I reckon I'd go for something like subtle, like preternatural speed (faster than any normal man, but still within the limits of physics. Say, being able to keep up with Usain Bolt without training), scientific intuition (just being really good at inventing stuff), or the ability to play music that influences peoples minds (not quite mind control, but like super-influential music)
Just stuff that would be really cool and useful to have, but wouldn't single you out as a god or a freak. Dunno about you, but I like being able to relate to normal people. Freakdom and godhood are equally lonely...