First, my research into some claims and backlash: LordKat and Lupa
LordKat posted an especially vile rant about how being associated with Spoony fucked over his interview chances at E3, and basically whined like a broken motor for a solid hour.
Ignoring the vitriol and some of the more questionable claims he makes this does put some things into perspective: in hindsight, the loss of E3 does coincide with the sharp drop in quality for his UWW videos and eventual departure from TGWTG (and yes, they pulled the same PR move as they did with Spoony, but with much less fanfare and attention; for obvious reasons).
Despite many of LordKat's claims to the contrary, he is VERY much like Spoony, at least as a reviewer and watching his content shows that he is prone to reusing the same joke, same taglines, and same style. He's just not as good at the comedic writing.
In fact, the manner in which he has responded to the situation with Spoony is very eerily similar to how Spoony has responded to his fanbase: backlash against the opposing fanbase, "Decree of the King" ego-driven mass-bannings in response to ANY dissenting criticism.
My point here: LordKat had beef with him because he was essentially redundant. The two of them are (in personality) far too much alike; two Alphas in the same pack, I suppose. But you will never get either of them to admit that.
Lupa is nothing more than the spark that lit the fire so she's become a pariah. Easy target.
Fact is, this shit has been building for a couple of years now. Spoony won a Webby let it go to his head, his girlfriend split (for whatever reason), health complications...yeah, Lupa didn't mastermind or engineer shit.
Dredging up a month-old post to get him fired? Please. Far-fetched doesn't begin to describe that. Spiteful and angry at Spoony's sexist antics on Twitter, yes. I can see her being spiteful because of that and events that happened between him and JesuOtaku.
But a scheme to get Spoony fired? That's not even funny ironically.
Her actions, in retrospect, are every bit as vile and hatefully bitter as LordKat's. It's VERY easy to pin this all on her. Regardless of her motivations, she earned no sympathy from me, "rape jokes are bad" or not.
Which comes back to the man of the hour: Noah Antwiler, aka "The Spoony One"
Simply put, I think he's a wildly bipolar individual. I saw his board gaming group do the Battlestar Galactica boardgame, and they did not come across as anything hateful, spiteful, etc.
In that, he seemed to be in his element, but totally out of character. Decent guy, good humor, not overtly hateful in the slightest.
His 2 hour rant with Brad Jones over Transformers 3 showed the same thing. He doesn't like acting like a total asshole in public, he claims he doesn't like thinking in certain ways.
Yet, once he gets onto Twitter, he's a raging asshole. He makes sexist comments, lets his ego rule completely over him and he isn't doing so ironically or in character. Public figures, no matter how great/small, are judged on their image. It's just part of the business.
Recently, Noah has gone into rejection-apathy mode, after angrily banning anyone with a differing opinion. I think at least subconsciously, he knows he's in deep shit now.
(Cripes, for the last month he's been quoting Lord Byron poetry, and that guy was one of the earliest examples of emo-drama...over a century before "emo" meant anything.)
But the point I'm building towards: The self-destructive cycle.
Spoony does nothing, becomes bored, and then lonely (pines over Scarlett; says he has no friends, etc). Finally gets off his ass and does a video, responds negatively to all criticism, and goes back to doing nothing.
With each cycle, he continues to find new ways to irritate his colleagues, alienate old friends, and piss off his dwindling fanbase.
Now, at last, it's blown up on him in a very public way.
He has real talent as a comedic actor, but he has to let go of all his bullshit attitude, ego, and emotional baggage. Given the rate in which he's going, I don't see TSE lasting another year. Channel Awesome was the tether that kept him afloat, and they've cut it.