little dated now (because they've inspired so many titles after them that have the advantage of graphics). Some were so well made and original that they're as good as anything today. *Everyone* who games should eventually give fallout and starcraft a go, for example.
So it's not all blind nostalgia. And I think older gamers will be less excited about new stuff that is the same as old stuff but with a facelinf. But there's no denying that there's some amazing games coming out - GTAIV for example. And there's no denying that , even if I've seen it before, people who play bioshock or halo are definately feeling 'immersion' - possibly more than i did back when i played system shock because of advances in the industry. Just harder to get exited about stuff that seems less original to me than to people with a shorter history.
PS, i'm not *that* old, i've been gaming just less than 2 decades. Any really old farts like to comment?