I usually give a game a chance before giving up on it. It "dies" when its just too much..
When grindings is both boring and required to progress in a game. I can handle some grinding if its fun to do it.
When cutscenes show the character behaving in stupid ways, or when the game steal away my control to force me to watch something bad/obvious happen while i just stand there unable to do anything at all (otherwise i might be able to stop or avoid it.. but NOOooo, gotta watch your cutscenes/scripted events kid! Doesnt matter is it just broke the gameplay laws we just showed you previously, its plot! Who cares about consistency when you got plot?)
When the gameplay is too linear and/or repetitive.
When the choices i have access to are badly done and/or don't matter.
My main example: Power-wise, in Oblivion, magic is better than everything else put together. Mages can do everything a rogue and a warrior can, but even better, faster, cheaper... and i don't like playing mages at all.
edit- bloody screens!! So reel! I can't stand them. Its just so irritating to fight the game to be able to see anything at all.
When grindings is both boring and required to progress in a game. I can handle some grinding if its fun to do it.
When cutscenes show the character behaving in stupid ways, or when the game steal away my control to force me to watch something bad/obvious happen while i just stand there unable to do anything at all (otherwise i might be able to stop or avoid it.. but NOOooo, gotta watch your cutscenes/scripted events kid! Doesnt matter is it just broke the gameplay laws we just showed you previously, its plot! Who cares about consistency when you got plot?)
When the gameplay is too linear and/or repetitive.
When the choices i have access to are badly done and/or don't matter.
My main example: Power-wise, in Oblivion, magic is better than everything else put together. Mages can do everything a rogue and a warrior can, but even better, faster, cheaper... and i don't like playing mages at all.
edit- bloody screens!! So reel! I can't stand them. Its just so irritating to fight the game to be able to see anything at all.