cuddly_tomato said:
oktalist said:
You still failed to do the exact thing that every other scientist working in the field has likewise failed to do - explain it how it came about in terms of natural selection, not just how it works now.
The only difference appears to be that proper scientists can at least admit this.
Science has done this. I explained not just how it works now, but also how it may have come about through natural selection. ("it" being eusociality) Allow me to summarise. Obviously we can't be sure about the exact details, and there is an inevitable oversimplification in describing a complex, continuous, interconnected nexus of partially simultaneous processes in the discrete, sequential medium of the written word, but it probably happened something like this:
- We start with a species that is experiencing high rates of predation, and is not social.
- Maintaining proximity to other individuals confers a selection advantage in avoiding predation.
- Building a shelter or burrowing into the ground confers a selection advantage in avoiding predation.
- In haplodiploidal species, there is a selection advantage to genes which cause individuals to gather food for their sisters instead of for their own offspring, and such behaviour is made possible by their proximity and fixed base of operations. Obviously such genes might eventually reach a point of such saturation in the gene pool that they are no longer advantageous as they would cause too few offspring to be produced -- as this point is approached the number of individuals in which this gene is expressed levels off to a steady optimum.
- These sister-rearers no longer use their reproductive systems, which become vestigial and functionless.
- The individuals which are still reproducing, and having their offspring cared for by that proportion of their older offspring who don't reproduce, don't need to do any rearing of young and so evolve towards immobility and putting all their resources into reproduction.
I thought that I, and the scientists referred to by Wikipedia, had explained this already. What's missing?