Hardtofindaname said:
And to repeat what others have said, most of the concepts have already been taken, all types of FPS have been made, RTS is not original anymore, it's extremely hard to come up with something brand new nowadays.
Yeah, I used to think that as well and was convinced it was why no games were coming out that I enjoyed.
Then, when I saw new things come out, or at least old ideas that I really liked rehashed with ideas that I thought I'd never see happen. For example, L4D. A fun game. It's not unique in that it's a coop zombie survival game, but the versus play is unique in that you get to play as the zombies while playing against real people.
And it was fun. But it was just average.
Then, or around the same time, EndWar came out, that Tom Clancy RTS where you can use a mic to control everything. It worked pretty well. It was fun, but it was just average. It was a new idea as well.
It turns out that a lot of games being made now are just average. There are a few good games being made, one you listed, but the rest just look like how an average game should be and, indeed, are just average games.
This gen you have:
The rare bad game
The common average game
The rare good game
The even rarer gem
And it's not nostalgia either. I'm still playing these games instead of new ones.
There are a lot of us who feel this way. There's something missing from games now that make them really, really good.