Villians that weren't actually doing anything Illegal.

Recommended Videos

StBishop

New member
Sep 22, 2009
3,251
0
0
RE: everyone who said that dictators etc aren't breaking laws just because they didn't make murder et cetera illegal

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_law

Murder is never cool, nor is kidnapping. Humans have basic rights, like free will.
 

BaldursBananaSoap

New member
May 20, 2009
1,573
0
0
The colossi in SotC. They were just minding their business until you invaded their territory, climbed on their head and went all stabby stabby.
 

Poke_Freak

Paid for this custom title
Sep 14, 2008
103
0
0
SuperMse said:
Poke_Freak said:
Antagonists (i.e. "bad guys")
This is a minor complaint, but "antagonist" does not always mean "bad guy". It is simply a character that opposes the main character (or protagonist). For example, in Death Note, Light is the protagonist and L the antagonist, though I think most people will agree with me in saying that Light is the villain and L the hero.
I know, but I didn't expect everyone on the internet to understand such long words, that's why I put "bad guys" within quotation marks. :)
 

GreeBo

New member
Jun 29, 2004
10
0
0
j0z said:
Fniff said:
j0z said:
Andrew Ryan?
He might not have been in the MORAL right, but what he did did make sense.
1) Andrew Ryan wasn't the villain, or even -a- villain. Would you kindly consider the rest of the game?
2) Absolutely his actions were legal. He didn't break any laws; he simply -couldn't- because he -made- that laws of that undersea nation. It's a logical impossibility.
You said it best.

Er.. no. He could make a law and then break it. Nothing stoping that from happening. Need to work on your logic there Spock :)
 

Poofs

New member
Nov 16, 2009
594
0
0
newguy77 said:
Miles Tormani said:
No one mentions Tom from Tom and Jerry? If anything, Jerry was the villain for doing all that stuff to get Tom in trouble with his keepers. Tom, being a cat, was just doing his job of trying to get rid of a mouse.
Yeah, I always kind of thought that Jerry was a bit of a douche. Just putting the cat through so much torture, just so he could laugh.

Yes, blah, blah, blah, cartoon, grumble, grumble.

Poofs said:
I'd Say all of the villains in the first Assassins Creed
They pulled a few dick moves but all in all they wanted to help people
except for the last boss, he was a true villain
Since this is about illegality

Tamir-Killed someone

Garnier-False imprisonment (Yes, did want to help people)

Talal-False imprisonment (Kind of wanted to help people)

Abu'l Nuquod-Killed entire party

William-Nothing I can recall right now (Wanted to help people)

Majd Addin-Killed without trials

Jubair-(Reaching a bit) Theft (Wanted to help people)

Sibrand-Killed innocent scholar (Insanity Plea)

Robert-Didn't see too much of him (World Peace 'n' all)

Maybe some laws were not laws back then, but this is my bit. Please feel free to correct me.
I know they did this but going with the rules of the thread they didnt do anything illegal since hey pretty much controlled the section of the city they were operating in
thats all i meant
 

SilentStranger

New member
Sep 21, 2009
149
0
0
Agayek said:
SilentStranger said:
They also, you know, want to plunge the world into darkness and horribly murder and torture all beings for eternity. It might be their jobs, but it's still illegal.
I am very, very confused by this.

What are you talking about?
...oh woops, just noticed, I quoted the wrong post, I meant to quote one about Diablo and his brothers. Sorry DX
 

Melon Hunter

Chief Procrastinator
May 18, 2009
914
0
0
Jaythulhu said:
SmoothNRK said:
Fanusc101 said:
I'm intrigued, what could a person do that is worse than murder and at the same time make murder legal.
that my friend is the secret me and my family protect from the world
Oh. My. God! Your family is responsible for creating pop-under advertising, aren't they?


-----

On topic, the "Bad Guy" whatshisname from Eragon. So he killed the dragon riders. Doesn't read like they were a particularly heroic or even halfway decent bunch, let alone "good guys". Then he ruled a kingdom which, it seems, ran fairly and justly. That whiney little anakin-wannabe Eragon is the real villain in the story.
Eragon took so many plot devices from Star Wars, to the point where I began being surprised when something original was used.

On topic, I would say that Adrian Viedt from Watchmen was an excellent example of an ambiguous villan. He made himself out as a hero, before it turns out he's planning something incredibly evil, but it turns out that he actually saves the rest of the world.
 

Queen Michael

has read 4,010 manga books
Jun 9, 2009
10,400
0
0
StBishop said:
RE: everyone who said that dictators etc aren't breaking laws just because they didn't make murder et cetera illegal

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_law

Murder is never cool, nor is kidnapping. Humans have basic rights, like free will.
Free will doesn't exist. Our actions are either predetermined by the law of cause and effect or random.
 

Phyroxis

Witty Title Here
Apr 18, 2008
542
0
0
Fniff said:
j0z said:
Andrew Ryan?
He might not have been in the MORAL right, but what he did did make sense.
Yeah,but was it legal?
I will make it legal




But seriously. Carmen Sandiego? Why did she need to be found, again?
 

Kayevcee

New member
Mar 5, 2008
391
0
0
DracoSuave said:
Fniff said:
j0z said:
Andrew Ryan?
He might not have been in the MORAL right, but what he did did make sense.
Yeah,but was it legal?
1) Andrew Ryan wasn't the villain, or even -a- villain. Would you kindly consider the rest of the game?
2) Absolutely his actions were legal. He didn't break any laws; he simply -couldn't- because he -made- that laws of that undersea nation. It's a logical impossibility.
Ryan wasn't a villain OR a criminal? Let's see, all went well until Frank Fontaine got the drop on Ryan with plasmid technology and suddenly the Great Chain wasn't pulling in Ryan's direction any more. He got pissed off, had Fontaine whacked and nationalised (since he essentially was the government, you can go ahead and say 'stole') Fontaine Futuristics. I'm not even going to start talking about all the crazy shit Suchong as up to that Ryan had apparently sanctioned, and by the time the player encounters Ryan he's mind-controlling legions of his own citizens as a private army of pheromone-led zombies. I'm pretty sure making slaves of Rapture citizens was against the city's charter if the propaganda announcements were anything to go by. Assuming he didn't take the time to go to court once the fire breathing teleporting wall crawlers showed up then he broke the highest law of his own land all over the place.

*cough*

Yes, anyway. Hmm. 'Villains' who were just doing their jobs? I suppose the Vogons in Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy count- yes, they blew up the Earth and every living thing on it five minutes it spat out the Question to the Ultimate Answer, but really, the planning statement had been available at our local office in Alpha Centauri and we had plenty of time to lodge an objection.

-Nick
 

Dyp100

New member
Jul 14, 2009
898
0
0
fwelord said:
Hmmm did that Hitler guy I've heard so much about do anything illegal, nothing that I can recall?
He was put in Prison for Treason, mate.

And any game where the villain is the government through legal ways, or making money through legal ways.

Also...Captain Planet villains, I'm sure. xD
 

Raven's Nest

Elite Member
Feb 19, 2009
2,955
0
41
Scary_Bob said:
fwelord said:
Hmmm did that Hitler guy I've heard so much about do anything illegal, nothing that I can recall?
He committed suicide didn't he? :)
It's not illegal to commit suicide... Who was the last person you heard got arrested for commuting suicide? Perhaps you're confusing it with mortal sin? It's illegal to assist someone committing suicide though.

My vote goes to Darth Vader... He was under order of the Emporer after all.
 

ajb924

New member
Jun 3, 2009
3,479
0
0
Any and all of the enimies in The World Ends With You. All of them were just doing their jobs, what Mr. Kitanishi was doing seemed... Fucked up to say the least, was for the good of everyone. I'm not going to go on in fear of spoilers.

Edgeworth and Franzisca von Karma in Phoenix Wright, yes, I went there.

Team _____ in the pokemon games, they are using the Pokemon to their benefit, just like you.
 

Scary_Bob

New member
Sep 24, 2008
185
0
0
ravens_nest said:
Scary_Bob said:
fwelord said:
Hmmm did that Hitler guy I've heard so much about do anything illegal, nothing that I can recall?
He committed suicide didn't he? :)
It's not illegal to commit suicide... Who was the last person you heard got arrested for commuting suicide? Perhaps you're confusing it with mortal sin? It's illegal to assist someone committing suicide though.
Actually, up until about 1960 it was illegal to commit suicide in the UK. Those that failed in the attempt would then be arrested. Not certain whether it was in other parts of Europe, but for humour's sake, let's say it was.

Edit: After a little bit of research, turns out suicide was legal in Nazi Germany. I hereby withdraw my vote for Hitler.
 

JaredXE

New member
Apr 1, 2009
1,378
0
0
StBishop said:
RE: everyone who said that dictators etc aren't breaking laws just because they didn't make murder et cetera illegal

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_law

Murder is never cool, nor is kidnapping. Humans have basic rights, like free will.

The Devil's Advocate side of me says that, no, Dictators AREN'T breaking the laws of their own country, and that this so called "International Law" is just other countries trying to press their moralistic thoughts upon unwilling countries. There technically is no law that says taking a life is wrong that doesn't have SOME exceptions to it's application. In most countries, shooting someone is murder, but if you are a soldier for your country, it's ok as long as the one you shoot is considered an enemy.

A right is only a right if you can seize it, rights are not given, they're taken.