The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Teaser

Recommended Videos

Username Redacted

New member
Dec 29, 2010
709
0
0
Too much CGI. Too much CGI that really looks out of place. The more I think about 'The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey' and the more I see of 'The Desolation of Smaug' the more I am convinced that this has absolutely no business being three movies. The first one bored me to tears with how glacially paced and needlessly padded it was. I cannot imagine either of those issues improving in the subsequent movies.
 

Jonluw

New member
May 23, 2010
7,245
0
0
Glongpre said:
Why do they feel the need to completely destroy such a cute and innocent little book by changing scenes that really do not need to be changed.

example 1- The Hobbit movie part 1, the fight with the trolls...just why. No we won't get bored if the first half of the movie has no action.

ex. 2- Thorin gets his head smashed in by a mace...o wait, no he's fine no damage. That orc should only appear at the battle of the five armies.

There are others but I won't get into that.

Edit: also wtf beorn isn't all aggressive like that.
Yeah, pretty much this.

I also didn't like very much the scene with the glade (well, cliff in the movie) and the wolves. Something about the pacing. The book feels very much more like a slow-paced but enthralling adventure with little action but much tension.
The films seem to be dropping the tension for the sake of action.
It's the same kind of problem I get while playing D&D. Everything ends up being about the combat, when really combat should only be a small part of the experience.
 

Maxtro

New member
Feb 13, 2011
940
0
0
cojo965 said:
Am I the only one who gets Grigori from Dragon's Dogma vibes from Smaug's size?
Heh, I thought of that a bit too, and somebody else mentioned wanting to hear Smaug speak. And of course, Grigori had an amazing voice.
 

Reaper195

New member
Jul 5, 2009
2,055
0
0
Berithil said:
Smaug looks awesome and I can't wait to heat him talk.
Not to mention he's voiced by the dude that plays Sherlock Holmes in Sherlock. And his voice is bass-ey as dicks as it is.
 

Lieju

New member
Jan 4, 2009
3,044
0
0
I'm a big fan of the books (more LOTR than The Hobbit, though I read both as a kid), but the movies never really felt 'real' for me. I have such a strong image in my head of how the world and characters should be that while I enjoyed the trilogy, it wasn't the defining experience for me.

With the Hobbit, I got less of that, since my attachment to the book isn't as strong, so in a way I'm looking forward to this more. Also I'm looking at it as Bilbo being an unreliable narrator, so the different tone doesn't bother me.
 

UrinalDook

New member
Jan 7, 2013
198
0
0
Massively excited for this.

Then again, I'm in something of a very small minority. I actually thought An Unexpected Journey was more entertaining than any one of the original LOTR movies. Heresy, I know.

Just bear with me. Nothing will ever surpass LOTR as a trilogy, as piece of cinema experience. It came out when I was just the right age to love it, it did something utterly unlike anything that had come before and (with the extended editions) one can watch it as a single, 12 hour piece doing nothing more than marveling at the exquisite attention to detail, lavish scenery and a couple of stunning acting performances.

Over ten years on, however, and I feel I'm so jaded I've come out right the other side. I'm sick and tired with grim, dark stories; of antiheroes, moral ambiguity and oppressive atmospheres. To go and see a movie that was simply three hours of fun, colour, energy and simple pleasures, highlighted with some wonderfully engaging perforamances, was utterly refreshing. I like seeing a protagonist setting out with no motivation other than the desire to have a little adventure, and maybe score a little treasure. I like getting to see a Gandalf from happier times, the Gandalf we glimpsed at the start of Fellowship, mischievously launching fireworks from the back of his wagon for the kids.

The nods to LOTR are, I will admit, almost pure fanservice. But it worked on me. After ten years, Rivendell lost none of its awe. And like the rest of the film, it was probably better for feeling like meeting up with an old friend.

I'm well aware that the CGI, the framing, the colour saturation and even the script all give it a very different tone from LOTR, and that at times the CGI can be a little glaring. But I've also never before had that much fun in a cinema. At least, not solely from watching a film.

This teaser promises more of the same, plus a little awesome dragon action. And hopefully some glorious pointing out of the obvious from Legolas (nostalgia's a powerful thing). Once again, I can't wait.