dyre said:
Well, alright, fair point. I take the stuff about Nazis back.
Are you saying you've lost your faith in humanity to reach its potential, and that you're upset that it resigns itself to being rather flawed?
Btw, I don't believe people are peaceful, open-minded, or accepting at all. I probably think humanity is as flawed as you think it is. But imo it's our unchangeable nature to be the way we are, and that we haven't gotten one bit better or worse than we were during feudalism or slavery or the Enlightenment or the 60s or w/e. We just have new laws and social/cultural standards.
So I see people who claim they've lost their faith in humanity as people who've either had an irrational faith in the first place (what is it that they believed humanity can do? Create a utopia? Was their faith grounded in any reality?), or are expecting more out of humanity than it can offer (and are probably no better than the humanity they despise nor are capable of being better than that).
The worst thing is, when they say "I've lost my faith in humanity" in response to some stupid news story about some event that is nowhere close to as bad as humanity can get. I always think, "are you kidding? You lost your faith in humanity because some guy beat his daughter? In a world where people kill each other by the million, you're disappointed because some jerk beat his daughter?"
Though, I'm not talking about you in that case. I'm just curious though, do you actually maintain that faith in humanity, and continually lose it and gain it again every day (else, you'd only be able to say "I've lost my faith in humanity" once in your life)? It seems...odd, for someone who is aware how lousy humanity is.
edit: sorry if I sound like a jerk/overly aggressive. I'm not trying to be; I just get pretty miffed at the whole lose-faith-in-humanity thing
See, I'm not sure I agree. I think we have got better, in a sense. We're more open-minded and accepting and more prone to fairness. However, it's a bit like if there's a dude who murders, lies, cheats, steals and generally acts like a dick. If, one day, he stopped murdering dudes, you'd say it was definitely an improvement, but you wouldn't exactly consider him a good person now, and overlook the bad stuff he was still doing, just because he'd stopped with the killing.
Of course, this depends what you mean by humanity. I'm guessing you mean basic human nature, come to think of it. We're basically the same people as back then, only the social norms around us are stopping us from being as douchey as we once were. Which is fair enough, because that's my problem. We HAVEN'T learnt a lesson from our barbaric past. There's no civil rights movement to end all civil rights movement, as it were. We didn't become more accepting when we stopped with the institutionalised racism; racial minorities were just taken off the list of people we were allowed to be intollerant towards.
At times I wonder what, if anything, can break this cycle. What can change the nature of mankind, so to speak. It's here that my loss of faith comes from, every time I almost dare to believe that humans are fundamentally good, I'm reminded of their pettiness and stupidity. I don't believe a utopia is possible, but I don't think that's an excuse for not striving to make the world one. Just because I can't be the nicest, bestest, kindest person ever, doesn't mean I shouldn't TRY to be a good person, and I guess that's all I'm really asking of humanity, that it at least puts in a little effort into being decent.
Yeah, see, if I heard about someone beating their daughter I'd be "wtf, dude" and wouldn't blame humanity as a whole. If, however, I went online and a bunch of dudes were saying that his daughter probably had it coming... that's when I would start to think of humanity being terrible. As for people time and again losing their faith in humanity, well, I don't know... It's like being married to a serial adulterer, every time you think about giving humanity a second chance, of giving it the benefit of the doubt, it lets you down again.
Also, no worries about coming off as aggressive or a jerk, I know how easy it is to get angry over stuff, especially when you're debating with someone online.