Too much diversity.

Recommended Videos

Strazdas

Robots will replace your job
May 28, 2011
8,407
0
0
Rebel_Raven said:
You saying some aren't? Gunna need some proof of that. Why is it that getting rid of women seems to be the ONLY option towards fixing the game?

hos·tile
ˈhästl,ˈhäˌstīl
adjective
unfriendly; antagonistic.
"a hostile audience"
synonyms: unfriendly, unkind, bitter, unsympathetic, malicious, vicious, rancorous, venomous, poisonous, virulent; antagonistic, aggressive, confrontational, belligerent, truculent, vitriolic; bellicose, pugnacious, warlike
"a hostile attack"
of or belonging to a military enemy.
"hostile aircraft"
opposed.
"people are very hostile to the idea"
synonyms: opposed to, averse to, antagonistic to, ill-disposed to, disapproving of, unsympathetic to, antipathetic to; More

That's a few levels under hate. You can be in the military and fight people and be hostile but you do not have to hate those people you're fighting. You can disagree and not hate the other person.
I chose the word for a reason.

There's hostility in people being against the inclusion of women. HATE? Not necessarily. Hostility? Yeah.

I offered more proof it exists than you that it doesn't. It seems more like you're excusing the actions of said assholes. If you disagree, then whatever.

No, because there's a need for -new- voice actors as opposed to recycling dude voice actors which is something anti-inclusive people just love throwing in my face as a reason that there's less women to play as, aka finances. That in and of itself easily puts it apart from just adding another team.

I'm not looking to show hatred. I'm looking to show opposition to the idea. Hatred, if it ever rears it's ugly face, is just gravy.

Honestly, most anything in CoD, including what you mentioned is more than most women get in terms of relationships.

Well, I feel like we aren't getting anywhere with this truth be told. You don't believe me, I don't believe you, and I'm not sure it's going to change because I see people complaining about inclusion all the time, and it adds up even if it's not allin one place. But it's mostly on facebook. Partly on Escapist, frankly.
Wait, did you just ask me to prove assholes are assholes? seriuosly now.

Also i never said that we should get rid of women. I said that people have grounds to be unhappy about EA not fixing broken mechanics and hiding under "but we added women" as deflection from criticism.

Well i guess by that definition im hostile towards you because i disagree with you. kinda makes the term meaningless though doesnt it?

And yet outside of the few cherry picked assholes you still havent shown people disagreeing with addition of women into games. there was what, 5 examples of entire readeship across multiple sites in the first link? If this is reflective of gaming as a whole according to you then id say we are far better off than most communities. In fact there are Some studies [http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/cyber.2014.0492] that even confirm that notion.

Does fifa recycle male player voices? I was under the impression EA get contract with players for their likeness and voice. If they recycle them then yes, you have a point here.

I dont believe you, because you have not given any proof. in fact, your so claimed proof turned out to be the opposite. I am refuting points you made. Im not making any claims asking you to believe them, you are.

Also just because people complain does not mean there is an actual problem. Not all complaints are automatically right.
 

SweetShark

Shark Girls are my Waifus
Jan 9, 2012
5,147
0
0
*I didn't saw the video, so correct me if I am wrong please*

If you think that most of the successful AAA titles, have indeed a generic white male Protagonist, this make sense.
They have a specific image for a Hero character. Like most of the time we see a very specific image for a female character:
Sexy, Thin, Not Many Clothes, Huge boobs/asses Female characters.
For that reason even if we see some normal and logical female character in a specific videogame [Jade from Beyond Good and Evil is a VERY GOOD example], aren't very popular.....
The same goes for black characters. I think only the game Walking Dead hace a solid black Protagonist. Other game? Maybe, but I don't remember.

At least many game give you the option to play something different than a Human Being, Like a Alien/Robot/Goat etc.
Thank God we didn't reach the point to complain why the Goat is always White and not Black or why the Devil Goat is Black and not White.
 

Rebel_Raven

New member
Jul 24, 2011
1,606
0
0
Strazdas said:
Rebel_Raven said:
You saying some aren't? Gunna need some proof of that. Why is it that getting rid of women seems to be the ONLY option towards fixing the game?

hos·tile
ˈhästl,ˈhäˌstīl
adjective
unfriendly; antagonistic.
"a hostile audience"
synonyms: unfriendly, unkind, bitter, unsympathetic, malicious, vicious, rancorous, venomous, poisonous, virulent; antagonistic, aggressive, confrontational, belligerent, truculent, vitriolic; bellicose, pugnacious, warlike
"a hostile attack"
of or belonging to a military enemy.
"hostile aircraft"
opposed.
"people are very hostile to the idea"
synonyms: opposed to, averse to, antagonistic to, ill-disposed to, disapproving of, unsympathetic to, antipathetic to; More

That's a few levels under hate. You can be in the military and fight people and be hostile but you do not have to hate those people you're fighting. You can disagree and not hate the other person.
I chose the word for a reason.

There's hostility in people being against the inclusion of women. HATE? Not necessarily. Hostility? Yeah.

I offered more proof it exists than you that it doesn't. It seems more like you're excusing the actions of said assholes. If you disagree, then whatever.

No, because there's a need for -new- voice actors as opposed to recycling dude voice actors which is something anti-inclusive people just love throwing in my face as a reason that there's less women to play as, aka finances. That in and of itself easily puts it apart from just adding another team.

I'm not looking to show hatred. I'm looking to show opposition to the idea. Hatred, if it ever rears it's ugly face, is just gravy.

Honestly, most anything in CoD, including what you mentioned is more than most women get in terms of relationships.

Well, I feel like we aren't getting anywhere with this truth be told. You don't believe me, I don't believe you, and I'm not sure it's going to change because I see people complaining about inclusion all the time, and it adds up even if it's not allin one place. But it's mostly on facebook. Partly on Escapist, frankly.
Wait, did you just ask me to prove assholes are assholes? seriuosly now.

Also i never said that we should get rid of women. I said that people have grounds to be unhappy about EA not fixing broken mechanics and hiding under "but we added women" as deflection from criticism.

Well i guess by that definition im hostile towards you because i disagree with you. kinda makes the term meaningless though doesnt it?

And yet outside of the few cherry picked assholes you still havent shown people disagreeing with addition of women into games. there was what, 5 examples of entire readeship across multiple sites in the first link? If this is reflective of gaming as a whole according to you then id say we are far better off than most communities. In fact there are Some studies [http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/cyber.2014.0492] that even confirm that notion.

Does fifa recycle male player voices? I was under the impression EA get contract with players for their likeness and voice. If they recycle them then yes, you have a point here.

I dont believe you, because you have not given any proof. in fact, your so claimed proof turned out to be the opposite. I am refuting points you made. Im not making any claims asking you to believe them, you are.

Also just because people complain does not mean there is an actual problem. Not all complaints are automatically right.
Look, you're the one that says you don't believe assholes attack diversity, yet say assholes attack everything. If it's by lack of me spoon feeding you every example when I've already shown it exists (and you admit there was at least one person being sexist) then forget about it. I really don't have it in me to dig up every last bit I can think of just so you can make excuses for the bulk of it, and pretend there's nothing there. Maybe it's because I waded through this hostility for a decade or better, but I know it's there.
I proved that it exists even to a degree, it's not cherrypicked. If anything you're the one cherrypicking trying to ignore it's existance.
Again, Im not going to spoonfeed you. Either you're interested, or you're not, and it seems the latter.

I never said you said we should get rid of women, but if you look at nearly every complaint about the bugginess, it's coupled with hostility towards the addition of women. I really doubt there's a single one that says "hey, fix the bugs, but lets keep women." That, all in all, is pretty hostile to the idea of inclusion. It's easy for EA to ay that when the people complaining zero in on the addition of women.

Yah, kinda takes the wind out of the notion I'm only interested in pointing out hate, huh? It doesn't make it meaningless, though. It shows that there's a lot of assholes against diversity out there. They're not likely organized into any neat lil'group though.

Look, beyond kids thinking girls can only be princesses to be rescued, and can't be super or anything, I don't put a ton of weight on how they negatively impact on how they impact development. Luckily we have TV, Movies, and Comicbooks that have a lot of potential to show a girl she can be plenty of things. And hopefully parents.

There's very little chance that Fifa got every last player, and every last referee to lend their voices to every grunt, breath, shout, and yelp, so yeah, I imagine they recycle voices. If they did get every last participant to lend their voice, that adds a lot of women, and a ton of more work, and cash into the effort.

And yet outside of the few cherry picked assholes you still havent shown people disagreeing with addition of women into games. there was what, 5 examples of entire readeship across multiple sites in the first link?
Again, make up your mind, do these assholes exist, or not? If they exist, that's proof. If you want to dismiss it, we're done talking. I'm so very not interested in spoonfeeding you so you can cherrypick some non-assholes and pretend that they make the assholes that exist not count.

For the most part, those complaints seem to be holding the industry back because they're likely shaping the marketing groups the industry uses to cling to their draconian views against leads that aren't straight white dudes.
Yeah, I admit there's a push for diversity -recently-, but it's not all that huge. Not yet.
There's still Ubisoft saying "women are too hard to make as playable characters" and I'm not all that hyped over the new AC until I know that the playable woman is an actual choice instead of a side plot, or something nowhere near the asking price of the whole game. Also weaseling out of adding playable women to FC4.
And Dontnod fighting to keep Strange Life's protagonist female which shows that while people are fighting for diversity, there's people fighting against it.

And yeah, you are asking me to believe that there's no problem with the gaming community, and I ain't buying the rose tinted shades you seem to be looking at it through.
 

someguy1231

New member
Apr 3, 2015
256
0
0
What really irritates me about the whole "diversity" debate is when people couple their demands for what they want to see more of with what they want to see less of. The video game industry is not a zero-sum game. There don't need to be less characters/games you don't like in order to "make room" for those you do like. Far too many people involved in this debate fail to realize that.

If you say "Games should have more...", fine, say whatever you want. Tell developers what you want, start a Kickstarter for it, etc. Whatever. But the moment you say "Games should have less of..." or "There's too many ... in games", I will always oppose you. Even if I agree with you that there's too much of what you're saying in games. Why? Because who am I to decide what amount of that thing is "right" or "okay" or "acceptable"? As long as there are people who like it, and enough of them buy games with that to satisfy the developers, who am I to tell them they're wrong?

For example, recently, the MOBA Infinite Crisis announced it's shutting down. Many believe that this is due to the oversaturation of the MOBA genre, the high licensing required from DC Comics, and the failure of the game to offer anything that other MOBAs didn't already, and better at that. THIS is how it should be determined when there's "too much" of something in the game industry. Not because some vocal minority doesn't like it.

So, in summary, if you truly want "diversity", only speak of what you want to see more of, not less of. Getting rid of games or character types you don't like is never and can never be "diversity".
 

Strazdas

Robots will replace your job
May 28, 2011
8,407
0
0
Rebel_Raven said:
Look, you're the one that says you don't believe assholes attack diversity, yet say assholes attack everything. If it's by lack of me spoon feeding you every example when I've already shown it exists (and you admit there was at least one person being sexist) then forget about it. I really don't have it in me to dig up every last bit I can think of just so you can make excuses for the bulk of it, and pretend there's nothing there. Maybe it's because I waded through this hostility for a decade or better, but I know it's there.
I proved that it exists even to a degree, it's not cherrypicked. If anything you're the one cherrypicking trying to ignore it's existance.
Again, Im not going to spoonfeed you. Either you're interested, or you're not, and it seems the latter.

I never said you said we should get rid of women, but if you look at nearly every complaint about the bugginess, it's coupled with hostility towards the addition of women. I really doubt there's a single one that says "hey, fix the bugs, but lets keep women." That, all in all, is pretty hostile to the idea of inclusion. It's easy for EA to ay that when the people complaining zero in on the addition of women.

Yah, kinda takes the wind out of the notion I'm only interested in pointing out hate, huh? It doesn't make it meaningless, though. It shows that there's a lot of assholes against diversity out there. They're not likely organized into any neat lil'group though.

Look, beyond kids thinking girls can only be princesses to be rescued, and can't be super or anything, I don't put a ton of weight on how they negatively impact on how they impact development. Luckily we have TV, Movies, and Comicbooks that have a lot of potential to show a girl she can be plenty of things. And hopefully parents.

There's very little chance that Fifa got every last player, and every last referee to lend their voices to every grunt, breath, shout, and yelp, so yeah, I imagine they recycle voices. If they did get every last participant to lend their voice, that adds a lot of women, and a ton of more work, and cash into the effort.

And yet outside of the few cherry picked assholes you still havent shown people disagreeing with addition of women into games. there was what, 5 examples of entire readeship across multiple sites in the first link?
Again, make up your mind, do these assholes exist, or not? If they exist, that's proof. If you want to dismiss it, we're done talking. I'm so very not interested in spoonfeeding you so you can cherrypick some non-assholes and pretend that they make the assholes that exist not count.

For the most part, those complaints seem to be holding the industry back because they're likely shaping the marketing groups the industry uses to cling to their draconian views against leads that aren't straight white dudes.
Yeah, I admit there's a push for diversity -recently-, but it's not all that huge. Not yet.
There's still Ubisoft saying "women are too hard to make as playable characters" and I'm not all that hyped over the new AC until I know that the playable woman is an actual choice instead of a side plot, or something nowhere near the asking price of the whole game. Also weaseling out of adding playable women to FC4.
And Dontnod fighting to keep Strange Life's protagonist female which shows that while people are fighting for diversity, there's people fighting against it.

And yeah, you are asking me to believe that there's no problem with the gaming community, and I ain't buying the rose tinted shades you seem to be looking at it through.
You made a claim, that you did not substanciate. I said i do not believe you, and told you my reasoning of why i do not believe you. You have tried to support your claim with additional data, but that data turned out to support my argument instead. You are still yet to make a case for people attacking diversity. the burden of proof here is on you. One person being sexist out of the example group of hundred or more does not show trend of most people being sexist, quite the opposite. Its not relevant if im interested, you are interested in proving there is a problem, you are the one that should put the effort.

Well since you defined hostility as disagreement, histility in comments is absolutely meaningless because disagreement does not mean jack shit. Heres the thing, you "Reall doubt". On the other hand i went out, read the comments and pointed them out, and yes, there is. This makes me think you havent actually read the comments you claimed were hostile. Thats the thing though, you have repeatedly failed to prove people are complaining about addition to women.


I already agreed that assholes exist. This however does not further your point, because these are only few assholes being assholes and in no way sets the general opinion of gamers or destroys diversity.

you have failed to prove there are complaints to shape the industry or hold it back, so your whole speech about draconianv views are nonsensical. even if you were to prove these complains are a significant portion, you would have yet to prove them effecting game developement. As we know complains about bugs, DLC and pre-orders certainly didnt, so why would this do?

Really, AC and FC? you do realize what story driven narrative means, no? you do realize you cant just genderflip made stories (well, perhaps you can, after all turning Thor female certianly worked out, right?). Especially not because some feminist whined online.


No, YOU are asking me to believe there is a problem, when your own evidence proves otherwise. Either get better evidence or stop making false claims.

P.S. This thread inspired me to do some research, but thats going to take a few weeks so ill get back to escapist on that after im done.