this short story of mine...

Recommended Videos

alwaysrockon

New member
Sep 24, 2008
308
0
0
I don?t really know much about writing but I love to just put a pencil to paper and let words flow. I know many people fancy themselves as authors and I know I am one among their ranks but I need (the readers) opinion on this one short "essay" I wrote.
The writing is a little bit rough and could be improved but I just need some helpful critism.

A bum told me a long time ago never to kill a bum. Having walked passed him for five years and him never even acknowledging my existence I laughed and agreed. He caught my good vibe and asked for a nickel. ?Much obliged, my good sir? I responded and handed him a 20 dollar bill. He grinned showing me his rotting brown teeth and stumbled to the nearest liquor store. I waved him goodbye and he saluted back. Later that night I returned to his dumpster and killed him. It wasn?t a act of murder, it was butchery. After I was done there was blood splattered on the street and pieces of cloth and skin stuck to the dumpster where he slept. I threw away my knife in the river, where it remains to my knowledge, and burnt my cloths in the same trashcan he used for warmth on cold winter days. The next day I woke up and went to work as usual. I passed the cops and the yellow tape, hell I even waved to one of the detectives eating his breakfast. I bought a newspaper with my coffee and started flipping through the pages at the diner where I had eaten breakfast for seven years. I took the bus and walked a quarter mile to my work where I sat in front a computer screen for four hours. I called my best friend during lunch and later went to a cafe after work with a co-worker; finally I went home and slept. The next day the police weren?t at the site. The story of the murdered bum never appeared in the papers and the damndest thing is that, well, I never even learned the bums name.
I am not fucked up. I am not a self-made monster, or a creep spawned by today?s society. I do not lead a double life or any other shit like that. I am what I am. Nothing. Nothing at all. Not a coward or leech. Not a metro or a fag. Like I said before nothing at all.
Twenty eight days after that incident my best friend went postal. He killed 6 employees at the factory he worked in before a policeman?s bullet removed half his brain in one spontaneous flash. A reporter asked me if I had anything to say about the incident. I looked him clear in the eyes and told him to go to hell. It seemed like the ?expected? thing to do. The reporter acted appropriately and left me alone for the rest of that day.
That night I went to my friend?s apartment and smoked his last pack of cigarettes. I sat on his torn and dirty couch and inhaled slowly trying to think why he had done it. As it turned out I couldn?t. It was the same damn reason I had given twenty bucks to the bum. I left the apartment and killed another bum on the way home. I didn?t feel relieved to have extinguished another mans life. I didn?t feel hate, or joy, or sadness. I just walked behind the mick and started choking him. He tried to scream but my fingers dug deeper into his throat and he passed out. I then dragged him into a empty lot and slit his jugular with a shard of broken glass. I left the scene and walked the rest of the way home.
No cop ever came to question me. No one saw me kill that man and if they did maybe they didn?t care. That?s when I realized that I was the best type of person that there could be. I didn?t kill out of hate or sorrow. I didn?t do it because of beliefs or ideals. I just did it. I was cold. I was indifferent. I was machine.


any comments would be fine
thank you...


edit: i have another story posted at the bottem of the page. review please.
 

ThaBenMan

Mandalorian Buddha
Mar 6, 2008
3,682
0
0
Wow, that was unexpected, but good. Some interesting themes going on, and pretty well-written. Good job.
 

Portkins

New member
May 27, 2008
562
0
0
What. An incredible twist, I must say, and a bit cynical, but well written to the point where I'd read it, and I don't like reading unless it's on paper.
 

omicronpercei

New member
Feb 4, 2009
113
0
0
I have to say this was the most intelligent thing I've ever read on the internet. It comes off as a modern Poe writing. Dark and cynical yet deeper in meaning than originally perceived. Well done
 

alwaysrockon

New member
Sep 24, 2008
308
0
0
okay so i seem to be getting better at this. So anyone else want to comment. i like praise but i also want some critism...
plus i'm wondering if i should write a contenuace (sort of)...
 

SquirrelPants

New member
Dec 22, 2008
1,729
0
0
Very deep and interesting, despite all its typos and whatnot. Reminds me very much of a short story one of my online buddies wrote about a murderer of his own design. Yours is very good, though.
 

boyitsme95

New member
Feb 26, 2008
293
0
0
Bravo. Very well written and was very entertaining. Could have been longer, but a small gem is better then a large turd (For the record, made that quote up).
 

alwaysrockon

New member
Sep 24, 2008
308
0
0
gameking218 said:
a small gem is better then a large turd (For the record, made that quote up).
now that my friend is an amazing quote :)
by the way the quote at the end of the story "i was machine" is supposed to be that way
 

samsprinkle

New member
Jun 29, 2008
1,091
0
0
Wierd. Maybe a good movie. But not good literature...American Psycho comes to mind with the bums...but I found it humorous how often you cold cocked bums...two random bums in a 3 paragraph(equivilant).
 

TheBluesader

New member
Mar 9, 2008
1,003
0
0
alwaysrockon said:
okay so i seem to be getting better at this. So anyone else want to comment. i like praise but i also want some critism...
plus i'm wondering if i should write a contenuace (sort of)...
You're heading somewhere, but you're not there yet. As it stands, this thing is just straight-up vicious existentialism. Fine, so your main character kills just because he wants to and can. Okay. That's what he says and thinks.

But do you as the author believe him? Does that make sense to you? Maybe it does. But as a amateur writer myself, I would immediately ask, do I really agree with this guy I've created? Or is he just pulling me along with him because I find it kind of fun?

Things can get a lot more complicated and interesting if you find out you don't agree with him, and you show that actual reality might not back up what he thinks. Is he really cold? Is he really unfeeling? Or is he lying to himself and us and you? If he is, why? What is really going on? What can you show from the world around him that will show us this, maybe show him this? And there are bigger questions too - if he's right about himself, is he really a human being anymore? Can he be something else? How much does what we think about ourselves matter to what we actually are? And what is the impact of this dilemma, other than a bunch of dead bums? Or is that a bigger issue than the killer thinks? Are they really worthless to him, or, because they inspire such actions on his part, are they really very important to him, in fact controlling him, at least emotionally?

See where I'm going with this?

Hope I'm not being too obtuse. But keep working on it.
 

theklng

New member
May 1, 2008
1,229
0
0
TheBluesader said:
alwaysrockon said:
okay so i seem to be getting better at this. So anyone else want to comment. i like praise but i also want some critism...
plus i'm wondering if i should write a contenuace (sort of)...
You're heading somewhere, but you're not there yet. As it stands, this thing is just straight-up vicious existentialism. Fine, so your main character kills just because he wants to and can. Okay. That's what he says and thinks.

But do you as the author believe him? Does that make sense to you? Maybe it does. But as a amateur writer myself, I would immediately ask, do I really agree with this guy I've created? Or is he just pulling me along with him because I find it kind of fun?

Things can get a lot more complicated and interesting if you find out you don't agree with him, and you show that actual reality might not back up what he thinks. Is he really cold? Is he really unfeeling? Or is he lying to himself and us and you? If he is, why? What is really going on? What can you show from the world around him that will show us this, maybe show him this? And there are bigger questions too - if he's right about himself, is he really a human being anymore? Can he be something else? How much does what we think about ourselves matter to what we actually are? And what is the impact of this dilemma, other than a bunch of dead bums? Or is that a bigger issue than the killer thinks? Are they really worthless to him, or, because they inspire such actions on his part, are they really very important to him, in fact controlling him, at least emotionally?

See where I'm going with this?

Hope I'm not being too obtuse. But keep working on it.
i think you're a bit too preemptive here. this was just a snip from something that is obviously larger, whether the author has written it yet or not. asking a snip like this to explain in minute detail why all of this is going on is overkill; it isn't necessary and perhaps it won't ever be.

i think you write well. i hadn't expected the turn of direction at all. the advice i want to give you is watch out for irrelevant excessive information. the reader doesn't need to know that the antagonist still thinks his knife is at the bottom of a river unless it's going somewhere.

the trick i've always found in my writing is to not pay too much attention to how i write, but just to write freely from imagination and then restructure it. and while i think you've got the first part, you still need to look at it from a different perspective when you read it through.
 

goodman528

New member
Jul 30, 2008
763
0
0
Not much realism. Doesn't suit my taste.

You know they say your first novel is often partly auto-biographical. I hope your first novel is not written about this kind of a subject matter.
 

Alex_P

All I really do is threadcrap
Mar 27, 2008
2,712
0
0
Sentence 7 is where it starts to suck. Initially, you've got a good lead-in. But, after sentence 7, the rest is very predictable. That's because sentence 7 is pretty much the climax. Right there is where you're done. The rest is just wrap-up. End the story in no more than seven sentences past that point.

If you want to flesh out the "sociopath" factor, you've gotta do it in the lead in. Flesh out the conversation with the bum -- talking to him, studying his face, watching his reactions with curiosity.

The two extra murders after the first one don't add anything.

-- Alex
 

ElephantGuts

New member
Jul 9, 2008
3,520
0
0
Well I don't consider myself a skilled or experienced critic of literature but to put it basically I liked it. It was scary, but interesting. I'm sure there are things that need to be improved or whatever but hell if I know them.
 

dooner11

New member
Aug 14, 2008
57
0
0
Sounds like the hero of some dark graphic novel or comic. Very, very nice.

Your style is refreshingly inhuman and i loved it.
 

Tattaglia

New member
Aug 12, 2008
1,445
0
0
... I'm gonna let it shine!
This short story of mine,
I'm gonna let it shine!
Let it shine,
Let it shine,
Let it shiiiiine!


I'm sorry, I couldn't resist.