Top 5 worst games of 2012

Recommended Videos

hazabaza1

Want Skyrim. Want. Do want.
Nov 26, 2008
9,612
0
0
So I've noticed a few "top 5" stuff going around but I don't think there's been quite enough hatred and negativity going around. So, this thread is used to discuss all the top 5 worst games that you've played this year. Try to keep rage and flaming to a minimum though.

Alright, starting us off, NUMBER 5:


But imagine that that's the case for the PC game.
Alright, so this might need some explaining. I played a good lot of Rainbow Six Vegas 2 with a friend and had a hell of a lot of fun. The leveling up in the campaign, Terrorist Hunt, all the gun variation and and silly sounding potentially racist accented comrades. Good fun.

Then this game goes and shits on it.
The epitome of the "Modern Military Shooter" the game is a ridiculously easy mundane walk through boring looking environments while things that aren't you take away any kind of engaging gameplay from things that are you.
You'll get walking mechs, flying drones, magical see-through wall vision and boring fucking forced stealth sections. A miserable game if there ever was one, and to top it off, the multiplayer is a massive clusterfuck.

NUMBER 4

First off, not, this isn't a "fjebsk.fefs.k gaemn is 2 hrad" rant. No, I fucking love Dark Souls. I love the melee combat, I love the boss fights, I love the environments and I love the weapon variation. You name something in Dark Souls, chances are I love it . So when I had the chance to play Dark Souls on PC, great, right?
Wrong.

Turns out that FromSoft got the most incompetent team of gibbering retard baby chimps to port this game over to PC because without unofficial modifications and outside input that doesn't come with the game, it's fucking broken.
Controls with mouse and keyboard are abysmal and unworkable, resolution is capped ridiculously low, there are barely any graphics settings and the ones that are there don't impact the utterly shit framerate caused by the shit port.
Great game, awful port.

NUMBER 3

So Darksiders the first wasn't very original. Probably anyone will agree with that. The gameplay is somewhat dull hacking and slashing, the dungeon design is ripped from Zelda, and even the somewhat unique elements like the story and setting were mishandled and kind of a clusterfuck.
But it still had some kind of identity and challenge.
War felt cool to control. He had a big fuckin' sword and some big fuckin' fists and you had to know when to use shit and when to back off. It had a level up system but only the most basic, keeping the essentials of the character throughout the game.

Darksiders 2 however, feels like the biggest "design by committee" game I've ever played.
"Let's add more leveling up and random loot because fuck making a balanced game, it's popular right now!"
"Prince of Persia platforming? Well sure thing jimmy bob! People seem to like that!"
"Relatable characters and making sense with aspects of our plot? Fuck no, that shit's dull!"

It's also just boring to play. Combat is ridiculously easy even on the highest difficulty, always ends just as it feels like you're getting into it, and if you do manage to get your health low enough, the game is constantly throwing potions at you. Ai partners also seems fairly common and when you've got one of those around, well them buddy boy, you don't need to do fucking anything, because they're absolutely invincible and deal massive damage to every enemy in a massive AoE.

The worst thing about Darksiders 2 is that it could easily have been good. Darksiders 1 was... maybe not good, but serviceable. Mostly enjoyable. Darksiders 2 has nothing. It is a game in which I fail to comprehend how anyone can enjoy it.

Darksiders 2 easily gains my "Number 3 worst game" of 2012 award, and well as my "Number 1 most wasted potential" award of 2012!

NUMBER 2

BORING BORING BORING BORING BORING
Boring characters in the past, boring characters in the future. Boring gameplay, boring plot, boring environments and boring sidequests. Boring Assassin's guild, boring naval missions, boring protagonist and boring levels of choice in terms of weapon and clothing variation.

[HEADING=1]BORING[/HEADING]

NUMBER 1
So, what game is even worse than Assassin's Creed 3? What game is more boring, more putrid than the excruciating badness that was Assassin's Creed 3?

DEAD PIXELS
A game that rides entirely on it's Indie cred and attempts to be "unique" turn into one of the most boring and uninspired games I have ever played.
The most basic description is "Diablo with a zombie apocalypse". That concept could at least last an hour of amusement. Having random environments and challenging combat would be fun.

Dead Pixels has nothing. "Random" environments is random backgrounds. Otherwise, you hold down the right button and run past the zombies. If you're wanting any kind of cool weapons, you'll have to grind your dick off to get the cash to do so. 'Different' game modes are the same game with even more dull adaptations to it.

Dead Pixels has no redeeming features. It looks like shit, it feels like shit, it controls like shit, the variation is shit and the challenge is shit. An absolutely derivative game that fails to accomplish anything on any level.

So there we are. My bottom 5. Your turn!
 

Ed130 The Vanguard

(Insert witty quote here)
Sep 10, 2008
3,782
0
0
Well...

There was a thread that did something similar...

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.395379-Worst-game-s-of-2012?page=8

And after 273 posts I tallied up the results, for Shits, Giggles (and because I'm insane).

(Note: if the poster included items like disappointed dishonourable mention etc that counted as a vote)

Resident Evil 6: 19
Torchlight 2: 6
Max Payne 3: 7
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning: 7
Dragons Dogma: 2
Hitman: Absolution: 4
Borderlands 2: 8
Far Cry 3: 3
Zombii Attack: 1
Gettysburg: Armored Warfare: 1
Amy: 11
Prototype 2: 3
Ghost Recon: Future Soldier: 6
Assassin's Creed 3: 22
Baldur's Gate Enhanced Edition: 4
PlanetSide 2: 3
Soul Calibur 5: 3
Medal of Honor: Warfighter: 13
Battlefield 3: 4 (semi included as most expansions/DLC came out this year)
Mass Effect 3: 39
Black Ops 2: 9
Neverdead: 2
Resident Evil Raccoon City: 6
Ninja Gaiden 3: 3
Family Guy: Back to the Multiverse: 1
Diablo 3: 16
Gratuitous Space Battles: 1 (released 2009)
Dark Souls: 2
XCOM: Enemy Unknown: 3
Assassin's Creed: Liberation: 1
Anna: 1
Way of the Samurai 4: 1
Kinect Star Wars 3
Revelations 2012: 4
Dragon Age Origins: 1 (released 2009)
Minecraft: 1 (PC release 2011 but Xbox release 2012)
Orcs Must Die 2: 1
Blades of Time: 1
Armored Core 5: 1
Guild Wars 2: 3
World of Warcraft: Mists of Pandaria: 2
Star Was: The Old Republic: 6 (released in Dec 2011 but some mentions of Free to Play version)
TERA: 1
Fable Journy: 1
I am Alive: 1
Twisted Metal: 1
Naughty Bear: Pick: 1
Assassin's Creed: Revelations: 1 (released 2011)
Frobisher Says: 1
Darksiders 2: 2
Fez: 2
Halo 4: 6
007 Legends: 4
Warlock Master of the Arcane: 1
Badge Glory: Face War: 1
Mark of the Ninja: 1
Hyperdimension Neptunia mk2: 1
CounterStrike: Global Offensive: 1
Dishonored: 2
Endless Space: 1
Walking dead: 1
Spec Ops: The Line: 4
Magicka: 1 (released 2011)
Amazing Spiderman: 2
Steel Battlion: 1
Les Pegasus: 1
Lollipop Chainsaw: 1
DayZ: 1
Silent Hill : Downpour: 1
UFO: Enemy Unknown (also known as X-COM: UFO Defense): 1 (released in 1994)
Xenoblade: 1

From this unscientific tabulation we have the top 5 worst games of 2012! (as decided by members of the Escapist who posted games in this thread)

1: Mass Effect 3 with nearly double the votes of its nearest rival.
2: Assassin's Creed 3
3: Resident Evil 6
4: Diablo 3
5: Medal of Honor: Warfighter

(Note: this thread predates the Escapist GOTY 2012 vote).

When this thread slows down I'll do something similar.
 

Zydrate

New member
Apr 1, 2009
1,914
0
0
People only hate ME3 because of the endings. But as an Escapist columnist already stated in one of their top 5's... the game itSELF is actually great. I retcon in my own endings in my personal headcanon and then bam, problem solved.

I don't really have any input because I only got two or three "new" games this year, and they're all fine.
 

WoW Killer

New member
Mar 3, 2012
965
0
0
So if we'd have had an official reader's choice poll, The Escapist would be declaring Mass Effect 3 as both the best and worst game of the year. That sums up the year quite well actually.
 

Ed130 The Vanguard

(Insert witty quote here)
Sep 10, 2008
3,782
0
0
Zydrate said:
People only hate ME3 because of the endings. But as an Escapist columnist already stated in one of their top 5's... the game itSELF is actually great. I retcon in my own endings in my personal headcanon and then bam, problem solved.

I don't really have any input because I only got two or three "new" games this year, and they're all fine.
Correct, many of the 'votes' had comments relating to the ending.
 

Zydrate

New member
Apr 1, 2009
1,914
0
0
Ed130 said:
Zydrate said:
People only hate ME3 because of the endings. But as an Escapist columnist already stated in one of their top 5's... the game itSELF is actually great. I retcon in my own endings in my personal headcanon and then bam, problem solved.

I don't really have any input because I only got two or three "new" games this year, and they're all fine.
Correct, many of the 'votes' had comments relating to the ending.
That's why I hate "Best/Worst" threads of any kind, because it's actually "hate/love" and "Favorite/least favorite". People don't think. They go "Oh, a thread, what's the worsMASS EFFECT THREE CLEARLY"

Kind of why I liked Jim's videos. He gives lists of actual reasons why games were bad, like Amy, which was a functional disaster. That kind of thing.
 

NinjaDeathSlap

Leaf on the wind
Feb 20, 2011
4,474
0
0
5) Assassin's Creed 3

The core experience of Assassin's Creed (or at least, what it used to be prior to some point between 2010 and 2011) is right up my alley. I love it, and it was only autumn of this year that Assassin's Creed 2 was dethroned as my favorite game of all time, so I was ready for Assassin's Creed 3 to be the highlight of the year for me. Everything I saw of Assassin's Creed 3 prior to its release made me even more sure that it was going to be a decisive return to form after a decidedly hit-and-miss Revelations. New characters, new setting, new combat system, what looked like a more focused game, actual concrete resolution to Desmond's story arc, a return of an AC1 style frontier, only better because this one would actually have shit to do in it, and you wouldn't end up with the entire Third Crusade descending on your arse for riding your horse at more than a trot.

The sad thing is, it actually looked like it really was going to live up to those expectations at the start. I loved how the traditional Assassin's Creed free running transitioned seamlessly to the forests of the frontier. Haytham and even young Connor were halfway decent protagonists (although neither of them could really hold a candle to Ezio). The new weapons were fun to use, and didn't feel so redundant as the veritable one-man arsenal Ezio was walking around with by the end of Revelations. The story seemed to be taking on a more complex tone for the Assassin/Templar war, and back in the present we were getting actual plot events and character development. The Homestead having actual people you could interact with and who benefited you made for a much more personal renovation side quest than the past three games. Last but not least, the Naval missions were effing sweet (I've said it before and I'll say it again, if those sailing mechanics had been used as the main focus of a new IP that actually wasn't afraid to just do one thing really really well, I'd have lapped it up and asked for seconds). When I actually talk about it, there was a lot about this game that was actually really damn good.

But then, just when I was ready to declare it a worthy successor to Assassin's Creed 2, it all turned to ash and fell away in my hands. Everything that was good about this game was lost because the core experience that I had once loved was now weak and diluted. The IP just doesn't seem to know what it wants to be anymore, so it trying to be everything, and failing. When I'm playing a game called 'Assassin's Creed', I don't want to be a merchant, I don't want to be a Big Game Hunter, and I most certainly don't want to be a bloody message runner. I. Want. To. Be. A. Cunting. Assassin! Let me be an Assassin again, please! In the end, even the random animal encounters, which had once brought the frontier to life and made it seem so much more than a grind between points A and B, just became, well, another bit of grind that I had to stop and deal with between points A and B.

The final nail in the coffin was the ending, which I'm not going to talk about in any depth because it would only make me angry, and I've already gone on far too long for just this one entry on this list. Just take it from me, it was bad... really, really bad.

4) Call of Duty: Black Ops 2

This is another game that shows promise only long enough for it to piss it all away. Call of Duty 4 still ranks easily in my top 10 games of all time. Slick, deceptively smart, action packed but also well paced, so not to make it wearisome, with a plot full of turns that kept me gripped from start to finish. By the time I finished the campaign of Modern Warfare 3 (in one day), I was utterly bored to tears with the entire formula, and I swore to myself that I was done giving the franchise the benefit of the doubt, as it really was only a shadow of its former greatness, and the next one would really have to throw me a curve ball before I gave it another chance.

When I first started to see material for Black Ops 2, I thought my prayers had been answered. A future setting with lots of high-concept toys to play with, tactical decisions in-game that would determine your level of success or failure at the end, an independent villain not tied to a distinct nation or culture that can be stereotyped the fuck out of, and a story with the potential to offer a bleak take on the dehumanizing effect of modern technology in warfare? Yes, sign me up for all o' that!

Or so I thought...

All the new toys were shown once, and only once, in short, barely controlled, tightly leashed set-pieces that seemed terrified that I might be more concerned with having fun than making the game look like the Hollywood movie that it so desperately wants to be, and then discarded to never be seen again. The tactical choices were barely present, and when they were which choice was the right one was obvious as fuck, all the characters were at best dull and at worst insufferable, and the story had literally nothing of any significance to say. A huge let down that has now made up my mind that the Call of Duty series has gone too far down this road to ever turn back now.

3) Medal of Honor: Warfighter

There is nothing remotely interesting that this game offers, and as such there is nothing remotely interesting that I can say about it. The only reason it isn't the worst game of 2012 is because it's so uninspiring I don't think it deserves the recognition of being number 1 on any list. This is the Marks & Spencer suit of gaming, the unbuttered white bread, it is the very definition of bland.

2) Family Guy: Back to the Multi-Verse

I like Family Guy, and I think it often gets a bad rap. Yes, it's crude, but that doesn't mean it's dumb. This game however, is dumb. Very, very dumb. Before I played it I may have been able to think of a better descriptive than dumb, but playing it has made me dumber so now I can only describe it as being dumb... and gay.

1) Steel Batallion: Heavy Armor

Jim Sterling had it right on the money when he said that this was a defective product. It really really is. Kinect isn't great at the best of times, but fuck me this game genuinely does not know your arse from your elbow. It is one thing for a game to be boring, or simply bad, but this game is unplayable. It falls at the first hurdle. If nothing else, if absolutely nothing else, your game has to work before it can be given any kind of merit. This game does not work, so I give it no merit, not even credit for trying.
 

Chairman Miaow

CBA to change avatar
Nov 18, 2009
2,093
0
0
I will just do top 1.
Steel Battallion.

As has been said, it is broken as fuck. How are you supposed to control a walking tank if you can't even catch an apple or shake a guys hand?
 

DustyDrB

Made of ticky tacky
Jan 19, 2010
8,365
3
43
[HEADING=1]Disclaimer for the inevitable angry people in this thread:[/HEADING]
The actual "worst game" is really likely to be some almost unknown entity lost in the interwebs. Some dude made a shitty flash game, yadda yadda. Or maybe it's Steel Battalion. Point it, only a few of us were unfortunate (or adventurous enough) to play those games. So before you start saying, "Why are you listing Gummi Bear's Revenge 6!?!? That game was a bit of a disappointment, but nowhere near worst game of the year! You're all a bunch of poopypants HATERS!", just realize we can only list the worst games among those games we have actually played.
/Disclaimer

Worst game for me is Kingdoms of Amalur. I've said this a few times already, though, and am struggling at rephrasing it over and over. Basically, it started out OK but then never really stopped feeling like an easy tutorial section of a game that could be better. Combat was too easy, the world too lacking in character, the story too bland. It all adds up to one hell of a bore. And that camera sucked.

I can't really do four more. I liked every other game I played this year.

Also, Darksiders 2 was fantastic! You're just a poopypants HATER!
 
Sep 14, 2009
9,073
0
0
hazabaza1 said:
Snip of anger.



OT:

Medal of Honor: Warfighter

Fable: The Journey I loved fable 1, and the lost chapteres DLC it had, but after that it just went downhill from there, and the journey is no different from that, the game just...fuck, i can't even explain how bad it is. just fuck.

Diablo III fuck blizzard for building that game from the ground up based around their stupid auction house, that game had one objective and one only, to squeeze every penny out of you with the Diablo name branded on it. Fuck the always online bullshit, and fuck inferno mode basically requiring you to grind to holy hell and use the auction house. also, fuck how boring and ill depth it has compared to its predecessor.



Darksiders 2 you are right OP, it was such a disaster to what it could've/should've been, i actually like alot of the lore behind it all (in general, not darksiders) but they fucked it up pretty royally and i felt the mechanics of the game were just a sloppy mess with what they wanted to do with the game.

Mass Effect 3

yes, yes I put it there, deal with it. The ending alone would put it at this spot, but the rest of the game could just as easily put it there too, from all the plot fuck up/holes, to most of the characters/story taking the shaft for EA-ificiation and them shoe horning the multiplayer into the game (the multi itself isn't bad, but shoehorning it into the 3rd game of a trilogy when everyone had been looking forward to the single player portion of it, fuck off EA). Also, fuck your artistic integrity, you over entitled fucking shit gobblers.

Even with the modded ending I just found out about, the game still is shit on by mass effect 1 and 2.
 

idarkphoenixi

New member
May 2, 2011
1,492
0
0
Dark Souls 'IS' a terrible port and unless you make the necessary fixes then it would easily remain so.

I recently got it in the big Steam sale and playing it with a controller is pretty much mandatory. Then you just need to mod the resolution so the textures look a bit sharper, maybe patch the frame rate to 60. So far I'm having a pretty good time with it, no real complaints that couldn't be fixed in a few minutes. The UI is abysmal however, they didn't even TRY to make it work better for a PC.
 

Frostbite3789

New member
Jul 12, 2010
1,778
0
0
This seems more like the "Bottom 5 triple A games that I'm saying for shock value" more than an actual bottom 5.
 

BrotherRool

New member
Oct 31, 2008
3,834
0
0
I think worst of is a hard descriptor. The answer is shovelware and none games but they don't really count. And it really has to be worst of that you've played and I try to avoid buying bad games. I'm not sure there's really a lower limit on badness either, it all sinks into a gooey mess. This game wasn't actually functional, that game just wasn't interesting at all. Which is worst?

So I would say it should be top 5 'most disappointing' or top 5 games that will have a negative affect (Like Call of Juarez say. A game that people will play and actively promotes bad ideas etc) Mass Effect 3 clearly doesn't deserve to top any worst of, because at it#s most basic it has a lot of fun combat and a story thats harmless enough not to have impact on the human race. Medal of Honour: Warfighter might deserve to win for 1, not being very good, and 2 having the usual terrible political thematic message that most MM shooters have had post CoD 4

Ed130 said:
From this unscientific tabulation we have the top 5 worst games of 2012! (as decided by members of the Escapist who posted games in this thread)

1: Mass Effect 3 with nearly double the votes of its nearest rival.
2: Assassin's Creed 3
3: Resident Evil 6
4: Diablo 3
5: Medal of Honor: Warfighter

(Note: this thread predates the Escapist GOTY 2012 vote).

When this thread slows down I'll do something similar.
This pretty much shows the problem with the popular vote in 'best of/worst of's and why ME3 won Escapist Game of the Year. In the end people are going to have to have played the game and so popularity and extremeness of opinions will skew everything. If 10 million people play ME3 and 5 million think it's awful and 5 million think it's amazing then a vote will show it being much better and much worse than a game which 1 million played and all thought was good/bad/meh.
 

hazabaza1

Want Skyrim. Want. Do want.
Nov 26, 2008
9,612
0
0
Frostbite3789 said:
This seems more like the "Bottom 5 triple A games that I'm saying for shock value" more than an actual bottom 5.
No, I'm being honest.
I'm not that into the indie scene or just randomly buying things so I don't have a massive comparative list. Plus, there were a punch of pretty excellent triple A games that I did like, so I assure you that I'm not trying to get shock value points or whatever.
Though it is somewhat funny when people act like they're the big rare exception in a world full of sheep when they don't like a popular game.
 

BloatedGuppy

New member
Feb 3, 2010
9,572
0
0
Zydrate said:
People only hate ME3 because of the endings. But as an Escapist columnist already stated in one of their top 5's... the game itSELF is actually great. I retcon in my own endings in my personal headcanon and then bam, problem solved.

I don't really have any input because I only got two or three "new" games this year, and they're all fine.
Balderdash. I'm getting so, so tired of this "ME3 was perfect right up until the ending!" revisionist history. Not only is it bizarrely forgiving of screwing up the most important part of any narrative, it also hand waves numerous issues that preceded the ending and were discussed at length when the game was still fresh in everyone's minds.

This was my response from the thread mentioned above, if you want my arguments supporting that.

Obviously, I've only played either high profile titles or low profile darlings, so the likelihood of me stumbling across a true contender for "worst game" is exceptionally low. Thus, all I can offer up is disappointing or mediocre games.

And naturally the crown there has to go to Mass Effect 3. From the opening minutes I got that sinking "Phantom Menace" feeling. Dialogue was out of sync, animations were clunky or bizarre, my Shepard looked almost if not entirely wrong due to the mesh not copying over properly, the dialogue was stiff, and there were some hilariously buggy/silly quirks (try running past Anderson during the initial sequence to see what I mean by this). The game evens out after a while, but is still peppered with oddities and missteps. Jessica Chobot's "character" is an abomination, the whole "war assets" mini game is lifeless and bland, the pacing is all over the place, and plot armored super villain Kai Leng is hugely annoying. Cerberus has undergone a further inexplicable transmutation...from terrorist cells to misunderstood human-centric revolutionaries to what is apparently now a massive standing private army. A giant MacGuffin has horned its way into the plot in the form of the Crucible, which everyone endorses as the one and only hope without having any idea what it is or what it does. The shooting mechanics are smooth, but the needlessly streamlined interface (spacebar for everythiiiiing) only serves to highlight a painful lack of environmental interactivity and game play depth compared to contemporaries.

And then we have the ending.

There were some lovely moments. Some POIGNANT moments, even. There's a lot of pathos, and a lot of leaning hard on well established characters that we came to know and love from previous, better games. That newer characters like Jimmy the Walking Stereotype Vega and Reporter Boobs McTitty fall so flat is testament to just how dependent the game is on old faces, all of whom had their arcs closed in ME1 or 2 and are now just hanging around the Normandy doing fan service. The best new character comes in the form of optional day one DLC.

ME3 isn't a TERRIBLE game. It's not Big Rigs or Ultima IX or E.T. But it's not a very GOOD game, either. It's aggressively mediocre, and as the finale to a critically and popularly acclaimed trilogy it's a straight up catastrophe. So on the basis of dashed expectations and squandered potential alone, I think it's a solid entrant for most disappointing game of 2012, at the very least, if not actually worst.

If you want to debate this with me, I won't stop you, but please do it via private message. I don't want to derail this into yet another ME3 thread.
 

DustyDrB

Made of ticky tacky
Jan 19, 2010
8,365
3
43
BloatedGuppy said:
Just to add some ammo (I have a lot to hate about Mass Effect 3 despite it actually being my #5 game of the year. A couple weeks ago I tried to play it (on the 360), but the EA servers were down. I couldn't get past a "checking for downloadable content" notification. So I went back to the dashboard, disconnected from XBOX live and tried again. Upon trying to resume my game, I was told that I would not be able to save offline. So it appears the game is nearly unplayable offline. That might be the worst thing about this game, and no one talks about it.
 

StupidNincompoop

New member
Oct 27, 2012
90
0
0
1. Medal of honour warfighter
2. The walking dead
3. Resident evil operation raccoon city/ resident evil 6
4. Diablo 3
5. Hitman absolution
 

daveman247

New member
Jan 20, 2012
1,366
0
0
NinjaDeathSlap said:
Yeah black ops 2 (rather predictably) wasted the potential it had :/ The main villain who was supposed to be "incredibly deep" turned out to be pretty one dimensional (SPOILER) Wah wah my family died, im gonna destroy the world now).

Plus the strike missions were borderline broken with some of the dumbest Ally AI i have ever seen.

A shame, but not unexpected i guess :/