Video Game Survey

Recommended Videos

IceMan In Black

New member
Apr 20, 2009
21
0
0
Hi everyone. I've come to the escapist for a long time but I'm new to the forums. As such I know it is kind of bold of me to ask but I could really use some help. I am in a marketing class and we are working on marketing research. The scenario is that my group is doing research for a new game developer and they need to know what game they should make. I've tried a couple of different surveys and I am having an extremely hard time getting quality response. The survey is only 10 questions and shouldn't take you over ten minutes. If you could fill it out for me I would be really appreciative.

Here is the link to the survey: http://ww w.surveymonkey.com/s.aspx?sm=AO4hcmhHq2wnq4aZSLK5Nw_3d_3d (The Survey Is Closed, Thank you for participating :) )

Thank you very much for your help, and if you have any additional comments you can put them here. Thank you again.
 

Lord_Jaroh

Ad-Free Finally!
Apr 24, 2007
569
2
23
With the limited choices that you have, how do you expect a quality response? What if someone likes Desktop Tower Defense, Rock Band, God of War, Diablo II, and Guild Wars equally as well? Those are a wide variety of games to have to pigeonhole into your "favorites" list. As well, with no space for comments, you don't take into account reasons someone may have chosen a specific choice.

For example, I picked that DLC wouldn't influence my decision to buy a game. I also don't own a 360. So that says that I am not willing to buy a game for $500...what reasonable person would? Also, if you are looking at DLC as bonus content that you can withold from the initial game to make more money later, I will also look upon that negatively, and maybe not purchase it.

You also had a question in there would a person buy a physical or digital copy for the same price? I think that is probably one of the silliest questions I've heard in a while. Why would I pay more money for less product?
 

Undeed

New member
May 22, 2008
228
0
0
The survey is at the same time both extremely vauge and rigid. There is no gray room, which is a shame because no one but you can quite know what you are talking about. Some of the phrasing is a bit odd( most favorite?). You are never asked to give reasons, and in something like this the reasoning behind why it's fun is likley more important than that it is fun. I enjoy burnout, it's a racing series. But it's the only racing series where you get points for destroying your opponents. This is a much more complex demographic than "Genre FTW", and you'd likely do well to reflect that in your survey.
 

IceMan In Black

New member
Apr 20, 2009
21
0
0
Lord_Jaroh said:
With the limited choices that you have, how do you expect a quality response? What if someone likes Desktop Tower Defense, Rock Band, God of War, Diablo II, and Guild Wars equally as well? Those are a wide variety of games to have to pigeonhole into your "favorites" list. As well, with no space for comments, you don't take into account reasons someone may have chosen a specific choice.

For example, I picked that DLC wouldn't influence my decision to buy a game. I also don't own a 360. So that says that I am not willing to buy a game for $500...what reasonable person would? Also, if you are looking at DLC as bonus content that you can withold from the initial game to make more money later, I will also look upon that negatively, and maybe not purchase it.

You also had a question in there would a person buy a physical or digital copy for the same price? I think that is probably one of the silliest questions I've heard in a while. Why would I pay more money for less product?
You have valid points. I'll start with the survey itself and the quality responses. I started with a better survey on facebook, thinking i could get the number of responses I needed. The refusal rate was 99% (I got six total responses over a week's time). So in order to remedy this, I went to surveymonkey to do an automated survey. Unfortunately, the free account (I am a poor college student and can't really afford any of the more premium services) limits you to ten questions. I tried as best I could to put up the best possible questions and format them as best I could.

I can agree that they limit and pigeonhole people into ranking one over the other (which, for our purposes, is called forced ranking). This was done so that I didn't get a result that showed that I should create some sort of Rock Band-WOW-COD4 demon child that wouldn't be feasible to make. I put the "most favorite" (and yes I can agree that my wording sucks) on there to try to show I was doing a forced ranking. I had the pick which ones you play to show if there was any lack of interest in any genre. If I had put "point-and-click action adventure" games on the ranking list, most people would probably have put that at the bottom. But who's to say anyone really plays those any more (or any other genre for that matter)? It wouldn't have done me any good to have a ranking system without knowing if people even play the games they are ranking.

The DLC question referred to things like GTA 4, where the expansion was released for the 360 exclusively. For the purposes of my class, its very relevant. Also, lets say that the Fallout 3 expansions had been limited to only one platform, that could have drastically effected which version sold the best.

They download/physical copy questions refer to things like steam where, at least when they are new, they are the same price. Our secondary research showed that there is a trend towards downloading a game more than buying a physical copy. Yes, I know and agree that its dumb to just download a game if you can go out and buy a physical copy for the same price, but this research is for making and marketing the game. When the company finds out that the strategy is dumb, they would have to reassess their strategy and it is (for my purposes) no longer a marketing problem and becomes a management problem (however, in my report I will make a note that there are people that would rather have a physical copy than to download it and risk things like hard drive crash)

The bottom line is I know its not the greatest survey, but for my purposes, it will work. This survey has only been up for about 13 hours (as of this writing) and I've already had 11 more responses then I did with a week for a better survey. With the survey being available to a wider audience, I need the automation to keep track of everything. I just have to conform to what the service will let me do.

If you filled out the survey, I sincerely thank you, since it really does help. And if you didn't, I still thank you because I'll make a note about your comments in the report (yes I too wish I could have had an additional comments question [I did on the other one, but no one filled it out]) and I can understand not wanting to fill it out because it isn't the greatest survey. But seriously, thank you for your time. I really appreciate it.
 

IceMan In Black

New member
Apr 20, 2009
21
0
0
Undeed said:
The survey is at the same time both extremely vauge and rigid. There is no gray room, which is a shame because no one but you can quite know what you are talking about. Some of the phrasing is a bit odd( most favorite?). You are never asked to give reasons, and in something like this the reasoning behind why it's fun is likley more important than that it is fun. I enjoy burnout, it's a racing series. But it's the only racing series where you get points for destroying your opponents. This is a much more complex demographic than "Genre FTW", and you'd likely do well to reflect that in your survey.
I would refer you to my response to Lord_Jaroh post since most of my answer for that covers yours too. Since you took the time to respond to the thread, I'll take the time to respond to you too. Yes, my wording can suck. A lot. I promise I'm smart, I'm just not always good with words/wording. I agree that the survey is too rigid, but for the purposes of my class it is what I need and my professor approved. I did have to bend to the options available to me with the website I chose and I wasn't able to really do what I had hoped to do with it. If I were actually doing the survey for a real company, it would be a lot different and it would reflect some of the complaints. I'm in a class and as such this is supposed to be a learning experience. Trust me, I have learned more from this project than what our book could have ever hoped to teach me. And I know our demographic is much more than just "Genre FTW". But from a developers standpoint, it kind of is. If it wasn't, we wouldn't have so many WoW and Halo clones. Some of them good, others not so much. Some of the best games are those that blend many aspects of all different genres. Some of my group members kind of hoped this project would somewhat lead us to a "perfect game". That's not really possible, since, as you said, our demographic is much more complex than that. This survey could (ok so it isn't a great survey so it probably wouldn't but just bear with me) show me how to make the most amazing MMORPG game ever. And you know what? I wouldn't play it. I just prefer other kinds of games to MMORPGs. I have more fun playing other kinds of games. No two people's definition of fun is exactly the same. In a sense, this survey is looking for the white whale when it is really gray (or maybe blue, I don't know I never read Moby Dick). I know its not perfect, but for what I need it for, it works.

And again, if you filled it out, thank you. If you didn't, I understand. Your comments are still valuable to me and will be reflected in my report. Either way I honestly and sincerely thank you for your time and effort. I really appreciate it.
 

IceMan In Black

New member
Apr 20, 2009
21
0
0
Lord Kofun said:
Good luck with your research, boss. I hope you get enough bodies to take the survey.
Thanks, I really appreciate that. Either way this one is going way better than the first one.
 

Goldeneye103X2

New member
Jun 29, 2008
1,733
0
0
It's a good survey, but in" Rank what matters the most" you didn't add gameplay, which is still important.

Good luck.
 

October Country

New member
Dec 21, 2008
215
0
0
All done. I think that the questions about what genres I played and my ranking of genres were kind of similar.
 

bodyklok

New member
Feb 17, 2008
2,936
0
0
Just make up the results dude, it's so much easier. And then you can spend the rest of the time playing video games.
 

Cpt_Oblivious

Not Dead Yet
Jan 7, 2009
6,933
0
0
Done and Good Luck. Although you didn't need to put the names of consoles in brackets after you'd written them.

Playstation 2 (PS2)
Playstation 3 (PS3)
Xbox 360 (360)

etc.
If we own it, we know what it's called. You also missed Xbox, Gamecube, Gameboy (I still use it) Playstation and more. If they exist, people will still use them.
 

IceMan In Black

New member
Apr 20, 2009
21
0
0
Goldeneye103X2 said:
It's a good survey, but in" Rank what matters the most" you didn't add gameplay, which is still important.

Good luck.
Yeah...about that...the only explanation I have for that is that I just forgot it. I would hope that all developers (especially new ones) would know gameplay is the most important part, but we still have things like MGS 4 so...oh well. Thanks for helping.
 

IceMan In Black

New member
Apr 20, 2009
21
0
0
October Country said:
All done. I think that the questions about what genres I played and my ranking of genres were kind of similar.
That's fine. That's probably the result I'll get anyway. Thanks for doing it.
 

IceMan In Black

New member
Apr 20, 2009
21
0
0
Cpt_Oblivious said:
Done and Good Luck. Although you didn't need to put the names of consoles in brackets after you'd written them.

Playstation 2 (PS2)
Playstation 3 (PS3)
Xbox 360 (360)

etc.
If we own it, we know what it's called. You also missed Xbox, Gamecube, Gameboy (I still use it) Playstation and more. If they exist, people will still use them.


I know people who own them know what they are called, but since this is for my class they may not have any idea what's going on. And this is supposed to be for a new developer making a new game. People may still have and play their gamecubes, gameboys, xboxs etc. (I still play my virtual boy, my eyes are mostly fine) but developers don't make games for them any more (there are, for whatever reason, still new games coming our for the PS2, so that's why its in there). Anyway thanks for filling it out, I appreciate it.