Video games are an indication of a new "Man-Teen" culture....for gods sake....

Recommended Videos

tendo82

Uncanny Valley Cave Dweller
Nov 30, 2007
1,283
0
0
The real question, not addressed by either of these articles, is the cause for delayed "adulthood"

I would argue that this prolonged adolescence is really the result of continued growing equality between the sexes since women entered the job force. Simply put, women couldn't afford to live on their own 40-50 years ago so marrying was a necessary step. As women have moved closer to achieving financial parity with men, they are afforded the opportunity to delay starting a family for a much longer period of time. Therefore we see a longer period in which men can be sexually aware single individuals, not unlike an adolescent. All this is to say that there is no reason to lament any of these changes - they are a condition unique to the most economically advanced nations in the world, and are an indicator of the privileged life a certain group of Americans enjoys.

Another factor not being considered in either of those articles is that media consumption has increased exponentially over the same time period, such that how we spend leisure time is fundamentally different from the way it was spent 50 years ago.

Finally, both articles willfully ignore some of the painful realities that don't fit their romanticized view of "men". They forget that their longing for the ?adult male? is a idealized archetype born from extreme gender inequality. They ignore that perhaps this new "man child" is an indicator of how far we've come in gender relations; that this is in fact the marker of a brighter more equal future between the sexes.
 

ErinHoffman

New member
Sep 6, 2006
55
0
0
Khell_Sennet said:
First, who the fuck is she to say video gaming is childish or that consoles are toys. Did someone put this dumb ***** in charge of rating how fulfilling and/or mature interests are. No! So get her the hell off that high horse, and maybe get the thing to take her from behind a couple times... My guess is that lil miss Muir there is fat, ugly as sin, and rejected by every man she approaches. She probably looks like a hybrid of L Ron Hubbard and the Numa Numa kid, with a dash of Robert Deniro for chest hair. In her desperation she probably drew conclusions that she can't get a man because Video Games stole them all, and thus blames the Playstation for making men into children.
Whoa. WHOA. You disagree with this woman, so you're going to say that she deserves graphic humiliating violence? Way to prove her point. You've just done far more to convince me of her argument than she ever could. And the "a woman disapproves of my hobby so she must be ugly" argument is pretty disgusting too. If you really care about this, tone down the PCP. There is never an excuse for this kind of hate.
 

ChrisP.Lettuce

New member
Jan 3, 2008
193
0
0
GloatingSwine said:
That's exactly the problem though.

She's not getting any. So she's lashing out at things she sees as distracting the male population from their true task of pandering to her needs for attention and validation and being told that she doesnn't look fat, ugly, or old.
Lol! I just think it's funny how when she eavesdrops on those two men, she is instantly turned off by the fact they are playing GoW. She instantly judges. One of them could work out for 45 minutes a day and have rippling abs to drive it home on her every night but she doesn't give them the time of day. Oh well, 2 way street blah blah blah. I just think this comment was full of win.
 

Possum-Man

New member
Jan 21, 2008
100
0
0
So wait, she's basically saying "Men who play video games or do 'geeky' things are sad because they enjoy doing something different to the norm."

Does that make Free-runners sad? What about men who Fence? How about other hobbies that aren't about body power?

She seems to have drawn a very distinct line between what she thinks is acceptable for men to do and what she calls "immature".

My opinion: It's my hobby, I enjoy it and if you don't like me because of that then it's your problem, not mine.

P.M.
 

Sniper_Zegai

New member
Jan 8, 2008
336
0
0
Possum-Man said:
So wait, she's basically saying "Men who play video games or do 'geeky' things are sad because they enjoy doing something different to the norm."

Does that make Free-runners sad? What about men who Fence? How about other hobbies that aren't about body power?

She seems to have drawn a very distinct line between what she thinks is acceptable for men to do and what she calls "immature".

My opinion: It's my hobby, I enjoy it and if you don't like me because of that then it's your problem, not mine.

P.M.
Its pretty clear shes stuck in some sort of time warp where men do nothing but work out and talk about boobies and monster trucks....yeah, monster trucks!
 

tendo82

Uncanny Valley Cave Dweller
Nov 30, 2007
1,283
0
0
In response to Hoffman's post:

On a related note, I was listening to 1Up Yours, which I realize is not a bastian of progressive gaming minds, and the panel members had a similarly mysoginistic reaction towards the Hymowitz article.

It was played off as locker room jesting, but their insults were similar in that they derided the writer's looks and insinuated she was a man-hating spinster. However I still don't think this proves her argument; instead, this reaction speaks more about the nature of the enthusiast videogame community than the larger idea of the, get ready for it, Manolescent, their articles address. I won't go into the mysognistic tendencies of the gaming community as that is another topic entirely.
 

braincore02

New member
Jan 14, 2008
293
0
0
amusingly both my parents, who are from that older generation where people "grew up" earlier, advised me not to jump into marraige. of course, they both got married in their twenties to two other people, and both their first marraiges went belly up, i guess because they were too mature.

so i blame them. maybe they should have consulted this genius, as she obviously knows who we all should be and what we should be doing.

breed breed breed! there's not enough people in the world! pump out them babies! sheesh
 

ErinHoffman

New member
Sep 6, 2006
55
0
0
Tendo, point made. I was also exercising some subtlety in that comment... the hate speech does more to convince me of Hymowitz's point because I found the whole article rather inane and forgettable on its own, ie I doubt it would have convinced anyone of much of anything all by itself. But paired with some of the jeering? It gives her criticism credence that it may not deserve by itself. Because I think what she's talking about is the culture around games. I certainly found Khell's post pretty amazingly misogynistic, but in a very incoherently adolescent way. I think what Hymowitz is aiming at is a fusion of the two -- otherwise she would be talking about some of the positive aspects of childhood. If it didn't result in bad behavior I don't think the article would have even what small point it has.

Some of the Kotaku comments are quite interesting and I think are on the mark, regarding the subject in general. People, including women, are putting off childbearing and family-rearing for a whole host of reasons, most of which have nothing to do with videogames and many of which don't even reflect negatively on society -- attending college, an early career focus, higher cost of living. So the argument itself is certainly specious on its face, but it's an opinion column, and I didn't see anyone commenting on the site agreeing with her. There actually are issues perceived by women/spouses about partners who spend too much time playing games, and she is hitting the core of that button in a very provocative (and counterproductive) way.

As far as misogyny goes, do you think there's actually more of it in the gaming community than there is on the internet in general? My experience is that the internet is just generally more full of people willing to spout hate because the consequences are less immediate -- they have a degree of anonymity to fuel what is basically a cowardly form of aggression that they would never act on in person, whether it's directed toward another gender, another race, another culture, what-have-you. Plain old fashioned xenophobia. I think if I thought the gaming community had more misogynists in it than other modern subcultures I'd probably be bothered by that and want to look into it more.
 

Copter400

New member
Sep 14, 2007
1,813
0
0
Haliwali said:
I'll need to see a pic first.
You asked for it...
http://women.timesonline.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00150/kate_Muir_150057a.jpg

Jesus. Christ. This woman can be safely ignored, as the pedestal from which she delivers her ignorant speech is made out of cardboard and Scotch tape.

She first implies that gaming is a childish hobby, when even Mr. Thompson knows that there are games out there which children really shouldn't be playing. She ruins her credibility further by suggesting that some mature hobbies, ones in which families wouldn't be ignored in such a villainous credulous way, are drinking, fighting, chasing after the women and (shudder) watching Big Brother.

I should probably read the article, and I should also avoid cussing and quoting Penny Arcade in one sentence, but the truth is I wouldn't waste the poop it would take to shit on this.
 

Echolocating

New member
Jul 13, 2006
617
0
0
I read the article, expecting to be offended in some manner... but to be honest, I think she has some valid points. The hardcore video gaming lifestyle is, in some manner, delaying other opportunities (and what the author views as societal obligations -- but that's another topic) in life.

Maybe if I wasn't already a husband and a father, I'd take some offense to it, but honestly (and as she puts it) it's no different than the guy who is consumed by model trains. And really... so what?

From my experience, I've found that people only get offended when the comments carry a little truth to them. Seriously... there is a blatantly immature side to gaming, whether most gamers will admit it or not. Personally, I can't wait until games mature to the point where they don't cater at all to children and older teens. Gears of War might be cool, but it's childish... [ in my best Stuart Smalley impersonation ] and that's okay. ;-)
 

Deatre

New member
Dec 5, 2007
15
0
0
tiredinnuendo said:
Don't forget this article too. In this one, we're not even Teens.

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/opinion/points/stories/DN-hymowitz_27edi.ART0.State.Edition1.378ca5b.html

- J
Interesting... so in theory, my brother who has six children (All to the same woman) should be the pinacle of maturity with a full understanding of responsibility and what it is to be an adult. As opposed to the thirty something jobless layabout who does nothing he is?

Maybe he did it wrong.
 

mshcherbatskaya

New member
Feb 1, 2008
1,698
0
0
Haliwali said:
While we manly boys are ranting here, I'd be interested in a FEMALE gamers opinion on the subject. How are YOU perceived for your hobbies? Are you single? Do you also live in the US? Care to meet me sometime? :)
In short what do you think about this?
Of course I gotta stick my dainty powdered nose into this shit-storm and take a big whiff. Ah, smells like...victory. Or maybe not.

First of all, despite all evidence to the contrary, it appears that I am actually a boy. Again [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/18.54023?page=2#386498]. My peenus iz pastede on yay! I even have a hard time finding girls who will sleep with my geeky ass. Except for the chromosomal thing and the Women's Studies degree, I am one of you! Apparently.

Second of all, I'm so tired of having to point out this basic tenet of usenet/mail list/bbs debate: Ad hominem attacks are the lowest form of argument, second only to grammar flames. Seriously guys, when some right-wing cockwaffle decided to open his second asshole and crap out the assertion that Mass Effect was interactive gonzo porn, you were outraged and rightly so. There were assaults on his intelligence, his journalistic integrity *snortcoughchoke*, and the standard wear and tear on everyone's W, T, and F keys. However, there was not an avalanche of, "Fucking fucker is a fucking cross-eyed flipper-baby who's just jealous because he can't play video games! And, plus, also, he's all frustrated because he can't ever masturbate with his stupid flipper hands, and so he doesn't want anybody watching porn! He should die! Somebody should stick a plasma grenade up his ass! He should be teabagged until he suffocates!"

This is a standard pattern, Guys piss people off because they say something stupid and get called dumbasses (because they are) and and told not to talk about things they are totally ignorant about. Women do the same and get called bitches (which is beside the point, since a woman can be dumb without being a *****, and a ***** without being dumb), told they need to get laid (which in my opinion tends to make women MORE stupid with regard to men), and are figuratively threatened with physical violence, assault, and death.

If you object to what she said, then talk about what she said. Leave your opinions about her physical attractiveness and sex life out of it. Though I have to give you guys kudos on the absence of !!!!!1!!ELEVENTY!!!1 and CAPSLOCK OF RAGE.

Soooooo, anywayyyy, what were we talking about again? Oh yeah, this woman's complaint that video games are responsible for the extension of male adolescence (add that to the list of everything else they're responsible for, right?) OK, so, passing over the fact that the length of adolescence has been steadily increasing ever since the late 1700's, let's just note the fact that the advertising and marketing industries lovelovelove the unmarried, late adolescent and early adult male consumer and therefore have every interest in extending his economic availability as such, with or without the aid of the gaming console. In my other life, spent largely in the company of hippies, artists, slam poets, and yoga practitioners, I can tell you right now, whether it's Xbox, weed (er, "hemp"), Burning Man, or polyamory, the guys who are going to be Permanent Children are going to be Permanent Children.

So what's her problem? Well, a couple of things. First of all, she's bought into the idea that she's not complete without a man. Do not underestimate the strength of cultural enforcement behind this idea. Second of all, she's bought into the idea that she's incomplete without a child. Do not underestimate this one either. As a woman who has said no to both, I can tell you that even as a level 62 Queer and the with defense bonus applied from my Prestige Class Feminist, I still take damage on this. The only 100% immunity comes from acquiring a Husband (of at least Boyfriend) and Child.

But wait, isn't she supposed to be a strong, independant woman? Isn't she supposed to be a heroine and not a damsel in this game? Yep. Welcome to the Catch-22 of Modern Woman. If she decides to forgo the man-and-baby option, she will forever be subject to the attack that anything she does or says in challenge to just about anything will be written off as the frustrated bitterness of the old maid. Kinda like what just happened here. Toss in the message that the worst thing a woman can do to her child it raise him or her without a father-figure and the situation just keeps getting better.

So everyone and everything around her tells her that she can't be happy, or even morally and intellectually worthy without YOU, and YOU are still playing that goddamn Xbox! No wonder she's pissed. Not that I agree with her. I think it's perfectly possible to live happily without one or the other or both, if you are willing to take the bullshit from all sides and just suck it up. So she's either not aware that it's possible, or she's not willing to suck it up. She'd just rather complain about it. That's my problem with her.

Oh, geez, I almost forgot your question, Haliwali. The answer is I'm definitely considered a weirdo for my hobbies. In fact, I'm a little bit closeted about my gaming, which is nothing like hardcore compared to a lot of you guys, but is definitely beyond the range of all my female friends, now that my one gamer-ish friend has detoxed off her WoW addiction. But people have so many other reasons to think I'm weird, including the amount of money I spend on comic books and manga, the amount of time I spend watching anime, sci-fi, and martial arts movies, the fact that I have a motorcycle instead of a minivan. And yes, they do think it's an immature type of weirdness. And, you may find this interesting, they rather envy me for it.

So there's one more thing to consider - when presented with "gamer" minus all the cultural baggage of The Female/Male split, women seem to be a little envious at the sort of selfish freedom of it. I've played all evening, clear through the night, and into the next morning, and then blew off the laundry and cleaning the bathroon for an extended nap. A lot of women can't even imagine the luxury of that much time devoted to something that produces no material benefit. And that's kind of sad.
 

Echolocating

New member
Jul 13, 2006
617
0
0
Cheeze_Pavilion said:
Thing is she's not talking about the hardcore video gaming lifestyle. I mean she writes: "One banker dad they knew was always on Age of Empires and Civilization." She talking about *all* video gaming. That to me says the author thinks that it is impossible that there will come a time that "games mature to the point where they don't cater at all to children and older teens." I agree with you that there are some valid points to be made, but, they're certainly not being made in this article.
Yeah, I'm probably giving that fucking ***** too much credit.

I kid. ;-)
 

Haliwali

New member
Jan 29, 2008
910
0
0
mshcherbatskaya said:
But people have so many other reasons to think I'm weird, including the amount of money I spend on comic books and manga, the amount of time I spend watching anime, sci-fi, and martial arts movies, the fact that I have a motorcycle instead of a minivan. And yes, they do think it's an immature type of weirdness.
One date... come on one date?

But really, why is there such a gap between male and female gamers? At least in my area (granted, not the greatest or most populated place in the world) the only girls who play games do so with their boyfriend or on their brother's system. WHERE ARE ALL THE GAMER-WOMEN-NERD-TEENS?!?!