I'll take a crack...FYI, have not played some of these games in forever. Like, I was probably in middle school the last time I played Assault and I think I was in elementary with Adventures.
Star Fox: Pretty sure it'd be pretty cool if it sort of playable. Maybe it has something to do with the SNES I've played the games on, but they run pretty terribly. Still pretty damn okay though.
Star Fox 64: An improvement on every level and it feels like the sort of game that the N64 was made for. Out of a lot 3d games from the era, this one still holds up really well. But how can it not when your object is HOLY SHIT! SHOOT THE FUCK OUT OF EVERYTHING!
Star Fox Adventures: I'd have the balls to say it was underrated because I remember enjoying it, but I was a kid at the time. Still, I don't think it should be treated so badly just because it's different than what we expected. I appreciate it when a series tries something different even if it's just borrowing elements from their other franchise.
Star Fox Assault: Either nobody liked this one or nobody played it...I remember liking it. I remember Screwattack complaining about the sections where you run around with a blaster, but...well, what the fuck else are you supposed to do with a character like Star Fox to make him branch out a bit? Space missions are cool, but let's spin things around for a little bit, no?
The last footage I saw looked hilariously cheesy, but I guess I wouldn't expect anything less from a Star Fox game. I hope to get to play it and I hope I'll enjoy it. I think I'll have to go back and play the ones I haven't played in a while so I can test my nostalgia, I guess.
I like the simple, arcade-y action and flying around in a spaceship is always cool. But, I also want to see more of the Fox who's in Smash Bros. That guy is a fucking ninja...there's no reason why we can't have a Star Fox game where we can base levels off of that.