What RPG should I Purchase?

Recommended Videos

DustyDrB

Made of ticky tacky
Jan 19, 2010
8,365
3
43
Hey, Pimppeter2...wait a minute...

Anyway, I'll list a few and a brief description. Beware: Lots of BioWare follows

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: It's an original Xbox (and PC) game, but it's a marvelous RPG. It has a great story (though it's slow at the start) and a leveling system that offers a good bit of variety. I love the sequel as well, but won't recommend it. It has some very annoying glitches when played on a 360. I can suffer through them, but I don't think most people would. There's also mods on the PC version that restore tons (and I really mean tons. It's enough to make an expansion pack on) of content.

Mass Effect (and Mass Effect 2): It's a third person shooter/RPG hybrid. It sort of struggles with its RPG elements (which are overabundant without providing any meaningful depth or choice in the first game, and much too sparse in the second game). But this is probably my favorite game series ever. Fantastic story, and an incredibly well-built setting. Decisions you make during the game carry over from one game to the next, offering you a ton of replayability.

Alpha Protocol: Yes, it was heavily criticized at launch, but patches have fixed some (not all) issues. Boss fights are kind of stupid (basically just normal people, but with lots of health. Though one is hilarious). But the game offers a lot of choice, both on how to build your character and in how you approach the story.

Two Worlds II: Not a great game, but it has a beautiful world. It has assy controls, bad voice acting, odd character animations, and a pretty boring story. But if you like to just explore, then I'd recommend it. It also has a co-op mode which some people speak highly about. I haven't tried it, myself.

Dragon Age: Origins (and the expansion: Awakening): It plays a good bit like Knights of the Old Republic, actually. The story is sort of "been there, done that", but the characters are great (Shale is worth getting, if you're not averse to DLC).

Dragon Age II: A somewhat controversial sequel. The combat is faster, though still tactical. Your character is now voiced. There are some head-shaking design choices (environments repeat a lot. Enemies come in waves). It's a more unique kind of story, but it falls flat in places. I still love it, but it takes as many steps back as it does steps forward from its predecessor.

Fable: Another original Xbox game. It's oozes charm, though. It's not the deepest game, and it came about at a time when morality in games was still "save the children or slow roast them and feed them to their parents", but its fun. The sequels I do not recommend. They're far to simplistic and don't really do anything well.

Jade Empire: A unique setting for a Western RPG: basically a fictionalized pre-medieval China. Pretty good story, great characters, passable (but shallow and spammy) combat.

Borderlands: I didn't like it, but tons of people do. And I think if you like Fallout 3, you're likely to enjoy Borderlands. It offers a lot of variety in terms of combat (lots of guns), and it has very MMO-esque quests (go here, kill that, come back and I'll reward you). Character interaction is shallow, so don't expect much there.

Onyx Oblivion said:
Gill Kaiser said:
CM156 said:
You don't have Dragon Age: Origins?

Fix that right away.

And Mass Effect is also a good choice.
Dragon Age isn't that great on the consoles. It's much better on the PC.

Therefore focus on Mass Effect, which is great on both platforms.
I'm sick of this.

It's worse on consoles, for sure.

But it's still damn great.

You can be almost as tactical as PC with the ring menu.

Consoles just lack "move to point"...making bottle-necking strategies useless as all hell.
I with you there. I've played it on both PC and the 360. The differences are small, and I prefer playing on my 360 just because that's where I feel more at home.
 

Tzekelkan

New member
Dec 27, 2009
498
0
0
Just yesterday I finished Mass Effect 2 with my Shepard from the first Mass Effect. It's my new favourite game. Consider this a strong recommendation.
 

thenamelessloser

New member
Jan 15, 2010
773
0
0
Dragon Age: Origins is probably the best traditional RPG to ever come out for consoles.

I really liked Alpha Protoocl as an RPG/action hybrid.

If they work on the 360 don't know if they do also get KOTOR, KOTOR II, and Jade Empire.
 

VanTesla

New member
Apr 19, 2011
481
0
0
Mass Effect 1 and 2. They are both way different in gameplay and story though. Why do people always say it's less a RPG... It's more RPG than most, it has actual roleplay in it! Dragon Age: Origins is great for the PC, great mods for long lasting play. Witcher 2 is great so far in my playthrough. Persona 4 for JRPG is my fave last gen console game.

Persona 4 has everything, story, great voice acting, great characters, comedy, mystery, you care about most characters and their outcomes. gameplay is decent with a guide for help, you can find a good guide on gamefaqs. Really love the game!
 

Nicolairigel

New member
May 6, 2011
134
0
0
Yes, everyone's saying, but Mass Effect 1 and 2 and Kotor 1 and 2. Both are unbelievably great games, and you will get completely immersed an realize you've been playing for 7 straight hours and it's now 4:00 am.
 

danintexas

New member
Jul 30, 2010
372
0
0
Been playing Divinity 2 - The Dragon Knight Saga this week.

So far about 10 hours in and I freakin love this under-rated game. Make sure you only get the Dragon knight saga version and not any other version.

So far the ONLY bad side is when you are talking to people. The characters close up are rather meh - but the voice acting makes up for it. Good story too so far. Have heard you can get over 100 hours out of the title
 

VanTesla

New member
Apr 19, 2011
481
0
0
Tzekelkan said:
Just yesterday I finished Mass Effect 2 with my Shepard from the first Mass Effect. It's my new favourite game. Consider this a strong recommendation.
Agree, make sure to play 1 then 2 for save content. Combat for the two are way different though. I liked both, but you may be turned off by one of them. Watch a few game vids that show combat first. Suggest 360 or PC, PS3 has no ME1.
 

VanTesla

New member
Apr 19, 2011
481
0
0
DustyDrB said:
Hey, Pimppeter2...wait a minute...

Anyway, I'll list a few and a brief description. Beware: Lots of BioWare follows

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: It's an original Xbox (and PC) game, but it's a marvelous RPG. It has a great story (though it's slow at the start) and a leveling system that offers a good bit of variety. I love the sequel as well, but won't recommend it. It has some very annoying glitches when played on a 360. I can suffer through them, but I don't think most people would. There's also mods on the PC version that restore tons (and I really mean tons. It's enough to make an expansion pack on) of content.

Mass Effect (and Mass Effect 2): It's a third person shooter/RPG hybrid. It sort of struggles with its RPG elements (which are overabundant without providing any meaningful depth or choice in the first game, and much too sparse in the second game). But this is probably my favorite game series ever. Fantastic story, and an incredibly well-built setting. Decisions you make during the game carry over from one game to the next, offering you a ton of replayability.

Alpha Protocol: Yes, it was heavily criticized at launch, but patches have fixed some (not all) issues. Boss fights are kind of stupid (basically just normal people, but with lots of health. Though one is hilarious). But the game offers a lot of choice, both on how to build your character and in how you approach the story.

Two Worlds II: Not a great game, but it has a beautiful world. It has assy controls, bad voice acting, odd character animations, and a pretty boring story. But if you like to just explore, then I'd recommend it. It also has a co-op mode which some people speak highly about. I haven't tried it, myself.

Dragon Age: Origins (and the expansion: Awakening): It plays a good bit like Knights of the Old Republic, actually. The story is sort of "been there, done that", but the characters are great (Shale is worth getting, if you're not averse to DLC).

Dragon Age II: A somewhat controversial sequel. The combat is faster, though still tactical. Your character is now voiced. There are some head-shaking design choices (environments repeat a lot. Enemies come in waves). It's a more unique kind of story, but it falls flat in places. I still love it, but it takes as many steps back as it does steps forward from its predecessor.

Fable: Another original Xbox game. It's oozes charm, though. It's not the deepest game, and it came about at a time when morality in games was still "save the children or slow roast them and feed them to their parents", but its fun. The sequels I do not recommend. They're far to simplistic and don't really do anything well.

Jade Empire: A unique setting for a Western RPG: basically a fictionalized pre-medieval China. Pretty good story, great characters, passable (but shallow and spammy) combat.

Borderlands: I didn't like it, but tons of people do. And I think if you like Fallout 3, you're likely to enjoy Borderlands. It offers a lot of variety in terms of combat (lots of guns), and it has very MMO-esque quests (go here, kill that, come back and I'll reward you). Character interaction is shallow, so don't expect much there.

Onyx Oblivion said:
Gill Kaiser said:
CM156 said:
You don't have Dragon Age: Origins?

Fix that right away.

And Mass Effect is also a good choice.
Dragon Age isn't that great on the consoles. It's much better on the PC.

Therefore focus on Mass Effect, which is great on both platforms.
I'm sick of this.

It's worse on consoles, for sure.

But it's still damn great.

You can be almost as tactical as PC with the ring menu.

Consoles just lack "move to point"...making bottle-necking strategies useless as all hell.
I with you there. I've played it on both PC and the 360. The differences are small, and I prefer playing on my 360 just because that's where I feel more at home.
One major thing you forget is fixing game bugs through mods on the PC. Dev's never completed some major dialogue and ending fixes, that mods from players fixed.
 

DustyDrB

Made of ticky tacky
Jan 19, 2010
8,365
3
43
thenamelessloser said:
Dragon Age: Origins is probably the best traditional RPG to ever come out for consoles.

I really liked Alpha Protoocl as an RPG/action hybrid.

If they work on the 360 don't know if they do also get KOTOR, KOTOR II, and Jade Empire.
KotOR works. KotOR II does too, but it's got some bad problems. While playing it, I experience an audio glitch about every two to five minutes. It sounds like TV static (the really loud and obnoxious kind). It happened at those intervals from start to finish. I Googled it and it seems like its a pretty common problem. There's also some massive frame-rate drops.

I got used to the audio glitch somehow. I don't know how many other people would sit through it though, especially when the game is old enough to run on pretty much any computer with the benefit of mods that restore content. I've got a Mac, so no option for that here.
 

RA92

New member
Jan 1, 2011
3,079
0
0
If it hasn't already gotten through you yet, Mass Effect.

Also, play with FemShep. Easier on the eye with the terrible facial animation, not to mention better voice acting if you're going renegade.
 

DustyDrB

Made of ticky tacky
Jan 19, 2010
8,365
3
43
VanTesla said:
One major thing you forget is fixing game bugs through mods on the PC. Dev's never completed some major dialogue and ending fixes, that mods from players fixed.
Which game are you talking about. I assume its either KotOR II or Dragon Age (though I'm not aware of problems with dialogue or the ending). I know about the Restoration Mod for KotOR II, but the OP says he has a 360. I'd be surprised if his PC can't run the game, but I'm still going on what he said.
 

thenamelessloser

New member
Jan 15, 2010
773
0
0
DustyDrB said:
thenamelessloser said:
Dragon Age: Origins is probably the best traditional RPG to ever come out for consoles.

I really liked Alpha Protoocl as an RPG/action hybrid.

If they work on the 360 don't know if they do also get KOTOR, KOTOR II, and Jade Empire.
KotOR works. KotOR II does too, but it's got some bad problems. While playing it, I experience an audio glitch about every two to five minutes. It sounds like TV static (the really loud and obnoxious kind). It happened at those intervals from start to finish. I Googled it and it seems like its a pretty common problem. There's also some massive frame-rate drops.

I got used to the audio glitch somehow. I don't know how many other people would sit through it though, especially when the game is old enough to run on pretty much any computer with the benefit of mods that restore content. I've got a Mac, so no option for that here.
Luckily I still have my regular xbox =D. I would have also reccomended Deus Ex Invisible War (I think iti si a great game it just isn't as good as the first one but I heard it doesn't work on the 360)
 

Dr Snakeman

New member
Apr 2, 2010
1,611
0
0
Well, I'll just reiterate what everyone else has been saying:

Mass Effect, Mass Effect, Mass Effect, Mass Effect.

Both of them. Get the DLC, too. You will not be disappointed.
 

VanTesla

New member
Apr 19, 2011
481
0
0
DustyDrB said:
VanTesla said:
One major thing you forget is fixing game bugs through mods on the PC. Dev's never completed some major dialogue and ending fixes, that mods from players fixed.
Which game are you talking about. I assume its either KotOR II or Dragon Age (though I'm not aware of problems with dialogue or the ending). I know about the Restoration Mod for KotOR II, but the OP says he has a 360. I'd be surprised if his PC can't run the game, but I'm still going on what he said.
Dragon Age: Origins. If you go to Dragon Age Nexus (mod site) you will see what the devs left unfinished or bugged. Have to do a bit of searching on the site though...
 

neo34

New member
Mar 11, 2009
56
0
0
I know it's not for the 360, but if you haven't played Chrono Trigger yet you should. Either play the original or the DS one, pretty sure they're exactly the same, and it's an amazing game. One of the best RPGs ever in my opinion. (It's kind of a JRPG, but I could handle it and I hate JRPGs, so you'd probably like it)
 

Dr. wonderful

New member
Dec 31, 2009
3,260
0
0
Soviet Heavy said:
Go retro and pick up a couple of Xbox 1 games. Knights of the Old Republic, Fable the Lost Chapters, there is a bunch of good RPGs that you can still play.

But avoid KOTOR2 on consoles. It is only worth playing if you have the pc version with the restoration mod.
Fable: TLC I thought was PC only.

Anyway, Go with this guy list, he cleary thinking with portals.
 

VanTesla

New member
Apr 19, 2011
481
0
0
Both Mass Effect games are under 20 dollars as well (new). I suggest buying new to support sales for Bioware. Don't get Dragon Age 2 though, it stinks like a bad burrito...

Also if you have a PS2 still or a older PS3 I truly recommend Persona 4. I truly suggest buying a copy by going to the game site and clicking to amazon.com (then funds go to atlus), cheaper than a used copy from gamestop.