What game to complete the story mode for

[superbleeder12]

I recently beat Red Dead Redemption (I know, Slowpoke mode) and now, looking to play another game. Looking at my list of played-but-yet-to-beat games. I'm stumped.

I made this thread a few months ago, not sure the rules on thread-necro-ing.

What game should I chose to complete the single player for?

(Warning: image is rather large)

Spoiler

Games crossed out are ones I've beaten.

Text list for those who don't recognize covers, or just don't want to wait for the image to load

Spoiler

Dawn of War - PC
Fallout 3 - PC
Icewind Dale - PC
Stalker - PC
Penumbra: Black Plague -PC
Cryostasis - PC
Oblivion - PC
Baldur's Gate 2 - PC
Amnesia - PC
Borderlands - PC
Oddworld - PC
Homeworld - PC
Zeno Clash - PC
Deus Ex- PC
Divinity 2: DKS - PC
The Last Remnant - PC
Titan Quest - PC
Torchlight - PC
Front Mission Evolved - PC
Rainbow Six Vegas - PC
The Witcher 2 - PC
Trine - PC
Half Life: Ep 1&2 - PC
Singularity - PC
Overlord - PC
Majin and the Forsaken Kingdom - PS3
Metal Gear Solid 4 - PS3
3D Game Dot Heroes - PS3
Folklore - PS3
Persona 3 - PS2
Odin Sphere - PS2
Front Mission 4 - PS2
Oni - PS2
Grandia 2 - PS2
Parasite Eve 2 - PS
Vagrant Story - PS
Chrono Cross - PS
Silent Hill 3 - PS2
Cold Fear - PS2
Zone of the Enders - PS2
Rune Factory: Frontier - Wii
Monster Hunter Tri - Wii
Metroid Trilogy - Wii
Red Steel 2 - Wii
Dead Space Extraction - Wii
Chocobo's Dungeion - Wii
Silent Hill: Shattered Memories - Wii
Cursed Mountain - Wii
Eternal Darkness - Wii
Resident Evil - GC
Resident Evil 4 - Wii
Bayonetta - 360
Prototype - 360
Splinter Cell: Conviction - 360
LA Noire - 360
Assassin's Creed 2 - 360
Resonance of Fate - 360
Nier - 360
Final Fantasy 13 - 360
Lost Odyssey - 360
Devil May Cry 4 - 360

Spoiler

What's worse is these are games that I own, but want to beat, this isn't the full list of games I have, but have no intention on completing.

 

[Iwata]

I'd say probably "Homeworld". Truly epic campaign.

If you want something short and sweet, go with "Singularity". Underrated game of 2010.

 

[jacobythehedgehog]

Well do you have a PS3? If so, play through Metal Gear Solid 4 i you havent, I was at future shop and seen it for only 19.99 brand new. almost 3 or 4 times more then whatI paid for it. But it was worth every penny. Hunted the demon;s forge was really good too.

 

[mireko]

Baldur's Gate I & II. I consider the second one to be the best game ever made. Deep, rich single player experience. P3: FES is a great choice too.

If you'd rather have something that isn't an RPG, try Bayonetta. Get the 360 version if possible, since on the PS3 it apparently has some severe issues if you don't install it (and some other issues even if you do). The PS3 version should still be good with patches, it just won't be as good as the other version. Play Folklore too. Beautiful game, if a little rough around the edges. Also Resonance of Fate. And Odin Sphere. And Dragon Age.

Argh, I just want to recommend all of them. I wish I could play some of these games for the first time again.

[small]Oh yeah, and while I didn't see them on your list: Demon's Souls and Persona 4. Possibly the best games on the PS3 and PS2, respectively.[/small]

 

[superbleeder12]

While I do own Demons Souls, I get easily frustrated.

 

[Booze Zombie]

I'd leave Fallout 3 and Oblivion until you've got a few games out of the way, those two are time eaters. They are premptivly noming on all of that time you waste opening game cases. Nom, nom, nom. Also, make sure you mod the two of those for (in the words of super genius mancat Professor Genki) MAXIMUM PLEASURE!

I would give Singularity a play through, it's apparently one of the few games to have a multi-choice ending where all of the choices are just as valid as one another, despite being different.

From personal experience, I know Deus Ex is a well-made (if in need of a few graphical mods) game that can keep you entertained for many hours... and you can even play it in such a way as to not kill people. Yay, amazingly friendly ninja time, GO!

Also, Dragon Age: Origins! Holy handgrenades how do you live without playing this one?! Play it as soon as possible, it's great! Just don't play as an archer... you'll hate it.

 

[Kahunaburger]

I'd say probably "Homeworld". Truly epic campaign.

^Troof.

Out of the others, I'd recommend starting with Deus Ex, Metroid Prime Trilogy, Witcher 2, Screed 2, Amnesia, and if you have a massive chunk of time to kill, Persona 3.

 

[Phlakes]

If you haven't played the games before, Metroid Prime Trilogy. Definitely. If you have, Deus Ex.

 

[Sinclair Solutions]

Singularity. It's rather short but fun as hell. I always thought it was extremely under appreciated, but other people don't like it.

Still, at least give it a shot.

 

[SonofaJohannes]

Do Chocobo's dungeon. It's a good game.

 

[SomeLameStuff]

You haven't finished Persona 3?!

Drop EVERYTHING and play that NAO!

 

[gmaverick019_v1legacy]

holy HELL you have alot of games to play..

for "story" though?

i'd recommend witcher 2 and dragon age origins, both definitely fun to get into and waste a weekend on, however if your looking for maybe a shooter or something with "story"

i'll say :

singularity and borderlands

borderlands is AMAZINGLY fun to do the campaign with friends in co op (not too bad by yourself either, but its basically a FPS dungeon loot crawler, so it's alot of fun with friends)

and singularity is definitely underrated...

 

[Ando85]

Damn you have a shitload of excellent games. So many are amazing, but I'd like to recommend Eternal Darkness. It is a really unique game. The sanity effects are interesting and it has an overall creepy vibe. Really loved that game.

 

[Sniper Team 4]

Uh...wow. I think you need to accept the fact that you are never going to be able to play all those games. Not unless you start devoting some SERIOUS time to gaming, and even then I think you won't make it.

I have to ask: Did you play Silent Hill and Silent Hill 2? If so, Silent Hill 3 would be my suggestion. After that, Half-Life games (assuming you played 2, in which case how have you NOT played the Episodes?) After that, I suggest Dragon Age: Origins and I hear Baldur's Gate 2 is supposed to be amazing. If you want a game that is so heavy on story that you will feel your brain being crushed under is convoluted weight, play Metal Gear Solid 4 as well. On that one though, know what you're getting into.
Good luck.

 

[StBishop]

Dragon Age: Origins. It's fucking good.

 

[SL33TBL1ND]

Vagrant Story is great. Plus I'd replace your Front Mission 4 with some Front Mission 3 goodness and do that.

 

[Wuggy]

The very first you complete is:

Dragon Age: Origins

After that, on the order you want to:

Dawn of War, Fallout 3, Torchlight, Wither 2, Half-Life 2: Episode One, Metal Gear Solid 4, LA Noire, Assassin's Creed 2

 

[StBishop]

Are we allowed to suggest more than one?

If so I add, Baldur's Gate 2 (didn't see one in there, I assume it's already finished, if not it comes first)
Icewind Dale 2 (same deal as baldur's gate)
Deus Ex
The Witcher 2 (Same thing, I assume the first one is already beaten)
Oni (Because It should only take 3 hours.)

that's it really. The rest I either don't have an opinion on either way, don't think are great for story, or haven't played.