Hmmm. I have to think about this one..... I've got it!
TLOZ:SS
Skyrim
Batman:Arkham City.
I will now awkwardly introduce reasons for this list. GO!
TLOZ:SS: It just looks so f**king badass. Also, it looks like the most creative of the zelda games. And I love creativity in games.
Skyrim: I personally am not looking forward to this game to any extent. I'm not a fan of MMORPGs, they just seem too time consuming, and the concept of a neverending game just seems stupid to me. But let's face it, this game will be up there for GOTY, one way or another.
Batman: Arkham City: This is a good time to say that this list is in no particular order, because me making a chronological list is about as likely as George Lucas making another good Star wars movie. *ba dum tish* This is also a good time to say this, because a bunch of Batman fans will be on my *** for putting this at third.. But anyway, this just looks perfect. There's just so many things that I'm looking forward to, I can't put all of it in one post. I'll just say this, just buy the ****ing game.
Other games that might make GOTY but I won't go into detail about:
Professor Layton 4
Every shooter coming out this year
One of the kirby games
Mario 3D land
And Portal 2.