Elderly Possum said:
In my opinion it's dungeons and dragons by no means is the game bad it's just the fact that the players not only make the mechanics the characters and rules they also write the story I leave it to you fellow escapists
Sorry, what?
Have you even played D&D? The players don't make up any of the mechanics or rules; that's why you need rulebooks to play it. They're free to tinker with the rules if they want, but that's the thing: they only need to if they want to. Ok, you create the characters, but that's no different from any CRPG (if you're playing it right, at least). And I don't see how giving the players the option to make up the story is lazy. There are plenty of pre-packaged adventures you can buy, which means the DM doesn't have to spend ages planning a campaign; you only need to design your own if you want to. Admittedly, most people will, but that's the great thing about D&D: it allows for much more creativity and open-endedness than
any CRPG could.
On-topic: Halo 3. Hey, look everyone! It's Halo 2 with shinier graphics! I still don't think it's that bad a game, but it's nothing particularly special.
